Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria
2160 Penfield Rd, Penfield
(585) 586-2555
Customers' Favorites
Large Pizza with Mozzarella Cheddar Green Peppers Sausage Meatball Onions
Sausage Green Peppers Onions Cheddar Mozzarella
Philly Steak Sub with Green Peppers and Onions
Pepperoni Slices Well Done as Requested
Meatball Sub Extra Sauce Mozzarella
Country Sweet Chicken Wings
Stuffed Shells with Butter
Large Italian Sub
Beef Pepperoni
Giant Calzone
Appetizers
FRESH CUT FRIES
1lb Grade A Idaho potatoes with 1 cup of Heinz Ketchup. Add some Salvie Plate hot sauce.Cals: 1424/order
ONION RINGS
1/2lb Thin sliced & lightly battered with 1 cup of Heinz Ketchup. Amazing!Cals: 750/order
10 PIECE MOZZARELLA STICKS
10pc sliced real mozzarella, battered & fried with choice of sauce -- 2oz cup. Kid's favorite!Cals: 900/order
4 PIECE PIZZA LOGS
4pc Italian egg rolls filled with pizza sauce, mozzarella & pepperoni w/ choice of sauce -- 2oz cupCals: 700/order
LOADED FRIES
Our fresh cut fries covered with chili, bacon & cheddarCals: 1779/order
5 PIECE MOZZARELLA STICKS
5pc sliced real mozzarella, battered & fried with choice of sauce -- 2oz cup. Kid's favorite!Cals: 450/order
2 PIECE PIZZA LOGS
2pc Italian egg rolls filled with pizza sauce, mozzarella & pepperoni with choice of sauce -- 2oz cupCals: 350/order
PIZZA FRIES
With pizza sauce & mozzarella
BUFFALO CALAMARI
Our famous calamari covered with mild wing sauceCals: 1410/order
SICILIAN CALAMARI
Our fried calamari tossed with asiago cheese, kalamata olives, banana peppers, roasted red peppers, and Italian dressingCals: 2041/order
FRIED MUSHROOMS
1/2lb Our most popular fried veggie with choice of sauce -- 2oz cup. Mr. Porta Bella's favorite.Cals: 500/order
GARLIC BREAD with MOZZARELLA
A loaf of our large bread with olive oil, butter, garlic, melted mozzarella. A family favorite.Cals: 880/order
FRIED CALAMARI
Everyone's favorite Italian appetizer with a fresh lemon and choice of sauceCals: 1309/order
SAUSAGE SLINGERS
Our famous giant Italian Sausage chunks deep fried and covered with your favorite wing sauce. Served with blue cheese. Italian sausage wings!Cals: 1050/order
HOME FRIES
Generous portion of home fries, served with ketchupCals: 1477/order
10pc SHRIMP APPETIZER
Tossed in your choice of sauce
10pc SALVIE STICKS
10pc sliced real mozzarella, battered & fried, then tossed in your favorite wing sauceCals: 900/order
5pc SALVIE STICKS
5pc sliced real mozzarella, battered & fried, then tossed in your favorite wing sauceCals: 450/order
SALVIE FRIES
1lb Grade A Idaho potatoes tossed in your favorite wing sauceCals: 1424/order
4pc SALVIE LOGS
4pc Italian egg rolls filled with pizza sauce, mozzarella, and pepperoni; tossed in your favorite wing sauceCals: 700/order
2pc SALVIE LOGS
4pc Italian egg rolls filled with pizza sauce, mozzarella, and pepperoni; tossed in your favorite wing sauceCals: 350/order
Superslice
SUPERSLICE with MOZZARELLA & PEPPERONI
768 cals/slice
SUPERSLICE with DOUBLE MOZZARELLA
Cals: 752/slice
PIZZA KIT
Fun kid friendly pizza kit comes with medium dough, sauce, mozzarella and 1 topping of your choice included; extra toppings charge (product arrives raw with baking instructions)Cals: 1669/whole kit
SUPERSLICE COMBO
1/4 OF A LARGE PIZZA Double Mozzarella or Mozzarella & Pepperoni with 20oz Soda & Bag of Chips or Cookie
GARLIC KNOT
BYO Pizzas & Calzones
GIANT CALZONE
With lots of mozzarella and choice of 2 toppings. (Additional toppings extra)1371 Cals/order
LARGE PIZZA
16 square slices with lots of mozzarella160 cals/slice
MEDIUM PIZZA
8 pie cut slices with lots of mozzarella170 cals/slice
12" GLUTEN FREE
Thin gluten free crust121 cals/slice
12" CAULIFLOWER
Keto-friendly cauliflower crust870 cals/pizza
12" THIN THIN
Mozzarella cheese & your choice of 1 topping480 cals/pizza
SHEET PIZZA
32 party-slice slices with lots of mozzarella160 cals/slice
BUILD YOUR OWN BOWL
The ultimate carb free, keto pizza with NO DOUGH. Your choice of three toppings
19" NY STYLE
8 pie-cut slices with lots of mozzarella350 cals/slice
Specialty Pizzas
THE SALVATORE PIZZA
A tomato base sauce, lots of mozzarella, pepperoni, mushrooms & Italian sausage
CHICKEN CHARLIE with COUNTRY SWEET
Blue cheese base, Country Sweet Sauce with diced chicken fingers & lots of mozzarella.
