Golden Guernsey Ice Cream

15 Main St, Oneonta
(607) 432-7209

Recent Reviews

Sort by
CARL FUTENMA

Really good flavors and nice people.

Jonna Michaels

Wait so long almost left. My turkey wrap was bland and soggy. The waffle fries were okay

MANIC BARRAGE

Ice cream is very affordable, taste great and the owner has been around along time, great service.

Steven Weygand

Great place to get very good ice cream

Charles Volante

Great variety of flavors. Ice cream was cold and sweet. You can order outside or inside amd sit at a table. They have food too. Employees are all very nice.

Beverly Murch

Family, fun and yummy atmosphere.

jessica griffiths

Great custard!

Olivia Mitchell

Pumpkin custard was top tier!

Vincent Fayad

Great place to go and have some great ice cream!

Andrew Kata

πŸ¦πŸ˜‹

C S

Get the cannoli ice cream!

Timothy Burgin

Good food decent price

Linda M

Charming ice cream shop with old timey ambiance. We stopped because of east on/off on I-88. They use Perry’s Ice Cream, which is just OK ice cream. The flavor variety was disappointing. We shared a large and wanted 3 balance flavors - vanilla based, chocolate based and a special flavor. Out of 37 listed flavors, only 3 are chocolate based. The only one we considered (don’t like raspberry or mint) was the dregs at the bottom, which we did not want (we asked if they pull out a new bucket - they declined; most places would scrap that out & put it at the top of a new bucket). There are lots of other interesting flavors though, many fruit or nut based. Portion size, average (not generous).
Pro-tip, share a large ($5.50, 3 scoops ) and you can get 3 different flavors for 3 people to try (instead of 3 small @$4 = $12) - I especially like the group decision making & sharing (ice cream & subsequent critique) - it’s a bonding experience.
Jul 2025

Jason Lindroth

So after you left the park we hung out up there a little bit longer tell Galaxy started showing signs of overheating then we went down to Golden Guernsey which was a disappointment compared to how it had been years prior. I mean yeah for a pup cup a milkshake a small cotton candy ice cream and med ice cream with sprinkles may have only cost a little over 20 bucks but they don't have the flavor that they used to and the customer service could use some touching up they treat the people at the drive-thru part as more of a hindrance and don't pay attention to the details versus when you go inside.. alone the ice cream flavors are basically generic with a few additives but mainly you could get all the flavors right there at Hannaford and Walmart . All in all I guess it's a good place to quickly go and grab something if you really don't care about the true flavors at this point they greatly have lost what they used to be except for a quick cheap fix.

Hani S

Nice place with friendly staff. But the ice creams are too sweet.

Loading...

Golden Guernsey Ice Cream

15 Main St, Oneonta, NY 13820
(607) 432-7209