35 Best Pizza Restaurants in New Haven

Modern Apizza Pizza • $
874 State St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Bread with Mozzarella
Italian Bomb Pizza
Plain Cheese Pizza
Clams Casino Pizza
White Clam Pizza
Veggie Bomb Pizza
Margherita Pizza
Margarita Pizza
Meatball Pizza
Broccoli Pizza

“I'm gonna start with a real bold opener here and say that out of the pizza greats MODERN IS THE BEST, HANDS DOWN. It's not up for debate, it's not an opinion, it's an empirical fact.I have NEVER had a bad experience doing business with them.Dine-in: FIVE STARS.Take-out: FIVE STARS.Their customer service: not even a contest! Always so polite, kind, accommodating, and really care about giving you a positive experience.My favorite nuances withheld in Modern's perfectly cooked dough are:-The subtle sweetness that arrives on the back end of every bite that I believe is in the dough and not the sauce (correct me if I'm wrong).-Their pies produce the absolute perfect bubble.-The dough has a really good bouncy mouthfeel without being overly floppy.-Exceptional sauce, very bright and flavorful.-Good sauce/dough/cheese ratio.-Clutch undercarriage.The best way to measure the worth of any pizza is with a plain cheese pie.I've waited about 3 years, maybe a little more, to post this review. My opinion was formed the moment I tasted the absolute best and it hasn't changed yet. I hope this review helps you to make the right decision when it comes to your pizza patronage.“

4.6 Superb212 Reviews
Zeneli Pizzeria e cucina Napoletana Pizza • $$
138 Wooster St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Margherita Pizza with Arugula
Homemade Italian Meatballs
Rigatoni All Amatriciana
Gnocchi Alla Sorrentina
Insalata Di Arugula
Calzone Napoletano
Salad Pizza Napoli
Margherita Verace
Fresh Mozzarella
Nutella Pizza

“Popped in on our way through town and found the best pizza I've ever had. The service was great, the waitress was very attentive, the pizza came out incredibly fast and priced very well compared to other spots near by. I'll be stopping by any time I'm in the area.“

4.8 Superb191 Reviews
Big Green Truck Pizza Pizza • $$
530 East St, New Haven

“Moe and George did a phenomenal job at our team building event back in early October. Weeks later everyone is still talking about it. We use the Big Green Truck every year for employee appreciation day. Each year they amaze us with their awesome customer service and delicious food. They will forever be our favorite truck at Hubbell !“

4.9 Superb68 Reviews
Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana Pizza • $
157 Wooster St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Margherita Pizza and White Clam Pizza
The Original Tomato Pie
Clam and Bacon Pizza
Meatball and Ricotta
Fresh Tomato Pie
Spinach Mushroom
Pepperoni Pizza
Quattro Formagi
Veggie Pizza
Caesar Salad

“A local very popular restaurant worthy of Michelin 1+ star performance. white clam pizza is a must try. This restaurant is deep in history and is celebrating its 100th year. Great atmosphere and vibe. Run by generations of family owners. Definitely need to check out their wood fire stone oven. it is the largest I have ever seen from east to west coast. if you come across one bigger please let me know. Even if this oven is second in size I bet you have a hard time finding one bigger.“

4.3 Superb287 Reviews
Est Est Est Pizza & Restaurant Pizza • $
1176 Chapel St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad with Bacon Add Tomatoes
Half BBQ Chicken and Snowball Pizza
Caesar Salad with Chicken Cutlets
Chicken Bacon Ranch Panini
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Mashed Potato Pizza
Small Cheese Pizza
Shrimp Pesto Pizza
BBQ Chicken Pizza

“Every time I stop by to get a slice I am greeted with kindness and respect and always feel welcome. It's nice they're open late. It's a great place to grab a slice on your way home after a fun night out. The pesto pizza is very tasty. Buffalo chicken is good, too. It gets crowded on weekends during the school year. Enjoy the glow from the oven and elbow in among the irrepressible chatter of the students or take your pie to go.“

