12 Best Pizza Restaurants in North Haven

Venezia Pizza Salad •
34 Middletown Ave, North Haven

Customers` Favorites

Sicilian Med 14
Gluten Free
Clam Casino

“This is my absolute favorite pizza restaurant in the North Haven/East Haven area. The pizza is always fantastic and no matter what pie I order I am always delighted with the exquisiteness of the pizza. I believe their Margherita Pizza is the best one I have ever tasted. The personnel are great and always efficient, happy and polite. Can’t wait to return and wouldn’t hesitate to recommend to anyone looking for a great pizza experience.“

5 Superb32 Reviews
Olde World Apizza Pizza • $$
1957 Whitney Ave, North Haven

Customers` Favorites

Bacon and Meatballs
Steak & Cheese Sub
Diet White Birch
Chicken Parmesan
Sausage Pizza
Mashed Potato
White Pizza
Pizzas

“This is the most scrumdidilyumptious piece of sauced circular bread I have ever had the pleasure of putting into my mouth. I drove to the ends of the earth just to savior the mouth watering goodness of Jake’s pizza. He’s the best employee. I always ask for him to make my pizza only the best for me!Parking: Nice“

4.5 Superb53 Reviews
Mangia Apizza Pizza • $$
244 Quinnipiac Ave, North Haven

Customers` Favorites

Large Mozzarella Pizza
Mashed Potato Pizza
Large Cheese Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza
New Haven Pizza

“2024's pizza place of my youth, revisited - tables with benches, old photos on the walls, the guy behind the counter who knows you by sight, and a really good slice of pie. (We didn't have a Vic's next door when I was a kid; that's a bonus.)My husband's a huge fan of their meat lovers. As a vegetarian I prefer a mashed potatoes and pesto, no bacon. Nice size small, too; I've got leftovers from the small I ordered last night. As always, we were both glad we went to Mangia, our favorite pizza place from the moment they opened their doors.I told my husband when we got home that, much as I enjoyed our last date night, which was a restaurant fancier than our usual, there's just something special about getting a New Haven pizza with a glass of PBR.“

4.4 Superb72 Reviews
Antonio's Rt. 5 Pizza • $
528 Washington Ave Suite 2, North Haven

Customers` Favorites

Shrimp and Scallops Florentine with Linguini
Steak and Cheese Panini
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Chicken Francese
Grilled Chicken
Cheese Pizza
Lasagna

“Antonio's was very good! Went for lunch...we all had soup...get this! $3.95. Think you're getting a little cup? NOPE! You get a bowl and it is huge!Penne Carbonara was delicious, also a large portion, shared between 2 people and still, some came home!Chicken Francais was plentiful and came with pasta. Again, large portion and enough to take home for another meal!Bruschetta Appetizer came with 6 thick cut slices of the most wonderful italian bread topped with a perfect blend of tomatoes, garlic, vinegar and whatever else they put in there! Took 1/2 of that home!Overall, very good food, nice atmosphere and friendly, attentive service and the price was most reasonable!!“

4.4 Superb70 Reviews
The Bar Pizza • $$
369 Washington Ave, North Haven

Customers` Favorites

New Haven Style Pizza
Caprese Salad
The Bar

“My friends and I had a wonderful evening at the Bar. The food was very good, great variety to choose from but what I loved most of all was the Ladies nite Special. What a great deal. A glass of wine, appetizers, I chose eggplant rollitini, entree, I chose chicken franchise, and a delicious brownie with fudge and whipped cream for dessert. All for $28.99. Great time and so good. Will b going back!“

4.4 Superb37 Reviews
New Haven Pizza Truck Pizza • $$
86 Leonardo Dr, North Haven

“We had the New Haven Pizza truck for our daughter’s high school graduation party on July 30th. The whole experience was fantastic from start to finish. Made the deposit to book time/day online and Kelly followed up a few days before with the details. Our 50 guests raved about the pizza! Sadly, we were so busy I forgot to take pictures until the last minute but it was a beautiful display too! These guys were punctual and professional! They have their own wooden tables attached to the truck to set up which is so helpful!! And what better way than to end with Gelato and cappuccinos/espressos! Highly recommend booking the New Haven pizza truck if you’re looking to have your next party catered!! You can’t go wrong. ?“

4.6 Superb8 Reviews
Grand Apizza North Pizza • $$
448 Washington Ave, North Haven

Customers` Favorites

Traditional Plain Gluten Free Pizza
Baked Ziti
Calzone
Pie

“Nice little spot, cozy inside and wide variety of food on the menu. The pizza is really good, but it can get expensive the more items you wanna put on it! The soup was fine, wasn't anything special...but the garlic breed with mozzarella was great! And the sauce dip was also great! Something I really liked too is you can order your own liter of soda and just get glasses and share it. Big fan of places that carry foxen park soft drinks too. Service was good, polite staff, and attentive. All around good little pizza spot.“

