Olcott Lobster Company
$$ •About Olcott Lobster Company
Customers' Favorites
House Made Chips with Old Bay Dusting
Popeye Chicken Sandwich
Lobster Roll Flight
Olcott Lobster Company Reviews
109 ratings
Share your opinion about Olcott Lobster Company
Quick, friendly service and an absolutely fantastic lobster roll! It was fresh, delicious, and loaded with lobster. I also really appreciated how mindful and accommodating they were of my lemon allergy—it made me feel very comfortable ordering and enjoying my meal.
Great food and wonderful service. Highly recommend!
Great food and wonderful service. Highly recommend!
Known for lobster roll and shrimp.
Usually a wait in line on weekends.
Outdoor summer tables only .
Usually a wait in line on weekends.
Outdoor summer tables only .
Great food , fast service
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | Closed |
| Friday | 12 - 7PM |
| Saturday | 12 - 7PM |
| Sunday | 12 - 7PM |
Olcott Lobster Company is a popular seafood spot known for its fresh and delicious lobster. Customers praise the lobster rolls as being the best in the area, with large chunks of lobster served with melted butter instead of mayo, unlike other places. The restaurant offers a variety of tasty options, including fried shrimp, lobster BLT, Hawaiian Cole slaw, and Old Bay chips, all of which receive high praise. Visitors enjoy the welcoming atmosphere, friendly staff, and great service, making it a favorite for repeat visits. The outdoor patio provides a nice setting to enjoy the food, and the place can get busy, so lines are common. Many guests have celebrated special occasions there, noting the staff's helpfulness and the inviting vibe. Catering services and party displays have also impressed customers, with some calling the lobster rolls the best they’ve ever had. Overall, Olcott Lobster Company is a thriving addition to Niagara County, bringing fresh seafood and lively energy to the waterfront.