4.6 Superb160 Reviews
Ernie's Pizzeria Pizza • $
1279 Whalley Ave, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Small White Native Tomato Bacon & Broccoli Pizza
Small Mootz with Meatball Onion & Cherry Peppers
Small Mootz with Native Tomato Garlic & Basil
Small White Mootz with Bacon Broccoli & Olives
Fresh Native Tomatoes and Broccoli Rabe
Meatball and Hot Cherry Peppers Pizzas
Hot Cherry Pepper and Bacon Pizza
Small Mootz with Meatball & Onion
Small Meatball Mozzarella Pizza
Sausage and Broccoli Rabe Pizza

“This is the best pizza in New Haven, forget what you read from influencers and blogs. Pat is a master of the craft and there is nothing better than a cheese pizza fresh out of the oven. Do yourself a favor and eat there! This pizza is best when it's only a few minutes out of the oven.“

4.8 Superb72 Reviews
Ricotta - Kosher Pizza And Bakery Pizza Delivery •
1203 Chapel St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Cream Cheese and Lox Bagel
Vegetable Personal Pie
Falafel Balls Hummus
Small Potato Burekas
Flavored Cream Cheese
Tomato Onion Pie
Cheese Burekas
Everyhing Pie
Sweet Cheese
Garlic Knots

“Ricotta is a Kosher Pizza and bakery. It's a small restaurant that sells pizza, bakery goods, Israeli breakfast, Israeli foods, Shakshuka, and other Israeli foods. On my way home out of New Haven I decided to stop by. The store was about to close in a hour so they didn't have as much pastries out but I will come back for another visit. The store was small and very clean. My daughter got a Chocolate Rugalach and she said it tasted pretty good. The staff were really welcoming and I would definitely have to come back to taste the Israeli food.“

4.7 Superb66 Reviews
RAWA Mediterranean Fusion, Middle Eastern Food, Pizza Place Pizza • $$
838 Whalley Ave, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Kebab with Vegetable Rice and Chopped Salad
Baklava with Aleppo Pistachios and Hama Ghee
Chopped Salad and Vegetable Rice
Lahmbajeen Pizza
Chicken Biryani
Shrimp Biryani
Sampler Plate
Baba Ghanoush
Seafood Pizza
Falafel Plate

“LOVE Rawa! Consistently good food, service, and atmosphere. The service is excellent and attentive. They brought a dessert on the house for a birthday guest. The food is very reasonably priced. The sampler platter of dips is fantastic. Creative bar menu with a great selection of beers. Our go-to place in New Haven especially for concerts at Westville Music Bowl.“

4.6 Superb82 Reviews
One6Three Pizza • $
163 Foster St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
American Margherita
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Meatball Pizza
Mashed Potato
Spicy Salami
Pizza Joint
Cheese Pizza
Fried Oreos

“Great pizza and sides. Should be in the New Haven Pizza conversation more often.Brick oven, Fresh ingredients, nice crunch and undercarriage/ crust. About 5 two person tables So not much for sitting in. More of a take out spot. Well worth it to go pick it up. Out of the down town city area. In Quiet East “

4.6 Superb81 Reviews
Next Door Pizza • $$
175 Humphrey St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Curried Butternut Squash Soup
Mashed Potato and Bacon Pizza
Honey Brussels Bacon Pie
Fresh Mozzarella Pizza
BBQ Chicken Pizza
French Fries
Caesar Salad
Cheese Pizza
Mac Cheese
Meatball

“Easily accessible and in walking distance of the New Haven green. Got brussels sprouts and a large pizza. The brussels sprouts were cut and fried in a unique way I had never seen before but it was quite delicious. The pizza was also quite good although a little too much garlic for my tastes (and i love garlic)“

4.6 Superb79 Reviews
Sally's Apizza Pizza • $$
237 Wooster St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza
New Haven Original Clam Pie
White Fresh Tomato Pie
Slice of Cannoli Pie
Plain Mozzarella Pie
Fresh Tomatoes Pie
Large Caesar Salad
Garden Special Pie
White Potato Pie
Meat and Cheese

“This place was everything I expected it to be. We were seated immediately, and our server was excellent. She asked us if we had any questions and even made a suggestion for us to add bacon to our potato and rosemary pizza. Both pizzas were delicious and unlike any other I have had before. We also tried a couple of the local Foxon sodas which were great as well. I hope to be able to go again the next time I'm in the area.“

4.1 Good231 Reviews
Pizza at the Brick Oven Pizza • $
122 Howe St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Brick Oven Bread with Tomato & Cheese
The Brick Special Pizza
Margherita Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
The Rugby Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Sauce
Soda

