13 Best Caterers in New Haven

“We had BGT for my son’s graduation party yesterday. Everything was wonderful . The pizza was delicious, so many varieties. The staff were great, friendly and accommodating. Our guests were all impressed and couldn’t stop talking about how delicious the pizza was!! Will definitely use them again for any other events! Highly recommend !!“

“We recently attended a New Haven high school reunion at Lost In New Haven Museum. The Olde World Pizza Truck was hired to serve 70 people. The food and service was excellent. Everybody in attendance commented how good the experience was. The staff was friendly and professional, serving different pies on a timely basis. The salad and Gelato was a nice added touch. There was plenty of extra pizza for the people to take home. All trash was cleared, no extra work. I highly recommend this company.“

“Our wedding at Amarante's was a dream come true. Truly. The manager Dominic was exceptionally professional. I felt like our wedding was the only one he was working on! I don't know how he does it. Our maître d' of the evening, Darlene, is a superstar! She executed everything with grace and poise -- always checking in to see if we needed anything. All in all, we couldn't have asked for a better experience or more perfect day. Our wedding was months ago, and our guests still talk about the stunning sunset views, the delicious food, and how much fun they had. Thank you for a beautiful memory, Amarante's!“

“We just used Est Pizza for my daughters graduation party. They did a fantastic job. All the workers were very pleasant, the pizza was delicious. Great amount of variety! The frozen yogurt was the best frozen I ever had. I highly recommend using Est Pizza for you next event.“

“This is my most favorite spot to grab breakfast and lunch. The entire staff, especially Jess is awesome. They treat you like family. Would recommend to everyone.“

“I just had my wedding here in May, and everything exceeded all my expectations for myself and my guests! The food was incredible, the staff was nice, Brian who ran the show on my big night was super helpful and attentive. The palm trees arrived on time and were stunning! The whole venue really is just beautiful between the beach, landscaping, terrace area where they have flowers and a beautiful view for guests during cocktail hour: i have zero complaints! We traveled 2 hours from home to have our wedding here and we already want to go back for a holiday event!“

“Shaken and Stirred did a phenomenal job catering our wedding. They were happy to do some custom items by request and all the items were crowd pleasers. We decided to go with Stations instead of a sit-down dinner. Their presentation was amazing and got you excited to eat before the first bite, which was great. Their staff was attentive and friendly. Their bartenders were a lot of fun and went above and beyond the call of duty. One of the owners was overseeing the event himself and made sure it all came together. Highly recommended.“

“Afro-Tina came to my wedding on Saturday, October 8th. Their food is so delicious! The empanadas (including tres leches), jerk salmon, sazon chicken, and bbq cauliflower were excellent! Not only is their food flavorful, their staff is super friendly. I can’t thank Ohioma enough for his help. He made me feel at ease. If you choose to go with Afro-Tina, you will be in good hands. Hiring them was the best decision I made for my wedding.“

“My family just shared an amazing meal from Sanctuary Kitchen that we ordered ahead and picked up from the Madison Farmers Market. Fresh, delicious and convenient! Best pita and flat bread I’ve ever had.“

“Oldest and best Irish Organization in Connecticut, one of the oldest in the US. Proud supporters of the Greater New Haven St Patrick's Day Parade and donates to many worthy causes including homeless shelters, and women's shelters.“

“Delicious ice cream and milkshakes!“

“The food is amazing“

“Pernil sandwich, alcapurria, chicken pincho, and cheesecake were all fantastic. Cash or credit accepted. Atmosphere was very casual with people coming in and out, kids playing in front, and a lot of conversation between customers, management, and kitchen staff. Very neighborly place with friendly service and great food.“