15 Best Caterers near Riverhead

1 Hamptons Heirloom

5.0 Superb 2 Reviews

164 Merritts Pond Rd, Riverhead

2 Ben & Jerry’s

4.8 Superb 54 Reviews

87 East Main Street, Riverhead

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Doing such a nice buy one get one free for Mother’s Day!”

3 Christopher Michael Catering

4.1 Good 9 Reviews

370 Manor Lane, Riverhead

“From our first interaction Matt Kar was professional and caring. He answered any of our questions or concerns in a timely manner. The majority of tasks and requests we had were expertly handled by him and his staff. The catering manager, Christine, was extremely detail oriented and made sure we were comfortable and happy with everything at the wedding. She went above and beyond to ensure the day went smoothly with minimal input needed from us the day of. The onsite staff, especially Jaclyn and Trisha, were incredible, frequently checking in with myself and my husband to ensure we had anything we might need. For guests with allergies, all the staff were vigilant and would make sure there were items to offer them that they could enjoy. We used the French Style service, many of our guests are still raving about the variety and how delicious everything was. We used Christopher Michael for all of the rentals as well. They did a beautiful job with the entire event.”

4 Restaurante el Quetzal

4.4 Superb 72 Reviews

1020 East Main Street, Riverhead

• Delivery

“The best authentic Guatemalian food, plus they have great birria tacos. La mejor comida auténtica de Guatemala, además de que tienen excelentes tacos de birria.”

5 Swan Lake Caterers

5.0 Superb 134 Reviews

388 River Road Suite 1405, Manorville · 7.23 miles

• Take-Out

“Our wedding at Swan Lake was truly everything we dreamed of. The golf course was absolutely gorgeous and made the most stunning backdrop for our outdoor ceremony. Having the upgraded tent fabric was such a beautiful touch—it looked incredible and gave us just the right amount of cover on a sunny day, keeping everyone comfortable while still feeling open and elegant. What really stood out was how thoughtful the venue was in making sure our day felt completely ours. They kept golfers separate with their own outdoor bar and even made sure no one was teeing off nearby when the ceremony began, which gave us peace of mind and allowed us to be fully present in the moment. The food was phenomenal from start to finish—the hors d’oeuvres, cocktail stations, and entrées were all delicious. Guests are still talking about the chateau briand, the stuffed chicken with cheesy tarragon, and those incredible pesto wild mushroom raviolis. To top it all off, the chef himself came out to check in, asking guests if they wanted seconds and if everything was to their liking—such a thoughtful and personal touch that made everyone feel cared for. The people at Swan Lake are what truly made the experience unforgettable. Elena, our maître d’, was amazing—she kept everything running smoothly, listened to our ideas, and then added her own creative touch to bring our vision to life. Jill, our bridal attendant, was honestly a lifesaver. She always seemed to know exactly what we needed—whether it was a drink in hand, a quick tip, or even rescuing us from a conversation so we could keep moving. Sophia, the coordinator, was so upbeat and caring, making sure that even when little hiccups popped up, we were still smiling and having fun. And beyond them, every single server and bartender went above and beyond, offering incredible service with a genuine smile all day and night. Not only did we have the best time celebrating with our family and friends, but we also walked away with new friendships at Swan Lake. It didn’t just feel like a venue—it felt like a community of people who cared deeply about making our day special. We honestly can’t wait to see them again.”

6 Cuisine by Colleen

5.0 Superb 27 Reviews

30 Old Riverhead Road, Westhampton Beach · 6.49 miles

“Colleen has been our go to caterer for years. The food never disappoints from a small bbq to a special birthday celebration for 50 at our home. Service is impeccable. Staff is professional & efficient. From the creative array of appetizers and the beautiful dinner, everything was truly yummy.”

7 East End Events Catering

5.0 Superb 25 Reviews

10095 Main Road, Mattituck · 7.98 miles

“As a wedding coordinator, I’m so grateful to have worked with Jenn and the amazing East End Events Catering team! Jenn was organized, communicative, and truly cared about bringing the couple’s vision to life. An outdoor wedding with challenging weather brought plenty to navigate, and I appreciated her dedication, teamwork, and heart throughout it all. Having such a caring team to work alongside meant so much. Thank you, Jenn and team! I would be thrilled to work together again!”

