13 Best Italian Restaurants near Port Jervis

“Friendly atmosphere….great staff…. Willing to go out of their way to help customers… food is delicious and priced well … all around a great experience! Looking forward to going back!“

“My husband and I stumbled across this gem of a restaurant while walking through Milford PA last night. We are so thankful that we stopped in as the food and the waitress (didn't get her name) were wonderful. She recommended the eggplant tower and the blue crab ravioli and both dishes were 5 star! The atmosphere is funky but relaxed and just what we were looking for. We're going to swing by next week for dinner on our way back from SC as we can't to sample another culinary treat. Kudos to this cute little place. You sure know what you're doing!“

“The best! Fast and delicious, always super nice 😊“

“All the food I’ve tried has all been great, smash burgers are rightly raved about, wings are excellent. I’m not a salad person and the Caesar is really good. My father constantly gets the fish and chips. Basically all the food on the menu is worth trying.“

“Take out menu for Mother's Day was great. Lamb shanks, mashed potatoes, side veggies and strawberry short cake dessert was the next best thing to going out today! Thank you for providing a wonderful way to celebrate during these times.“

“I can honestly say the BEST pizza I have had in this area is from Candys Pizza.. Frank is such a sweetheart and a great person! 10/10 recommend!“

“I just had their eggplant pizza! It was delicious. I'm from NY, so I'm picky about pizza. We will definitely be going back!“

“Stopped in tonight for dinner with my wife. Food and service were great. Thank you!“

“I just had the Lamb Gyro Platter. it was EXCELLENT They are GREAT!!!n“

“Fabulous pizza. Will definitely return.“

“My dads own recipes, style, and heart was poured into this restaurant. Ive been all over the east coast for work and pleasure and Luna Rossa is on par with the best Italian food that New York/Connecticut/New Jersey/Pennsylvania have to offer. Proud to be part of the future of Luna Rossa.“

“I’ve gotten 4 items delivered so far to my home. The Sicilian pie with garlic knots and sauce -which is much better than all the other pizza places I’ve tried. The cheese is NOT overly salty, they’re generous with it and the food comes hot and fresh. We also had the Italian sandwich (not the Italian sub/hero with all the meats) but their way of making a new sandwich. Tons of mayo, Romaine lettuce, tomato, Italian meats. (I forget what type), fresh roll. I have a small appetite but ate the entire thing. That’s how good and different it was! The Neapolitan pizza pie-plain. Good stuff. Going back for something different soon. Sorry I have no pictures. We ate it all. lol. Coming from an area that has a dozen pizza joints it’s been fun trying to find something we both really like and see things we haven’t seen on other menu’s. Maybe we will dine in soon. ;1)“

“Always the best!! Everything on the menu is great and just remember: You get what you pay for! I feel like I'm back in the city!!“