FRED'S MEAT MARKET PIZZA
A tomato sauce base, lots of mozzarella, pepperoni, italian sausage, meatballs & bacon
BREAKFAST PIZZA with MEAT
Mozzarella, cheddar, eggs, Italian sausage, bacon & ham
SALVATORE'S SUPREME PIZZA
With lots of mozzarella, pepperoni, mushrooms, Italian sausage, olives, diced green peppers & onions
THE TACO PIZZA SINCE 1978
Salsa sauce base, onions, seasoned hamburger beef, lettuce, sliced tomato & lots of cheddar cheese
MAMA TONI'S PLATE PIZZA
Salvie plate hot meat sauce, hamburger, home fries, diced onions, mac salad covered with cheddar cheese
CHICKEN CHARLIE with MILD SAUCE
Blue cheese base, Mild Wing Sauce with diced chicken fingers & lots of mozzarella.270 cals/slice
LINDA DA' VEGGIE PIZZA
A tomato sauce base, lots of mozzarella, diced green peppers & onions, mushrooms & olives
THE BREATH MINT GARLIC PIZZA
Our garlic pizza with virgin olive oil, garlic, diced onions, sliced tomatoes, lots of mozzarella and your choice of 1 additional topping
STEAK BOOMBA with COUNTRY SWEET SAUCE
A Country sweet base, steak, peppers, onions, & mozzarella
CHICKEN BACON RANCH PIZZA
Ranch base, grilled chicken, bacon, cheddar & mozzarella
BREAKFAST PIZZA with VEGGIES
Mozzarella, cheddar, eggs, mushrooms, onions, peppers
ALFREDO, NOT MY BROTHER PIZZA
Alfredo sauce base, artichokes, roasted red peppers, olives, sliced grilled chicken & asiago cheese
SOCCER SAM'S LOW FAT PIZZA
tomato sauce (no mozzarella), diced green peppers & onions
UNCLE RICO'S BBQ CHICKEN PIZZA
BBQ base sauce with sliced grilled chicken, roasted red peppers and onions covered with cheddar cheese
FISH FRY PIZZA
Tartar sauce base with battered deep-fried haddock, home fries & cheddar cheese on top that gets baked in the oven, then we top it with lettuce, tomatoes & a drizzle of honey mustard
VEGAN with VEGAN CHEESE
Choice of Oil & Garlic or Vegan Red Sauce base with vegan cheese
VEGAN NO VEGAN CHEESE
Choice of Oil & Garlic or Vegan Red Sauce base no vegan cheese
LOVE HOLLY PIZZA
Garlic & oil base, mozzarella, artichokes, roasted red peppers, and banana peppers
COUSIN PAM'S NONNA PIZZA
Extra sauce & parmesan cheese (no mozzarella)
GIACOMO'S BIG JACK
Sesame Seed Crust, 1000 island base with a Mozzarella & Cheddar blend, topped with chopped burger, lettuce, tomato and Pickle chips and a 1000 Island swirl on topAllergy Notice: This pizza features sesame seeds on crust
STEAK BOOMBA COUNTRY SWEET
A Country sweet base, steak, peppers, onions, & mozzarella
PIZZA OF THE MONTH
SLICE WING IT!
Tomato Sauce Base with lots of Mozzarella & Old Fashioned Pepperoni and topped with dollops of Buffalo Chicken Wing Dip. Served with Fritos on the side to sprinkle on top or to dip!
MEDIUM WING IT!
Tomato Sauce Base with lots of Mozzarella & Old Fashioned Pepperoni and topped with dollops of Buffalo Chicken Wing Dip. Served with Fritos on the side to sprinkle on top or to dip!
LARGE WING IT!
Tomato Sauce Base with lots of Mozzarella & Old Fashioned Pepperoni and topped with dollops of Buffalo Chicken Wing Dip. Served with Fritos on the side to sprinkle on top or to dip!
MANHATTAN 19" WING IT!
Tomato Sauce Base with lots of Mozzarella & Old Fashioned Pepperoni and topped with dollops of Buffalo Chicken Wing Dip. Served with Fritos on the side to sprinkle on top or to dip!
SHEET WING IT!
Tomato Sauce Base with lots of Mozzarella & Old Fashioned Pepperoni and topped with dollops of Buffalo Chicken Wing Dip. Served with Fritos on the side to sprinkle on top or to dip!