8 Hamptons Aristocrat [Private Chefs + Culinary Production}

4.8 Superb 61 Reviews

Firehouse, 87 Sunset Avenue UNIT A / corner across from, Westhampton Beach · 7.32 miles

• Delivery

“Christmas Eve we were stuck home in quarantine. I was sick and did not feel well enough to cook. Hampton Aristocrat saved the day!!!! My husband and I had a wonderful meal prepared by Hampton Aristocrat. Sliced steak, boneless chicken wings, mac n cheese, mashed potatoes, and stuffed mushrooms. Everything was delicious!!! Thank you, Hampton Aristocrat for saving our Christmas Eve dinner!!!!”

9 Lighthouse Deli and Catering

4.8 Superb 26 Reviews

363 Meeting House Creek Rd, Aquebogue · 2.63 miles

• Delivery

“I am an egg sandwich connoisseur. I have a few spots for different preferences. Here is best for the plain ham and egg on a roll, like the old Calverton Deli. Pull up on Meetinghouse Creek by boat and walk over or park your car at the dock. It’s like heaven.”

10 By Hand Catering

4.8 Superb 13 Reviews

13550 Main Road Suite 2, Mattituck · 8.56 miles

“Our guests just can’t stop talking about the food created by By Hand Catering. Adam and Liz are phenomenal to work with, offering the opportunity to work with you to create a menu and event that fits your style. We had a backyard wedding with 150+ people that required an endless-cocktail style reception and the use of unique spaces for our bars. Adam adapted to all of it and we would not have had the event we had without the teamwork between him, his colleague Liz, and Rita from Rita Ellis Events. Most importantly, Adam and Liz worked with their chef to help recreate Chilean empanadas that are so important to my husband’s side of the family. Those empanadas were AMAZING and were the main hit amongst all of our guests. If you want excellent food and need excellent logistical support for a complex event, look no further than By Hand.”

11 Giorgio's Baiting Hollow

4.9 Superb 137 Reviews

100 Fox Hill Dr, Baiting Hollow · 5.48 miles

“My son was just married there and the service was spectacular, the food was amazing, the grounds flawless. So many nice touches that really stepped up the event, the staff was super attentive from the bridal attendants, maitre d and all wait staff. Abundant food at the cocktail hour, everything you could think of, then an exquisite dinner where you were offered seconds or to try other main courses, a sorbet cone between courses, amazing pastries and cookies with dessert cake and then passed out hot from the over chocolate chip cookies!”

12 Aby’s Deli & Catering

4.5 Superb 46 Reviews

459 Montauk Highway, East Moriches · 9.28 miles

• Delivery

“Great food, reasonable prices and friendly staff!”

13 Ben & Jerry’s

4.3 Superb 59 Reviews

121 Main Street, Westhampton Beach · 7.48 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Nothing but FANTASTIC things to say about my experience with Antoinette and the catering aspect of Ben & Jerry's of Westhampton. We used them to cater a sundae bar party for our wedding on June 30th at Bellport Country Club and from start to finish Antoinette was a PLEASURE to deal with, so incredibly helpful, not pushy at all, and attentive to my requests. I would literally get excited every time I had to talk to her! On the day of our wedding, the sundae bar was everything I could have dreamed of and more. From the photo props, to the flavors sign, to the toppings, scoopers, and of course the ice cream---worth every penny! If you are even remotely considering getting this store to cater an event of yours DO IT! You will not regret it :) Thank you Antoinette!!!!!!!!!!!”

14 Moriches Bay Deli Inc

4.3 Superb 85 Reviews

490 East Main Street, East Moriches · 9.39 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We cannot recommend Moriches Bay Deli enough! We ordered a 3-foot bacon, egg, and cheese hero for my dog's birthday party, and it was absolutely incredible. Roe is amazing—friendly, kind-hearted, accommodating, and so easy to work with from start to finish. The hero was fresh, delicious, and prepared perfectly. Every single guest raved about it and kept asking where it came from! Moriches Bay Deli always impresses us. Everything they make is top-notch, and their customer service is second to none. If you're looking for great food and great people, look no further. Thank you for making my baby's birthday special Roe! :)”

15 Better Burger Catering & Food Truck

4.0 Good 137 Reviews

473 County Rd 111, Manorville · 7.73 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Awesome Experience. Quality products Homemade tots are terrific Great set up.”