Restaurants in Peekskill

“Great service, great cocktails, great food, great desserts. You can’t go wrong. Cant wait to come back.”

“I recently discovered Benny's and a bit depressed I was late to the game. A great sandwich shop. To date I have had the Chilii Turkey, Thai Fried Chicken, and the Chimi Chimi Roast Beef. All are excellent. The Thai Fried Chicken would be best when you can sit down and enjoy it. Cool chip selection and beverages. Counter folks are super friendly as well. Sandwiches are like $15 but are built to share. Great place I will frequently visit now.”

“Hidden gem!! Food, staff, music fabulous.”

“Our favorite local Indian restaurant! The flavors are authentic, delicious, and always incredibly satisfying. Every dish we’ve tried has been packed with spice, freshness, and care. If you’re looking for amazing Indian food in the area, this is the place to go.”

“Best bangers and mash I’ve ever had, great beer selection, and the workers were friendly and great conversationalists! Strongly recommend! ☘️”

“Noticed the truck over by bear mountain and decided to stop for an empanada! I was pleasantly surprised!! The tequila quesadilla AND the empanada were ON POINT!! The line aioli sauce was so delicious I wish I asked for extra! The empanadas were cooked perfectly!!! Definitely recommend 5 out of 5!!”

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️🌟🌟🌟⭐️⭐️ Peekskill Public is the BEST! Dana makes happy hour fun and lively, Henry is always welcoming, and Samantha—she deserves 10 stars! Attentive, friendly, and unforgettable, she makes every visit amazing. Delicious bar pizza, unbeatable drinks, and the best crowd in town—don’t miss it!”

“Great atmosphere! Owners Drew & Ted are passionate about their restaurant, art gallery, jazz club and so am I!”

“My friend and I were really hungry after a long hike and were looking for a simple place with quality and affordable food. This restaurant was exactly what we were looking for. The servers were very friendly, the food was delicious and inexpensive. Just a heads up, they don't have a liquor license. Definitely give this place a try!”

“Always great food and employees”

“Wonderful food and staff. Our favorite restaurant by far!!”

“This place is the Bomb! Went there today to have a smoothie with my friend! We had a ball, Rob was wonderful, great smoothie, great service, great conversation! We will be back soon Rob to see how you made out! Very nice to meet you! :) definitely go and treat yourself to a smoothie!”

“My favorite dish is the camarones apanado( breaded shrimp) and their seafood rice. their food is super flavorful and you can tell they cook with love. I highly recommended visiting La Cabana.”

“The best and most authentic Mexican food there is. Their carnitas and carne asada are so flavorful and juicy. Everything they serve is amazingly delicious. My go-to food for comfort. It’s a diamond in the rough! We love it!! DELICIOUS!”

“Wonderful food and great service!”

“A gem of a place that we fell upon by happenstance. So glad we did. My mother loved the baked goods - they had just come out of the oven. Delicious and friendly service.”

“Had a wonderful time at a great local eatery!”

“Great customer service & yummy baked goods!”

“I have been going here for years. I wanted to make sure I told everyone this is possibly one of the best places to get a meal and feel like you belong. The food is a classic American Diner but the food, Atmosphere and staff make you feel like your home. Some diners almost rush you out. Here they let you enjoy your food. Take a moment and get a burger or an omelette. You will not be sorry.”

“Ordered online.
Delicious pizza,and side appetizers.
They called to confirm the order and it was amazing.
Driver was courteous, and polite.
Received ahead of expectation, fresh out of the oven. Can't ask for better than that! Highly recommend.”

“Me encanta la atención que brindan y lo mejor es la calidad de su comida recomiendo las tortillas de harina y los churrascos son los mejores me hacen sentir que estoy en mi país cuando llego ♥️👍”

“We had pistachio and coconut from the large variety of selections available. This is handmade in the store stuff. Off the charts delicious.
Lovely propietor and assistant doing it old school. Hardest part is knowing which flavors to choose.
Thanks!”

“After going to Bear Mt zoo we were hungry and decided to stop at Tiffany’s Cafe. The service was impeccable and the food was delicious! We all got something different and we all cleaned our plates clean! When we come back to the area again for hiking we would definitely stop by here again.”

“Margaritas…Wednesday, be there or be squared.”

“The best pasta I ever had. All the selections are great. My favorite are the raviolis and tortellini!!”

“Sweet Frog team is welcoming, always keeping everything clean. The pricing is affordable and best of all the fro-yo and toppings are yummy.
Go here on with my kids all the time.”

“Outstanding food and staff”

“We ended up here for pizza before a show at the Paramount, Owner & his staff were incredibly gracious, Pizza was awesome, great variety of oversized slices readily available & reasonably priced!
Don’t miss this great spot !!
eat here before the shows!!”

“Was visiting our son at West Point and wanted a good local pub to watch football. Kelly’s was it. Great staff, food, drinks and so much more. Casual easy atmosphere and plenty of TV’s to watch your game.”

“Awesome food and great service, would definitely return again!”

“I was on and out of town visit when I dropped by the store. The sandwich I usually get consists of vegetables only: spinach, cucumber, tomatoes, olives and banana peppers. Many stores act as if the spinach is just a topping rather than the base of the sandwich. This shop made the sandwich nicely. I had no complaints. They staff was also very patient while I signed into the subway app as I had forgotten my password and it took more time than usual. Overall, it was a very pleasant experience.”

“Exelente comida recomendado....!”