Pizza Bowls
THE SALVATORE PIZZA BOWL
A tomato base sauce, lots of mozzarella, pepperoni, mushrooms & Italian sausage
LINDA DA' VEGGIE PIZZA BOWL
A tomato sauce base, lots of mozzarella, diced green peppers & onions, mushrooms & olives
CHICKEN CHARLIE PIZZA BOWL
A bleu cheese base sauce with your choice of buffalo mild wing sauce or sweet country, sliced chicken fingers & lots of mozzarella
THE BREATH MINT GARLIC PIZZA BOWL
Our garlic pizza with virgin olive oil, garlic, diced onions, sliced tomatoes, lots of mozzarella and your choice of 1 additional topping
FRED'S MEAT MARKET PIZZA BOWL
A tomato sauce base, lots of mozzarella, pepperoni, italian sausage, meatballs & bacon
STEAK BOOMBA PIZZA BOWL
Your choice of tomato sauce or sweet country base, sirloin steak, grilled peppers & onions, covered with lots of mozzarella
RANCH PIZZA BOWL
Ranch base, grilled chicken, bacon, cheddar & mozzarella
BREAKFAST PIZZA BOWL with MEAT
Mozzarella, cheddar, eggs, Italian sausage, bacon & ham
BREAKFAST PIZZA BOWL with VEGGIES
Mozzarella, cheddar, eggs, mushrooms, onions, peppers
ALFREDO NOT MY BROTHER PIZZA BOWL
Alfredo sauce base, artichokes, roasted red peppers, olives, sliced grilled chicken & asiago cheese
SOCCER SAM'S LOW FAT PIZZA BOWL
Tomato sauce (no mozzarella), diced green peppers & onions
SUPREME PIZZA BOWL
With lots of mozzarella, pepperoni, mushrooms, Italian sausage, olives, diced green peppers & onions
UNCLE RICO'S BBQ CHICKEN PIZZA BOWL
BBQ base sauce with sliced grilled chicken, roasted red peppers and onions covered with cheddar cheese
THE TACO PIZZA BOWL SINCE 1978
Salsa sauce base, onions, seasoned hamburger beef, lettuce, sliced tomato & lots of cheddar cheese
MAMA TONI'S PLATE PIZZA BOWL
Salvie plate hot meat sauce, hamburger, home fries, diced onions, mac salad covered with cheddar cheese
FISH FRY BOWL
Tartar sauce base with battered deep-fried haddock, home fries & cheddar cheese on top that gets baked in the oven, then we top it with lettuce, tomatoes & a drizzle of honey mustard
VEGAN PIZZA BOWL with VEGAN CHEESE
Choice of Oil & Garlic or Vegan Red Sauce base with vegan cheese
VEGAN PIZZA BOWL with NO VEGAN CHEESE
Choice of Oil & Garlic or Vegan Red Sauce base no vegan cheese
LOVE HOLLY PIZZA BOWL
Garlic & oil base, mozzarella, artichokes, roasted red peppers, and banana peppers
Original Wings
5pc ORIGINAL WINGS
Served with 1 dipping sauce, and choice of wing sauceCals: 198/wing
10pc ORIGINAL WINGS
Served with choice of flavors & dipping sauces. Cals: 198/wing
20pc ORIGINAL WINGS
Served with choice of flavors & dipping sauces. Cals: 198/wing
30pc ORIGINAL WINGS
Served with choice of flavors & dipping sauces. Cals: 198/wing
40pc ORIGINAL WINGS
Served with choice of flavors & dipping saucesCals: 198/wing
50pc ORIGINAL WINGS
Served with choice of flavors & dipping saucesCals: 198/wing
100pc ORIGINAL WINGS
Served with choice of flavors & dipping sauces.Cals: 198/wing
5pc ORIGINAL WING MAC SNACK PACK
Served with choice of wing sauce, macaroni salad, and breadCals: 1550-1900/order
Boneless Wings
5pc BREADED WING MAC SNACK PACK
Served with sweet country sauce, macaroni, and bread (sauce substitutions permitted)
5pc BREADED WINGS
Cals: 287/wing
10pc BREADED WINGS
Served with choice of flavors & dipping sauces. Cals: 287/wing
20pc BREADED WINGS
Served with choice of flavors & dipping sauces. Cals: 287/wing
30pc BREADED WINGS
Served with choice of flavors & dipping sauces. Cals: 287/wing
40pc BREADED WINGS
Served with choice of flavors & dipping saucesCals: 287/wing
50pc BREADED WINGS
Served with choice of flavors & dipping saucesCals: 287/wing
100pc BREADED WINGS
Served with choice of flavors & dipping sauces.Cals: 287/wing
Breaded Wings
5pc BONELESS WINGS
Served with dipping sauces and choice of wing sauceCals: 96/wing
10pc BONELESS WINGS
Served with dipping sauces and choice of wing sauce. Cals: 96/wing
20pc BONELESS WINGS
Served with dipping sauces and choice of wing sauce. Cals: 96/wing
30pc BONELESS WINGS
Served with dipping sauces and choice of wing sauce. Cals: 96/wing
40pc BONELESS WINGS
Served with dipping sauces and choice of wing sauceCals: 96/wing
50pc BONELESS WINGS
Served with dipping sauces and choice of wing sauce. Cals: 96/wing
100pc BONELESS WINGS
Served with dipping sauces and choice of wing sauce.Cals: 96/wing
5pc BONELESS WING MAC SNACK PACK
Served with choice of wing sauce, macaroni salad, and bread
Large Sub (Seeded Roll)
ITALIAN ASSORTED LARGE SUB
Thin sliced baked Virginia ham, imported genoa salami, Italian style cappicola.Cals: 725/order
TUNA FISH LARGE SUB
Charlie's favorite. Fresh daily, and made with Hellman's real mayo. Nice an' creamy!Cals: 1161/order
MIXED MEAT LARGE SUB
Can't decide on a meat? Pick from any 3 of our 5 cold cut meats and create your own masterpiece! Additional choices are extra
SHAVED STEAK LARGE SUB
The best steak sub in town. Thin sliced choice top round steak. Grilled to perfection.Cals: 785/order
MEATBALL MAMA LARGE SUB