“the owner is the nicest person ever. the pizza was great and slices were huge. we talked to him about our schools rutgers and st joes and he was so kind and friendly. hope anyone who goes here enjoys! was just driving through connecticut and tried it here 10/10 worth it! glad places like this are still “

4.4 Superb115 Reviews
Frisco’s Pizza Pizza Delivery • $
345 Forbes Ave, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Tomato and Sausage
New Haven Crust
Clams Casino

“Pizza is excellent. We get take out here a couple times a month for dinner and have never been disappointed. We love that the pizza is well done but never burnt. They put a ton of toppings on and their bacon is well done (without asking) which is a plus! They are also always very nice.“

4.6 Superb55 Reviews
Yorkside Pizza & Restaurant Pizza • $
288 York St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Sausage Pizza
Yorkside Special Pizza
Meatballs Spaghetti
See Pizza Toppings
Small Greek Salad
Chicken Tenders
Buffalo Chicken
Slice of Pizza
Tzatziki Sauce
Fried Calamari

“I hear al ot about new haven having the best pie I had better in Newton at pizza palace and haven't had any better then fioris in Pittsburgh but the staff are decent over all a kinda wierd exchange with a the guy who felt like he ran the place when I was paying up he asked if I knew uncle Sam assuming I didn't know about taxes or even cared he must of thought my steering at the menu was something other then curiosity of the actual menu not the price Flux but the pizza was definitely far from the worse 4 outta 5“

4.4 Superb88 Reviews
Quinnipiac food mart & deli Pizza • $
1653 Quinnipiac Ave, New Haven

“If you really want some good fresh sandwiches and the best FRESH desserts this is the place to go!!!!!! GREAT SERVICE AND ONLY THE BEST MEAT… Boars Head !!!!!! From NY STYLE copped cheese to the Steak and cheese you can’t ever go wrong here!!!!!!!!!!!“

5 Superb22 Reviews
The Spot Pizza • $$
157 Wooster St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Tomato Pie with Mozzarella

“Wait time in a line outside was 30 min-40 min to get a table on Saturday night. Service was fantastic and food was fantastic. I didn't care for the anchovies but that's my preference. I was convinced to get the tomato pie without the mozzarella and it ended up being my favorite.“

4.4 Superb67 Reviews

17
BAR

BAR Bar • $$
254 Crown St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Mashed Potato Pizza and Margherita Pizza
Mashed Potato and Bacon Pizza
Bacon Mashed Potato Pizza
Mash Potato Bacon Pizza
Mashed Potato & Bacon
Build Your Own Pizza
Large Cheese Pizza
Brisket BBQ Pizza
White Clam Pizza
New Haven Pizza

“LOVE LOVE LOVE THIS PLACE!!! EVERY DISH IS DELISH, EVERY PIZZA IS A WORK OF ART! Super thin, cooked to perfection. PHENOMENAL WAIT STAFF & the Pool table is a plus!!! And of course the mashed potato pizza w garlic and bacon if u want, is OUT-OF-THIS-WORLD! If u like to party n dance--well then theres the BACK ROOM! Wow love this joint!“

4 Good193 Reviews
Family Mediterranean Pizza Halal • $
45 York St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Shawarma over Rice
Side of Lamb Shawarma
Lamb Shawarma Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza
Shawarma Plate
Baklava
Hummus
Salad

“If you are working near New Haven hospital till late hours and require something to eat, i will highly recommend this place. It is really accessible to get to this place (it is linked from new haven hospital to the parking garage. furthermore its sheltered) and the food served here is pretty decent. I used to love ordering the pizza and kebab from this place while i was living in New Haven. The price is also really reasonable“

4.5 Superb38 Reviews
Clemente's Pizza & Grill Pizza • $
1302 Whalley Ave, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Quesadilla
Mozzarella Sticks
Grilled Chicken
Pizza And
Fries
Steak
Gyro

“Best of pizza I've had in 10 years!! Excellent value, I got a meat lovers Pizza and it was loaded!! Everything cooked to perfection. The crust the meet the cheese everything. I would have given them 10 Stars if I! I gave them five stars for atmosphere because they're so nicen and very clean!“

