16 Best Pizza Restaurants in Branford

“Indian Neck Pizza is a popular local spot in Branford, known for its pizza, pasta, and homemade bread. The restaurant has a cozy, kitchen-like atmosphere where customers can bring their own beer or wine. The menu features standout items such as the white clams casino, broccoli rabe and sausage red pizza, and carbonara pasta. The calzone, described as "perfectly made" and "oozing with fresh ricotta," is a must-try. While it may be a bit pricey, customers agree that it is worth every penny. The owners and staff are friendly and engaging, making it a welcoming environment for all.“

“Genaros Restaurant & Pizza is a gem in Short Beach, loved by families and foodies alike. The restaurant's incredible food, including tender chicken and soft vegetables, is a highlight. Standout dishes include the vegetable pizza with chicken and the pesto gnocchi, which has a devoted following. With excellent customer service, timely delivery, and fair pricing, Genaros is a top choice for a satisfying meal.“

“Stony Creek Market is a popular spot for locals and visitors in Stony Creek, known for its dog-friendly outside seating and friendly staff. The restaurant is especially known for its thin crust pizza, which is highly regarded for its taste and generous portions, making it a popular choice on Friday pizza nights. In addition to pizza, Stony Creek Market offers a variety of tasty dishes for breakfast and lunch, and is known for remembering regular customers' orders. The restaurant also provides a beautiful view, making it a great spot for a peaceful meal. However, there are a few downsides to note, such as the lack of public restrooms and all-day breakfast options, as well as the premium pricing. Overall, Stony Creek Market is a worthwhile visit for its tasty food and friendly atmosphere, but it may not be worth a detour for those passing through the area.“

“Ilforno Ristorante Italiano is a great place to watch a game and enjoy some delicious food. The restaurant offers a range of dishes, including fresh-made gnocchi, gnocchi Della casa with added calamari, and shrimp marinara with linguine. The food is of high quality and freshness, with generous portions. The ambiance is nice, and the menu offering is excellent. Some dishes, such as the spicy calamari, are worth ordering with caution, but overall, the restaurant provides great value for the price.“

“Capone's Pizza Bar offers delectable pizza with an exceptional sauce, alongside a welcoming "Cheers" atmosphere and friendly staff. The menu boasts standout dishes like broccoli rabe and a superb cauliflower crust. While the portions are generous and the food is tasty, the pricing for beverages may be considered high by some customers.“

“Nonna Gina's Prepared Foods & Gelateria is a local spot offering a variety of prepared dishes, sandwiches, and gelato. The food is consistently praised for its quality, with dishes like the panecotte and panini meatball being standouts. The staff is friendly, and while prices are slightly higher, customers feel it is worth it for the delicious offerings. Some customers have enjoyed the pre-made meals, while others have only tried the sandwiches and gelato, all with positive results. The market also features a wide array of choices, making it a place worth visiting frequently.“

“Benny J's Pizza is a restaurant known for its amazing and best food, with the avocado pizza being a must-try for an explosive taste. The summer California salad and eggplant rollatini are also popular choices. They offer great prices and a kid-friendly environment, complete with a piano for entertainment. The restaurant is small, but its location in the center of town allows for al fresco dining. Benny J's is a local favorite for grab-and-go salads, with fresh ingredients and perfectly cooked pizzas.“

“Da' Carmine Pizzeria & Restaurant offers excellent and well-priced pizza, though the restaurant itself lacks in atmosphere and service. The pizza is described as the best on the shoreline, with large portions and delicious toppings like sausage and mushrooms. While the decor and service need improvement, the pizzeria is highly recommended, especially for displaced New Yorkers seeking top-notch pizza in the Branford area.“

“LoMonaco's Ristorante Italiano offers authentic Italian cuisine, with great meals and attentive service. The restaurant serves a variety of dishes, including the popular Portobello app, Shrimp laMonaco, and Salmon special. The Veal LoMonico is a standout, with two pieces of veal topped with prosciutto and cheese, served with a side of pasta and excellent sauce. The atmosphere is casual and inviting, with good wheelchair accessibility.“

“Pacileo's Apizza & Pasta offers top-quality dining experiences in a fun and family-friendly environment. Their amazing thin-crust pizzas, including the delicious cheese pizza, are a highlight, and their menu caters to various dietary needs. With plenty of indoor seating, free parking, and good wheelchair access, Pacileo's is a must-visit for Italian food lovers on the shoreline.“

“Branford Pizza is a long-standing local favorite, known for its consistently flavorful and palatable dishes. The prices are decent, and the delivery staff are described as very nice. While a calzone was found to be a bit "doughy" with limited sauce, the pizza itself is praised as great. The restaurant is commended for its handling of a missed delivery, making the customer a new order promptly. However, there have been instances of delayed or undelivered orders, leading to disappointment.“

“Honeyspot Pizza 3 offers an exceptional dining experience with outstanding customer service and delectable menu items. The pizza is renowned as the best in Branford, while the chicken cutlets and subs are also highly praised. The restaurant provides a cozy takeout-focused atmosphere and accommodates vegetarian preferences with customizable pizzas. Although the food quality may vary, with some dishes being slightly greasy, the overall experience is positive, making Honeyspot Pizza 3 a recommended choice for delivery or pickup.“

“I was in town on an estimate and had 30 minutes to kill. Stopped in for a couple slices. The pizza was so delicious. The gentleman was so kind. He had his step daughter "Angela" with him a 4 year old who sat down with me and kept me company. She was adorable. I think I would actually come back down here for the pizza and I live in waterbury it was that good.“

“Marco Pizzeria is a restaurant that offers New Haven style pizza, along with a variety of other menu items such as stuffed breads, desserts, and unique options like Buffalo chicken egg rolls and BBQ chicken cauliflower pizza. The restaurant has a clean and welcoming atmosphere, with staff who are knowledgeable about the menu and willing to make recommendations. However, there have been some issues with food quality, such as undercooked egg rolls, hair in the pizza, and tough chicken in the salad. Additionally, the taste of the water and salad dressing has been disappointing to some customers. While the service is generally good, these food quality issues may impact the overall dining experience.“

“Longley's Restaurant, formerly Allegra's, offers a dining experience with mixed results. Upon arrival, guests may not be immediately greeted by staff, but once seated, the friendly waitstaff provides service, albeit slow. The menu features items such as nachos supreme, pretzels, chicken Italiano wrap, and steak and cheese panini. While some dishes, like the pretzels, are enjoyable, others, like the nachos and fries, may be lacking in quality. However, some menu items, such as the chicken Italiano with prosciutto, balsamic glaze, and bruschetta, and the ahi tuna, fried shrimp, and fried steak tacos, have received high praise for their flavor and freshness. Overall, Longley's has the potential to be a great dining destination, but consistency in service and food quality is key to ensuring a satisfying experience.“

“P&M Fine Foods is a deli offering fresh and delicious sandwiches, including hard rolls, wraps, stuffed breads, and focaccia sandwiches. Italian dishes and desserts are also available. Vegetarian options include broccoli rabe, eggplant parmesan, and cheese or veggie pizza. Located near the town center and train station, it features outdoor seating and offers take-out. Plentiful street and lot parking nearby, with a 10-minute walk to the train station.“