We sautee our meatballs in Salvatore's famous pasta sauce, cut them in half and cook with sauce.Cals: 1375/order
CHICKEN FINGER LARGE SUB
We fry our famous chicken fingers to perfection & put them on our fresh baked Italian sub bread.Cals: 925/order
ROAST BEEF LARGE SUB
We use only angus premium roast beef, cooked medium well & sliced nice & thinCals: 695/order
BAKED HAM LARGE SUB
Thin sliced baked Virginia ham, holiday time ham, lightly smoked and real leanCals: 665/order
GENOA SALAMI LARGE SUB
Thin sliced imported genoa salami. Loaded up.Cals: 965/order
CAPICOLA LARGE SUB
Italy's favorite cold cut, seasoned and sliced thin. Tony Soprano would be proud!Cals: 695/order
TURKEY BREAST LARGE SUB
Yea ' real turkey breast used on our turkey subs. You would think it's Thanksgiving at Nona's.Cals: 665/order
ASSORTED CHEESE LARGE SUB
Linda Da Vessie's favorite sub. Choice of American, Swiss, & provolone cheese. No meat for you!Cals: 785/order
ITALIAN SAUSAGE LARGE SUB
We take chunks of our famous Salvatore's pizza Italian sausage & grill it to perfectionxCals: 965/order
PIZZA SUB LARGE SUB
We invented it in 1978. We ran out of pizza dough on a Friday night. It's our famous pizza on our sub bread. Pizza sauce, cheese & pepperoni.Cals: 780/order
EGGPLANT PARMESAN LARGE SUB
The secret to a great eggplant sub is the thin fried eggplant. Then we cover it with our famous pasta sauce and mozzarella.Cals: 1210/order
BLT LARGE SUB
Lettuce, tomato, Hormel bacon and Hellman's mayo make this hot & cold sub a favorite.Cals: 1407/order
BURGER LARGE SUB
Our angus beef home style seasoned burgers put on our famous baked Italian sub bread.Cals: 1145/order
VEGGIE LARGE SUB
Linda Da Veggies 2nd favorite sub. Choice of lots of fresh veggies'Cals: 636/order
CHICKEN PARMESAN LARGE SUB
Our second best selling hot sub. Our seasoned chicken breast fillet covered with our famous sauce & mozzarella.Cals: 1302/order
CHICKEN CORDON BLEU LARGE SUB
Salvatore style with baked ham, swiss cheese & Hellman's mayo. Custom dressed
GRILLED CHICKEN LARGE SUB
Marinated & grilled chicken breast. No breading.Cals: 745/order
BREADED CHICKEN LARGE SUB
Our chicken parm sub without Salvatore's pasta sauce & mozzarella. You decide how to make it!
Medium Sub (Seeded Roll)
ITALIAN ASSORTED MEDIUM SUB
Thin sliced baked Virginia ham, imported genoa salami, Italian style cappicola.Cals: 515/order
TUNA FISH MEDIUM SUB
Charlie's favorite. Fresh daily, and made with Hellman's real mayo. Nice an' creamy!Cals: 786/order
MIXED MEAT MEDIUM SUB
Can't decide on a meat? Pick from any 2 of our 5 cold cut meats and create your own masterpiece! Additional choices are extra
SHAVED STEAK MEDIUM SUB
The best steak sub in town. Thin sliced choice top round steak. Grilled to perfection.Cals: 535/order
MEATBALL MAMA MEDIUM SUB
We sautee our meatballs in Salvatore's famous pasta sauce, cut them in half and cook with sauce.Cals: 875/order
CHICKEN FINGER MEDIUM SUB
We fry our famous chicken fingers to perfection & put them on our fresh baked Italian sub bread.Cals: 665/order
ROAST BEEF MEDIUM SUB
We use only angus premium roast beef, cooked medium well & sliced nice & thinCals: 475/order
BAKED HAM MEDIUM SUB
Thin sliced baked Virginia ham, holiday time ham, lightly smoked and real leanCals: 455/order
GENOA SALAMI MEDIUM SUB
Thin sliced imported genoa salami. Loaded upCals: 665/order
CAPICOLA MEDIUM SUB
Italy's favorite cold cut, seasoned and sliced thin. Tony Soprano would be proud!Cals: 475/order
TURKEY BREAST MEDIUM SUB
Yea ' real turkey breast used on our turkey subs. You would think it's Thanksgiving at Nona's.Cals: 455/order
ASSORTED CHEESE MEDIUM SUB
Linda Da Vessie's favorite sub. Choice of American, Swiss, & provolone cheese. No meat for you!Cals: 560/order
ITALIAN SAUSAGE MEDIUM SUB
We take chunks of our famous Salvatore's pizza Italian sausage & grill it to perfectionCals: 655/order
PIZZA SUB MEDIUM SUB
We invented it in 1978. We ran out of pizza dough on a Friday night. It's our famous pizza on our sub bread. Pizza sauce, cheese & pepperoni.Cals: 520/order
EGGPLANT PARMESAN MEDIUM SUB
The secret to a great eggplant sub is the thin fried eggplant. Then we cover it with our famous pasta sauce and mozzarella.Cals: 860/order
BLT MEDIUM SUB
Lettuce, tomato, Hormel bacon and Hellman's mayo make this hot & cold sub a favoriteCals: 944/order
BURGER MEDIUM SUB
Our angus beef home style seasoned burgers put on our famous baked Italian sub bread.Cals: 830/order
VEGGIE MEDIUM SUB
Linda Da Veggies 2nd favorite sub. Choice of lots of fresh veggiesCals: 436/order
CHICKEN PARMESAN MEDIUM SUB
Our second best selling hot sub. Our seasoned chicken breast fillet covered with our famous sauce & mozzarella.Cals: 929/order
CHICKEN CORDON BLEU MEDIUM SUB
Salvatore style with baked ham, swiss cheese & Hellman's mayo. Custom dressed
GRILLED CHICKEN MEDIUM SUB
Marinated & grilled chicken breast. No breading.Cals: 530/order
BREADED CHICKEN MEDIUM SUB
Our chicken parm sub without Salvatore's pasta sauce & mozzarella. You decide how to make it!