“Stumbled in on accident. Grabbed some food and it was amazing ended up ordering more! I’m a customer for life. Authentic Hispanic food made to order but not a long wait time”

“The food is great! In comparison to a lot of Ecuadorean restaurants in the area you get a lot for what you paid for. Definitely recommend coming here the servers are always really nice too.”

“We Veterans had a great meal on 5/24/17. The food and the company were great. The Elks have always held us Veterans in high esteem. My Dad was Exalted Ruler at the old White Plains Lodge as well as a Trustee and I am a Life Memeber. When I was in the VA hospital, we always looked forward to the parties they put on. Peekskill NY deserves a big round applause. Thank you”

“These guys and gals are the best. Trailer hitch broke and they were awesome enough to let us leave it until we could get it towed. Thank you from a grateful Indianapolis couple!!!”

“the chicken rice and salad is very good and filling”

“always always happy with their BEC sandwiches. they only have a *tiny* amount of room for dining in, so it’s mostly/mainly a take-out/pick-up spot. food is always delicious though. if you commute or have a train trip or whatever then it makes way more sense to get food from here vs. the other nearby options (there’s a whole entire restaurant/bar at the actual old Peekskill station, but its a lil ‘foo-foo’. THIS spot which is right across the street has much better/more food options).their menu prices are very reasonable, and the food quality makes it totally worth it.”

“The best tea room I ever had the pleasure of staying in. I highly recommend this place when dining with family during the holidays or whatever you have the free time to drink their wonderful tea flavors or a variety of food.”

“I have been coming to this store/deli for about 5 years or so. Not really sure but for a long time. Their service is great, nice people. A couple times they messed up my sandwhich and didn’t put tomato but out of all the other times from ordering, I must say they make the best sandwiches made in the City of Peekskill! Good prices and fresh bread. I highly recommend.😊💯👌👏”

“Came here for a late lunch and left completely stuffed. The picanha was very tender, with the perfect amount of fat. The roasted pineapple was a highlight. The drinks were awesome. I'm coming back as soon as bear mountain bridge reopens.”

“First time trying ramen that is not the instant Maruchan kind. Now I see what the hype is all about... delicious ramen, excelent portions, staff were so attentive and the decor is so cute and cozy. Will definitely come back 😋🫶🏼”

“Love love love!!! Food is amazing, drinks are fantastic and a great staff!!”

“Succulent oxtails - unfortunately couldn't taste any habanero and they were super mild but the overall flavor & texture made up for the lack of spiciness. Rice & peas + the stewed cabbage were also cooked well and tasty. Large portion will easily feed two people for a reasonable price. The older gentleman was lovely and provided great customer service. Really want to try the jerk pork next time!”

“This place is really great for an impossibly cheap and delicious meal. It’s half market, half eatery. My wife is from Peru and got to experience Ecuadorian food for the first time here and she loved it. I’ve been to Ecuador before and I can say that this is pretty delicious and authentic food. Definitely check this place out when in Peekskill.”

“This is as traditional as traditional can get for Guatemalan food. This restaurant offers authentic food and even the way it’s laid out is just like in my country. Please do not come here expecting service or vibes like American restaurants. This is a homey authentic and relaxed environment. If you’re looking for clean delicious flavor this is it.”

“Dale k no fuimos hasta abajo uuuuu this s crazy but cool uuuhh yeah”

“My daughter celebrated her wedding at the Abbey and was great.”

“Girl in the red shirt and glasses was super nice! The food was delicious and not too salty or too sweet. The place was clean and comforting. Definitely would recommend to anyone in the area or stopping by for a bite to eat.

The food reminded us of home and was really great for the price!♡”

“Better than average brunch especially for a pub. Loved the pie shaped hashbrowns and the corn beef hash. Solid mimosas. Knowledgeable bar tender who called out the highlights in their beer selection. It's a little divey, but that's part of the charm. Need to stop in when the weather is warmer. Soldi option for Peekskill.”

“The last time I dined here was in 2021, a dinner for two with just my husband. Last night, I had my two young daughters and mother join us. We cannot say enough how delicious, savory and affordable their food & drinks are. We also ate breakfast there this morning and was equally impressed by the food and staff.”

“That’s great place and delicious food !!???”

“The reviews leave you thinking, you will either love it or hate it. 8 guys cooking and 2 women picking up no stop ringing phone orders. Got my shrimp egg fu young and went to hotel room.
Was hot and smelled great. Mixed it all together and it came up short. It was so-so. Definitely filled the belly. YMMV”

“Fantastic food!”

“our wedding cake was from here and the whole process was super smooth and easy! the samples were delicious and we had a tough time choosing our cake. we got a beautiful tiered cake and it was so tasty! the bakery was very communicative and professional, as well.”

“We loved this grocery store, especially the massive deli selections. We love the halal food & roast, beef sandwich & fresh vegetables The cashier registers were very sweet and nice! Thank you! 😊”

“This is a regular stop for me whenever I'm in Peekskill on business. They finally brought back French crullers. We had been missing them for a while. I wish they had continued the $1 donut with a medium or larger coffee promotion.”

“Good food, convenient location. Counter staff needs to seriously improve their listening skills! Ordering and paying was a particularly frustrating experience.”

“It’s was freezing stopped in and had a amazing pick me up well over due”

“It was awesome and enough for two people. Great service.”

“Early dinner Thursday. Nice ambience. High-backed booth felt private. Nice ambience. Exceptionally friendly waiter. Couldn't be nicer. Enjoyed fresh salad, flavorful pizza, sautéed spinach and cold IPA. Perfect for us.”