4.4 Superb33 Reviews
Casa Bianca Pizza Ansonia Pizza • $
669 Main St, Ansonia

Customers` Favorites

Mozzarella Cheese Pizza
Meatball Parm Grinder
Grilled Chicken Pizza
Meat Lovers Calzone
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Mozzarella Sticks
Buffalo Chicken
Chocolate Cake
Boneless Wings
Chicken Cutlet

“Fantastic pizza. Great food. Shawn is the owner. He takes pride in what he makes and values his customers. He goes above and beyond to make sure you are satisfied with both the food and the customer service. Casa Bianca is involved in the community and gives back. Shawn, Kim and the team at Casa Biance make Ansonia proud. We appreciate you.Had to add to this review! Shawn outdid himself. What a wonderful birthday for our granddaughters 8th birthday! Pizza, wings and a special heart shaped pepperoni pizza just for her!“

4.2 Good64 Reviews
More Than Pizza Pizza • $
283 Blake St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Medium Size Pepperoni Sausage Bacon Extra Cheese Pizza
Fried Fillet of Sole
Eggplant Parmigiana
More Than Pizza
Buffalo Chicken
Chicken Steak
Italian Combo
Garden Salad
Carrot Cake
Onion Rings

“The gentleman in the front counter was very nice, but it looked very busy. He was handling the front of the house and the back of the house overall. I had a very great chicken parm sandwich and the fries were pretty good. The area is a little sketchy, but it's a very busy intersection.“

4.3 Superb38 Reviews
Casa Bianca Pizza New Haven Pizza • $
185 Derby Ave, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Chekinbacon Chicken Ranch Pizza SPE
Grilled Chicken Salad
Margarita Pizza
Steak & Cheese
Philly Steak
French Fries
Garden Salad
Chicken Parm
Cheese Pizza
Fried Dough

“My go tos are regular cheese or meatball pies w/extra sauce(nyc style). I love my pizza not to be dry.Their fettuccine Alfredo w/ chicken & broccoli is really good as well. Only thing is it's expensive & there's hardly anything there (real small portion.) I always had it delivered bc inside is pretty small (when I worked in New Haven) Delivery guy was extra nice & called me by my name bc I was a regular.“

4.2 Good54 Reviews
Da Legna at Nolo Pizza • $$
687 State St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Vegan Pizza
Nolo Cheese Pizza
Margherita Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Sausage Pepper
Mashed Potato
Goat Cheese
Arugula
Pie

“Sweet vibe and even sweeter staff. The food is fantastic, and they even got live music. What else could you want?Vegetarian options: Plenty of vegetarian pizzas since most pizzas are. But what's cool is they got a buncha vegan pizzas, too.“

3.9 Good77 Reviews
Star Diner & Pizza Pizza • $$
585 Lombard St, New Haven

“This has been an amazing experience. I have been going here for years and have tried most of the items in the menu. The pizza and sandwiches are amazing and really shine in this retro diner especially compared to the rest of new haven. Everything is freshly made and really good.“

4.7 Superb12 Reviews
Whalley Pizza Pizza • $
350 Whalley Ave, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Chicken and Rice with Vegetables
Grilled Chicken Salad
Sausage Pizza
Chicken Pizza
Extra Cheese
Bacon Pizza
Sandwich
Steak

“U Gotta Try What Tha City Calls The "Crack Salad" Its Piled With Chicken & Veggies, *& it Goes Down...Been Havin it for YEARS...Just Recently Had The Chicken & Rice for the first Time, & it Wasn't Bad...Decent Taste With a Lil Seasoning U Might Have 2 Add Depending On Ya Taste Buds“

4.1 Good42 Reviews
East Coast Pizza Truck Pizza •
All of, New Haven

“Attended a graduation party that was catered by this wonderful truck.They continued making one pizza after another of so many different flavors. They were all delicious. Super friendly guys. They served us exceptionally good cappuccino and espresso as well as yummy gelato! Definitely w would recommend!“

4.3 Superb15 Reviews
Aladdin Crown Pizza Pizza • $
260 Crown St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Barbecue Chicken Pizza
Aladdin
Hummus
Kabab

“Excellent pizza that holds its own in a city where great pizza is the standard. It’s a bit more NY style which is nice bc it’s different from everything else in this town. Friendly service and good vibes. Love stopping in here for a slice on my lunch breaks“