Round Roll (Seeded)
ITALIAN ASSORTED ROLL
Thin sliced baked Virginia ham, imported genoa salami, Italian style cappicolaCals: 420/order
ROAST BEEF ROLL
We use only angus premium roast beef, cooked medium well & sliced nice & thinCals: 370/order
BAKED HAM ROLL
Thin sliced baked Virginia ham, holiday time ham, lightly smoked and real leanCals: 360/order
GENOA SALAMI ROLL
Thin sliced imported genoa salami. Loaded up.Cals: 480/order
TUNA FISH ROLL
Charlie's favorite. Fresh daily, and made with Hellman's real mayo. Nice an' creamy!Cals: 525/order
CAPICOLA ROLL
Italy's favorite cold cut, seasoned and sliced thin. Tony Soprano would be proud!Cals: 370/order
TURKEY BREAST ROLL
Yea' real turkey breast used on our turkey subs. You would think it's Thanksgiving at Nona's.Cals: 360/order
ASSORTED CHEESE ROLL
Linda Da Vessie's favorite sub. Choice of American, Swiss, & provolone cheese. No meat for you!Cals: 450/order
MIXED MEAT ROLL
Can't decide on a meat? Pick from any 1 of our 5 cold cut meats and create your own masterpiece! Additional choices are extra
SHAVED STEAK ROLL
The best steak sub in town. Thin sliced choice top round steak. Grilled to perfectionCals: 400/order
MEATBALL MAMA ROLL
We sautee our meatballs in Salvatore's famous pasta sauce, cut them in half and cook with sauce.Cals: 650/order
ITALIAN SAUSAGE ROLL
We take chunks of our famous Salvatore's pizza Italian sausage & grill it to perfection.Cals: 460/order
PIZZA SUB ROLL
We invented it in 1978. We ran out of pizza dough on a Friday night. It's our famous pizza on our sub bread. Pizza sauce, cheese & pepperoni.Cals: 375/order
EGGPLANT PARMESAN ROLL
The secret to a great eggplant sub is the thin fried eggplant. Then we cover it with our famous pasta sauce and mozzarella.Cals: 625/order
BLT ROLL
Hormel bacon and Hellman's mayo make this hot & cold sub a favorite.Cals: 588/order
VEGGIE ROLL
Linda Da Veggie's 2nd favorite sub. Choice of lots of fresh veggies.Cals: 350/order
CHICKEN FINGER ROLL
We fry our famous chicken fingers to perfection & put them on our fresh baked Italian sub bread.Cals: 520/order
CHICKEN PARMESAN ROLL
Our second best selling hot sub. Our seasoned chicken breast fillet covered with our famous sauce & mozzarella.Cals: 671/order
CHICKEN CORDON BLEU ROLL
Salvatore style with baked ham, swiss cheese & Hellman's mayo. Custom dressed
GRILLED CHICKEN ROLL
Marinated & grilled chicken breast. No breading.Cals: 430/order
Wraps
CHICKEN FINGER WRAP
We fry our famous chicken fingers to perfection & put them in a wrap
BLT WRAP
Lettuce, tomato, Hormel bacon and Hellman's mayo make this hot & cold wrap a favorite
FRIED CHICKEN WRAP
Our chicken parm sub without Salvatore's pasta sauce & mozzarella. You decide how to make it!
GRILLED CHICKEN WRAP
Marinated & grilled chicken breast. No breading
BURGER WRAP
Our angus beef home style seasoned burgers put in a wrap
SAUSAGE PARMESAN WRAP
Chunks of Italian Sausage covered with our famous sauce and mozzeralla cheese
EGGPLANT PARMESAN WRAP
The secret to a great eggplant wrap is the thin fried eggplant. Then we cover it with our famous pasta sauce and mozzarella
BAKED HAM WRAP
Thin sliced baked Virginia ham, holiday time ham, lightly smoked and real lean
TURKEY BREAST WRAP
Yea ' real turkey breast used on our turkey wraps. You would think it's Thanksgiving at Nona's
ITALIAN ASSORTED WRAP
Thin sliced baked Virginia ham, imported genoa salami, Italian style cappicola
ROAST BEEF WRAP
We use only angus premium roast beef, cooked medium well & sliced nice & thin
GENOA SALAMI WRAP
Thin sliced imported genoa salami. Loaded up
CAPICOLA WRAP
Italy's favorite cold cut, seasoned and sliced thin. Tony Soprano would be proud!
TUNA FISH WRAP
Charlie's favorite. Fresh daily, and made with Hellman's real mayo. Nice an' creamy!
ASSORTED CHEESE WRAP
Linda Da Vessie's favorite wrap. Choice of American, Swiss, & provolone cheese. No meat for you!
