15 Best Pizza Restaurants near Oriskany Falls

“Happened to run into this pizzeria while traveling and decided to stop in to grab a slice to go. I had a buffalo chicken slice as well as a pepperoni slice, thin crust and absolutely delicious. My boyfriend got a slice of chicken Parm and he just raved about it. He's not a huge fan of thin pizza but really enjoyed the crust. Soft and chewy. Didn't spend time looking over menu but I certainly can vouch for their pizza. Prices were normal for today's pizzerias.“

“We’ve had Pizza’s from all over the Utica area. I’ll say that we are fortunate to have many good Pizza places to choose from.New York Pizzeria is hands down the best. Their entire family welcomes you every time tou go there. Simply fabulous!!!“

“The food for my sons graduation party was delicious and plentiful! Many of our guests commented on how delicious it was and asked where this was. The only problem we had was the packaging. I would recommend cardboard boxes to transport as the half pans of baked beans leaked all over.“

“Kinda disappointed with this pizza we ordered last time with my small team at work. I wish it has more cheese. The sauce on the pizza was okay but I wish it has more flavor. But not giving up on this because a friend recommended other dishes on the menu that she guarantees are tasty!“

“It was the best of pizzas. It was the worst of pizzas. Two pizzas were ordered; a NY style large meatball and a plain upside down pie. The NY pie was not very good. The crust was so thin, there was no chew. All crisp and no chew. No layer between the crispy bottom and the wet, saucy side. Cracked and crumbled when folded. The ratio of crust to cheese to sauce was off. Baked on a screen. WAY too much gooey, non-snapping cheese. The outer crust had no chew to it and was too airy and light. Sauce was on point and meatballs were excellent. And, 16" isn't really a large in a REAL NY pizzeria. 18" is the NY standard. Then came the big save; the upside down or Utica pie. It was truly excellent. Probably pretty much the same ingredients as their NY style pizza, but WAY better in a different form. I ate it hot. I ate it at room temperature. Each bite was a flavorgasm. So, skip their NY style pie which is mediocre at best and order something memorable.“

“I ordered the Chicken Parmesan dinner, and it was excellent!!! The chicken was HUGE, and tasted great! I couldn't eat it all! There was plenty of spaghetti and sauce with the chicken!!! WELL worth the money!! If you order Giovanni's chicken Parm dinner...I guarantee you'll love it!! Thank you Giovanni's!“

“Small area to dine in. Most take their food to go and pickup. Plenty of parking. Fantastic place to get quality meats, deli meats, cheese, jerky, spices. Lots of good stuff in a small place! Staff are always nice and they keep it stocked and clean.“

“Stopped by this local spot near Hamilton College in upstate ny. Bought two slices and a bottle of soda for less than $9. The slices were surprisingly thiccccc... lol not that $1 slice in the city type. Bit sbarro thiccccc lol. "IYKYK" Service was great, saw sone college kids working the counter. Overall the quality of the slices were 7.5/10 #iSupportSmallBusinesses“

“It's my goal to try out all the pizza places in Central NY. Oliveri's is a stand out - friendly staff and a warm little cozy place probably does a lot of business in takeout. They do a good crust here - crispy thinner crust is key. Sauce and cheese are decent too. I will return. Prices are the fairest I have seen in the area.“

“Alteri’s is family owned and you can feel the warmth dining there. Staff are friendly and the food made with love! They have some uniquely delicious sandwiches like The Mort and Roman is tasty too! The Big Salad and the Cheesy Bread should start every meal!“

“Great wings with just the right amount of crisp, not soggy and chewy, and not fried to a crisp - just right and medium of delicious, even for the spice wimps like me. Slight kick, but not enough to break a sweat. The pizza is pretty good, too! I ordered two days in a row, and the second day, I asked for it to be left in for an extra 2-3min and it was PERFECT! Crispy bottom that stood straight out, and gooey cheese oozing all over. It was like a taste of home made by friendly, hard-working people.“

“Fish fry us possibly the best I'm rhe area. Calzones are amazing. Salads awesome. Price is okay but for takeout should be less than set down meal. Fish fry should come with a garlic knots. I will be trying more would be nice if they did shrimp dinner and chicken Cesar wraps.​“

“We went to this Pizza Hut cuz the one in Rome had the dining room closed. Explained to Sean about our gluten-free cheese sticks made from a gluten-free pizza crust with cheese and the seasonings. He accepted the challenge and came out victorious. The cheese sticks were perfect, nice and crisp and our pizzas were perfect too just the way we ordered them. Thank you, SeanDietary restrictions: Gluten free“

“Had the Italian sub and it was just a basic sandwich. Bread was too big for my liking. Seemed like most people order takeout. They seemed surprised that we walked in and were going to order. Only have one kind of diet drink as well. It's just ok.“

“Made an 1 45 minute drive to give them a try because we were told it was a great place. We were not steered wrong! We had 8 people in our party and not a single one of us had a complaint! All our food was delicious (we went for Sunday brunch). They have a beer for everyone and the atmosphere is awesome!“