4 Good59 Reviews
Bella casa vegana Vegan •
9 Whitney Ave, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Vegan Chicken Pesto
Vegan Garlic Knots
Vegan Meatball Sub
Chicken Parm

“Such an authentic Italian chicken parm! The meat substitute was great, whatever cheese they use is great and their marinara sauce is some of the best! Ordered a size of the cheezy garlic knots which were also amazing! Will definitely be back soon!“

4 Good42 Reviews
Town Pizza Pizza • $
25 Whitney Ave, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Ceasar Salads
Mozzarella Sticks
Town Pizza

“Town Pizza is the BEST!!!! I have been going there for over 20 years, and not only is the food fresh and delicious, great pizza, Greek specialties and more, but the owners and the staff are the nicest folks ever! LOVE everything about Town Pizza!“

4.3 Superb10 Reviews
Town House Pizza Pizza Delivery • $
246 Kimberly Ave, New Haven

“Incredible pizza! If you're looking for the right pizzeria that will satisfy your cravings, this is the right place. Salads are also amazing. I usually order a salad to go with my pizza and it's always so fresh. My favorite place for pizza, staff is also very welcoming and friendly. 5 stars!!!“

4.2 Good11 Reviews
Petals Market and Pizza Takeout • $
100 Ashmun St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Caprese Panini
Bacon Egg and Cheese

“I’m a student in the area and I frequently stop by to grab snacks, but I recently decided to get a breakfast wrap for $6.67 and it was a 10/10! The staff are always nice and the place is clean. 100% recommend stopping by for a quick breakfast.“

4 Good27 Reviews
Costa Pizza Restaurant Pizza • $
9 Whitney Ave #1, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Ravioli
Pepperoni Pizza
Buffalo Wings
Garlic Knots
Chicken Parm
Vegan Pizza
Meat Pizza
Panini
Salads
Subs

“On a road trip from Maine, and saw a few vegan options on the menu. We didn't realize that half the menu was vegan options, we had the Buffalo chicken loaded fries, and got a calzone and a pizza, probably enough for 3 more meals each. The price is steep, but totally worth it, the flavor was amazing and the crust is one of the best we have had!Next time thru this will be a must stop for us!“

4 Good40 Reviews
Kimberly Pizza Pizza • $
34 Kimberly Ave, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza
Cheese Pizza

“Takes you right back to the 80s from the way the joint looks, to the taste of the pizza, even how you pay harkens back to the 80s: cash only. Lol.It really just took me back. Tastes like pizza did when we were kids. Check them out if you want something both different AND nostalgic.“

4 Good20 Reviews
Pizza Haven Pizza • $$
34 Howe St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Pita
Pizza Haven Special
Grilled Chicken
Cheese Pizza

“Used to go there very often years ago when I worked in the neighborhood I just went there to pick up a salad it was delicious as ever Place has been there I think 24 years It is very delicious go eat there. I always used to get the pizza haven salad, or the chicken parm . For today it was just like I remembered you get Pizza Haven salad and some boneless wings can't go wrong!“

3.9 Good17 Reviews
Triple AAA Pizza Restaurant Pizza • $
339 Whalley Ave, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Georgia Hot Sandwich with French Fries
Chicken and Broccoli Alfredo
Chicken Cheese Pizza
Pancakes or French
Pastrami Sandwich
One Topping Pizza
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Grilled Chicken
Chicken Alfredo
Turkey Salad

“Unpretentious but comfortable and attractive diner-style booth seating with wooden tables & booth dividers. Friendly, attentive, prompt service. We were offered a choice of booster seat or high chair for our baby. The booster seat's straps were partially missing but we don't tend to count on those anyway. I was delighted to find liver & eggs on the menu; the modest (but cheap) portion of liver was cooked perfectly, with just a little pink on the inside. On request, our waitress was happy to substitute grilled tomatoes in place of my home fries, and got me some light cream for my coffee in place of half and half. The breakfast sausage was also good. My partner got chicken wings and a salad, her portions were large, and the cucumber on the salad was quite good. Very glad this place is in the neighborhood and that we checked it out despite the unappealing facade.“

3.8 Good38 Reviews
Loading...
map Map