SHAVED STEAK WRAP
The best steak wrap in town. Thin sliced choice top round steak. Grilled to perfection
MEATBALL MAMA WRAP
We sautee our meatballs in Salvatore's famous pasta sauce, cut them in half and cook with sauce
VEGGIE WRAP
Linda Da Veggie's 2nd favorite wrap. Choice of lots of fresh veggies
MIXED MEAT WRAP
Can't decide on a meat? Pick from any 2 of our 5 cold cut meats and create your own masterpiece! Additional choices are extra
CHICKEN PARMESAN WRAP
Our second best selling hot wrap. Our seasoned chicken breast fillet covered with our famous sauce & mozzarella
CHICKEN CORDON BLEU WRAP
Salvatore style with baked ham, swiss cheese & Hellman's mayo. Custom dressed
PIZZA SUB WRAP
We invented it in 1978. We ran out of pizza dough on a Friday night. Pizza sauce, cheese & pepperoni
Specialty Wraps
BUFFALO CHICKEN WRAP
Romaine lettuce, tomatoes, sliced Salvatore's famous chicken fingers covered with Chuck's buffalo wing sauce & blue cheeseCals: 520/order
CHICKEN CAESAR WRAP
Romaine lettuce with caesar dressing, sliced grilled chicken breast, asiago cheese, covered with Hellman's caesar dressing.Cals: 770/order
CAJUN CHICKEN WRAP
Lettuce, tomatoes, sliced grilled cajun chicken breast, covered with mexican ranch dressingCals: 880/order
Chicken Sandwiches & Tenders
5pc CHICKEN FINGERS
Served with choice of fresh cut french fries, or home friesCals: 1362-2182/order
CHICKEN SANDWICH
Your choice of chicken. Served with choice of fresh cut french fries, or home friesCals: Breaded chicken 1308/order |Grilled chicken 1072/order
2pc CHICKEN FINGERS
Served with choice of fresh cut french fries, or home friesCals: 982-1332/order
BUFFALO CHICKEN SANDWICH
Breaded chicken tossed in your choice of sauce. Custom dressed, & served w/ fries
Pasta Dinners
PASTA with MEATBALLS
4oz of Barilla spaghetti. 2 mama Salvatore's meatballs covered with our famous pasta sauce. Served with garlic bread.Cals: 1028/order
EGGPLANT PARMESAN
The secret to a great eggplant parmesan is the thin fried eggplant. Then we cover it with our famous pasta sauce and mozzarella. Served with 4oz Barilla spaghetti & garlic bread.Cals: 1393/order
BREADED CHICKEN PARMESAN
Our seasoned chicken breast fillet covered with our famous sauce & mozzarella. Served with 4oz Barilla spaghetti & garlic bread.Cals: 1290/order
STUFFED SHELLS
Five giant shells stuffed with ricotta, covered with our famous pasta sauce & mozzarella. Served with Garlic breadCals: 1070/order
GRILLED CHICKEN PARMESAN
Our grilled chicken breast covered with our famous sauce & mozzarella. Served with 4oz Barilla spaghetti & garlic bread.Cals: 818/order
HADDOCK PARMESAN
Covered with tomato sauce and melted mozzarella with side of pastaCals: 1608/order
BAKED PASTA with MOZZARELLA & SAUCE
Cals: 918/order
2pc MEATBALL MANIA
Served with your choice of sauce Tomato (Cals: 383) Alfredo (Cals: 473) Pesto (Cals: 698) Blue Cheese (Cals: 758) Sweet Country (Cals 578)
SIDE DISH
Choice of meat or pasta. Add cheese for $1.25eggplant (Cals: 240)meatballs (Cals: 380)sausage (Cals: 680)pasta (Cals: 390)
4pc MEATBALL MANIA
Served with your choice of sauce Tomato (Cals: 795) Alfredo (Cals: 1035) Pesto (Cals: 1635) Blue Cheese (Cals: 1795) Sweet Country (Cals 1315)
Burgers & Hots
SALVATORE'S BURGER
1/3lb burger cooked to perfection. Custom dressed your way!Cals: 570/order
CHEESE BURGER
1/3lb burger with your choice of melted cheeseCals: 640/order
ITALIAN BURGER
1/3lb burger with Salvatore's famous pasta sauce & provolone cheeseCals: 670-680/order
SALVIE BURGER
1/3lb burger with lettuce, tomato, onion, Hellman's mayo & provolone cheeseCals: 840/order
BBQ BURGER
1/3lb burger covered with our very popular bbq sauceCals: 630/order
BLEU CHEESE BURGER
1/3lb burger covered with our wing blue cheeseCals: 710/order
SWISS BURGER
1/3lb burger with 2 slices of melted swiss cheeseCals: 650/order
MUSHROOM BURGER
1/3lb burger with sautéed fresh mushroomsCals: 583/order
DOUBLE BURGER
Two 1/3lb burgers stacked & custom dressed your way!Cals: 900/order
DOUBLE CHEESEBURGER
Two 1/3lb burgers with your choice of melted cheeseCals: 1040/order
HOT DOG
Zweigles red hot dogs on a medium sub roll custom dressedCals: 335/order
Salvie Plates
CHEESEBURGER PLATE
2- 1/3 cheeseburgers with choice of two sides (macaroni salad, fries, or grilled beans). Topped with fresh diced onions and Salvie Plate hot sauce.Cals: 1030/order
HAMBURGER PLATE
2- 1/3 burgers with choice of two sides (macaroni salad, fries, or grilled beans). Topped with fresh diced onions and Salvie Plate hot sauce.Cals: 890/order
ITALIAN SAUSAGE PLATE
Our famous Italian sausage with choice of two sides (macaroni salad, fries, or grilled beans). Topped with fresh diced onions and Salvie Plate hot sauceCals: 870/order
HOT DOG PLATE
2- Zweigles Red Hots with choice of two sides (macaroni salad, fries, or grilled beans). Topped with fresh diced onions and Salvie Plate hot sauceCals: 670/order
STEAK PLATE
Our top round grilled shaved steak with choice of two sides (macaroni salad, fries, or grilled beans). Topped with fresh diced onions and Salvie Plate hot sauceCals: 530/order
1 HAMBURGER, 1 ITALIAN SAUSAGE PLATE
1- 1/3 burger with Italian Sausage with choice of two sides (macaroni salad, fries, or grilled beans). Topped with fresh diced onions and Salvie Plate hot sauce.