3.9 Good54 Reviews
Abate Restaurant Pizza • $
61 State St, North Haven

Customers` Favorites

Giant Sicilian with Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza
Plain Cheese Pizza
NY Style Calamari
Clams Casino Pizza
Chicken Parmesan
Fried Calamari
Vodka Penne
Cannolis
Tiramisu

“First time trying Abate Pizza, North Haven. I usually drive 25 minutes, to Zuppardi's, Frisco's, Ernie's or Modern. We tried Abate’s twice to be sure it’s consistant, and the bacon. Mushroom/onion, pepperoni, or sausage pizzas were excellent! .“

3.8 Good84 Reviews
J Roo's Restaurant Italian • $$
243 State Street, 243 Stiles Ln, North Haven

Customers` Favorites

Steak and Cheese Egg Rolls
Chicken Tenders Platter
Burger and Fries
Pepperoni Pizza
Buffalo Wings
Ceasar Salad
Chicken Parm

“Today we hosted a surprise baby shower for our daughter at J. Roos. From the time I booked to the end of our event everything went smoothly and the service was great. Every person I spoke with during the whole process was a delight.The space met our needs and looked great! Our server Johna (sorry if misspelled) was so sweet and on top of everything. She worked hard to make sure everything we needed was met and all our guest all mentioned how polite she was.We chose the brunch buffet option because our daughter enjoys a good brunch and we were not disappointed. The penne ala vodka was delicious! I will definitely consider hosting future events at J. Roos as well as visit at other times to try their other food options.“

3.8 Good96 Reviews
Gagliardis Italian • $$
1899 Hartford Tpke, North Haven

Customers` Favorites

Fresh Clams over Pasta
Veal Cutlets Breaded
Eggplant Rollatini
Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken Cutlet Sub
Fried Calamari
Zuppa D Peace
Garlic Knots
Meatball Sub
Sauce

“Perfect service, was fast, they stayed open a bit late when I didn't realize they were closed, had great food, was super cozy, and the staff did everything they could to make us feel welcome. Best experience I've ever had. Fantastic!!!!! Can't recommend them enough!Created a yelp account just to rave about this place!“

3.7 Good128 Reviews
Mama Rosa's Pizza Italian • $$
352 State St, North Haven

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza Friday Pick Up Special
Steak and Cheese

“One thing that I find very difficult is finding a pizza place that you really like and they consistently stay good. We have found places over the years that we love for a while and then they become inconsistent with the quality. It seems to have happened with every place for the past few decades. I have driven past Mama Rosa's for many years and never tried it out until my child's classmate had a pizza from there and it looked amazing. We decided to try it out and it is now our go-to place for a takeout. They run great nightly specials. They're Philly steak pizza is the best I've had. They season the beef very well and the pizza is a perfect balance. They don't skimp on the cheese. Either( that's something that we've had a problem with where unless you order extra cheese there's not a lot on it). I have never dined in there but always done takeout and the service has been great. They tend to have your food much faster than other places. I highly recommend the Philly steak pizza, their pepperoni's good and has little kick to it, the eggplant parmesan is very good. I look forward to trying more of a variety of items on their menu since there's nothing that we've had that hasn't been good.Kid-friendliness: It has a small dining room but I have seen families in there enjoying the food.Parking: There's a huge parking lot surrounding the restaurant so there is never an issue. SeeWheelchair accessibility: There is a ramp that leads up to the door of the restaurant so there should be no issue for anyone in a wheelchair being able to get into the placeDietary restrictions: They have a sign up that they now have gluten-free items available. I know they have pasta that's gluten-free and I believe they can make pizza dough that is gluten free as well.“

3.5 Good29 Reviews
Bellini's Restaurant Italian • $$
2 Broadway, North Haven

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Breast Stuffed with Prosciutto
Linguine Puttanesca
Eggplant Parmigiana
Penne Alla Vodka
Mozzarella Fritta
Fried Mozzarella
Chicken Parmesan
Pollo Rollatini
Veal Parmesan
Meatballs

“We live in town; this is our go-to place for Italian food. Whenever we bring anyone here for dinner, this is where they want to go next time we see them. We really enjoy lunches there, too. Prices are quite reasonable, excellent food, plenty of it, and genuinely welcoming service staff. The garlic knots in the bread basket are a major plus, too.“

3.6 Good57 Reviews
Loading...
map Map