1 HAMBURGER, 1 HOT DOG PLATE
1- 1/3 burger and 1 Hot Dog with choice of two sides (macaroni salad, fries, or grilled beans). Topped with fresh diced onions and Salvie Plate hot sauce.
1 CHEESEBURGER, 1 ITALIAN SAUSAGE PLATE
1- 1/3 Cheeseburger and Italian Sausage with choice of two sides (macaroni salad, fries, or grilled beans). Topped with fresh diced onions and Salvie Plate hot sauce.
1 CHEESEBURGER, 1 HOT DOG PLATE
1- 1/3 Cheeseburger and 1 Hot Dog with choice of two sides (macaroni salad, fries, or grilled beans). Topped with fresh diced onions and Salvie Plate hot sauce.
1 ITALIAN SAUSAGE, 1 HOT DOG PLATE
Our famous Italian Sausage and 1 Zweigles Red Hot with choice of two sides (macaroni salad, fries, or grilled beans). Topped with fresh diced onions and Salvie Plate hot sauce.
GRILLED CHICKEN PLATE
2 grilled chicken breasts with choice of two sides (macaroni salad, fries, or grilled beans). Topped with fresh diced onions and Salvie Plate hot sauceCals: 490/order
CHICKEN FINGERS PLATE
4 chicken fingers with choice of two sides (macaroni salad, fries, or grilled beans). Topped with fresh diced onions and Salvie Plate hot sauceCals: 670/order
FISH FRY PLATE
Full piece of Battered Haddock with choice of two sides (macaroni salad, fries, or grilled beans). Topped with fresh diced onions and Salvie Plate hot sauceCals: 850/order
VEGGIE PLATE
Grilled Mushrooms, onions, and green peppers, with choice of two sides (macaroni salad, fries, or grilled beans). Topped with fresh diced onions and Salvie Plate hot sauceCals: 380/order
1/2 STEAK PLATE
Our top round grilled shaved steak with choice of two sides (macaroni salad, fries, or grilled beans). Topped with fresh diced onions and Salvie Plate hot sauceCals: 380/order
1/2 GRILLED CHICKEN PLATE
1 grilled chicken breast with choice of two sides (macaroni salad, fries, or grilled beans). Topped with fresh diced onions and Salvie Plate hot sauceCals: 360/order
1/2 CHICKEN FINGERS PLATE
2 chicken fingers with choice of two sides (macaroni salad, fries, or grilled beans). Topped with fresh diced onions and Salvie Plate hot sauceCals: 450/order
1/2 VEGGIE PLATE
Grilled Mushrooms, onions, and green peppers, with choice of two sides (macaroni salad, fries, or grilled beans). Topped with fresh diced onions and Salvie Plate hot sauceCals: 305/order
1/2 HAMBURGER PLATE
1- 1/3 burger with choice of two sides (macaroni salad, fries, or grilled beans). Topped with fresh diced onions and Salvie Plate hot sauceCals: 560/order
1/2 CHEESEBURGER PLATE
1- 1/3 cheeseburger with choice of two sides (macaroni salad, fries, or grilled beans). Topped with fresh diced onions and Salvie Plate hot sauceCals: 630/order
1/2 ITALIAN SAUSAGE PLATE
Our famous Italian sausage with choice of two sides (macaroni salad, fries, or grilled beans). Topped with fresh diced onions and Salvie Plate hot sauceCals: 550/order
1/2 HOT DOG PLATE
1- Zweigles Red Hot with choice of two sides (macaroni salad, fries, or grilled beans). Topped with fresh diced onions and Salvie Plate hot sauceCals: 450/order
Salads
GRILLED CHICKEN SALAD
Our tossed salad with a 4oz grilled chicken breast sliced and mozzarella cheese. Choice of dressingCals: 275/order
BUFFALO CHICKEN SALAD
Our tossed salad with sliced chicken fingers covered in mild wing sauce and topped with cheddar cheese. Choice of dressingCals: 425/order
SIDE SALAD
Romaine Spring Mix, tomatoes, carrots, cucumbers, and onions. Choice of dressingCals: 60/order
TOSSED SALAD
Romaine Spring Mix, tomatoes, carrots, cucumbers, and onions. Choice of dressingCals: 100/order
ANTIPASTO SALAD
That's Italian! Our tossed salad with black olives, pepperoni, ham, salami, provolone cheese, and pepperoncini. Choice of dressingCals: 353/order
TUNA TOPPED SALAD
Our tossed salad topped with our very popular tuna fish with Hellmann's mayo. Same tuna we use on our amazing subsCals: 325/order
CAESAR SALAD
Our tossed salad topped with mushrooms, bacon, asiago cheese, and Caesar dressing, Add chicken for $4.55Cals: 287 /order
CAJUN CHICKEN SALAD
Our tossed salad with sliced grilled Cajun chicken breast and cheddar cheese. Choice of dressingCals: 285/order
IT'S GREEK TO ME
Our tossed salad with feta cheese, kalamata olives, and Greek dressing. Add chicken for an additional charge.Cals: 280/order
Soups
10oz OF CHILI with CHEDDAR
Chunks of beef & red beans with melted cheddar
CHILI with CHEDDAR
10oz OF SOUP W/ MOZZARELLA
10oz OF CHILI
Chunks of beef & red beans
10oz OF CHILI with MOZZARELLA
Chunks of beef & red beans with melted mozzarella
Fish & Shrimps
BIG BERTHA'S GIANT FISH SANDWICH
Our famous fish fry stuffed in a loaf of our fresh baked Italian sub bread. Includes tartar sauce on the sideCals: 1245/order
10pc BREADED SHRIMP DINNER
With fresh cut fries and choice of two saucesCals: 1574/order
BATTERED FISH FRY - INCLUDES 2 SIDES
Fresh Haddock with tartar sauce and two sides. Please note that fries do not come with this automatically, but are one of the choices we offerCals: 2017/order
10pc SALVATORE'S STYLE BREADED SHRIMP DINNER
With blue cheese, sweet & sour sauce, mac salad & fresh cut friesCals: 2135-2835/order
Desserts
PEANUT BUTTER PIE
Rochester's original peanut butter pie since 1978.Cals: 640 /order
FRESH BAKED COOKIE
Cals: 370/order
(1) CANNOLI
Ricotta filled. Italian bakeries are always trying to steal our recipe.Cals: 230/order
RASPBERRY CHEESECAKE
Raspberry white chocolate cheese cake
2pk CANNOLI
Cals: 460/order
CARROT CAKE
Rochester's best cream cheese frosting carrot cake.Cals: 540/order
4pk COOKIES
Fresh BakedCals: 1480/order
CARLO'S RAINBOW CAKE
As featured on TLC's Cake Boss
CARLO'S CHOCOLATE CAKE
As featured on TLC's Cake Boss
CARLO'S RED VELVET CAKE
As featured on TLC's Cake Boss
Sides
REGULAR LAYS CHIPS
NACHO DORITOS CHIPS
COOLER RANCH DORITOS CHIPS
LARGE BREAD
Side Order- GRILLED CHICKEN
4oz grilled chicken breast
Side Order- TUNA FISH
1 scoop Salvatore's fresh tuna salad
COLE SLAW
Salvatore's fresh coleslaw
GARLIC BREAD
A loaf of our large bread with olive oil, butter, garlic, melted mozzarella. A family favorite.
MEDIUM BREAD
HARD ROLL
8oz BAKED BEANS
Side Order- BREADED CHICKEN
4oz breaded chicken breast
PICKLE CHIPS
2oz
Drinks
20oz BOTTLE
Select Flavor
GATORADE
Select Flavor
2 LITER
Select Flavor
ENERGY DRINKS
Select Flavor, Price based on selection
ICED TEA DRINKS
Select Flavor, Price based on selection
JUICES
Price based on selection
MILKS
WATER
Sauces
SALVATORE'S PIZZA SAUCE
4oz
KEN'S BLUE CHEESE DRESSING
2oz cup
HOT WING SAUCE
Buffalo style, 2oz cup
MILD WING SAUCE
Buffalo style, 2oz cup
SWEET COUNTRY STYLE
(Sweet & Sour)2oz cup
KEN'S BBQ SAUCE
2oz cup
KEN'S TARTAR SAUCE
2oz cup
KEN'S 1000 ISLAND DRESSING
2oz pouch
ZESTY ITALIAN
2oz pouch
KEN'S RANCH DRESSING
2oz pouch
KEN'S CAESAR DRESSING
2oz pouch
KEN'S HONEY MUSTARD DRESSING
2oz pouch
A1 STEAK SAUCE
2oz cup
SALVATORE'S PASTA SAUCE
4oz cup
SALVIE PLATE HOT SAUCE
2oz cup. Put it on everything!
GARLIC PARMESAN
SPICY MUSTARD
SALVATORE'S BLUE CHEESE CUP
2oz cup
HOT HONEY
Utensils
FORK
KNIFE
SPOON
PLATE
CUP
NAPKINS
Photos
+24 photos
+23 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
I’ve worked here since highschool, going to college on and off. The staff are great and all friendly, they welcome you with open arms and treat you like family. When I don’t work for a while due to college, I am always welcomed back with open arms and a place for me to work. I am lucky to be a salvatore’s employee!
July 2024
Pizza has been just ok from here. Recently got a slice and was shocked that it was $7.00. Size of slice has decreased over the past couple years while the pricing has gone up. Save your funds and head down to Perri's. Slice is significantly larger for $5.00.
February 2024
Great calzones, subs, and tenders & fries! We had never eaten at a Salvatore's and stopped by on our way through town, and ordered a few different meals. The guy on staff was very friendly and helpful, the food was all delicious, and the outdoor eating area was very nice! We'll make it a point to stop back again! :)
July 2023
You May Also Like
Monte Alban - 2160 Penfield Rd
![]()
Mexican, Vegetarian
Taco Bell - 2157 Fairport Nine Mile Point Rd
![]()
Fast Food, Mexican