11 Best Italian Restaurants in North Haven

“Rachel was the nicest hostess I’ve ever had, 10/10 Olive Garden is my favorite restaurant and I would sell my children if that means she is working there for the rest of her life. (Gordon Ramsey would approve because she isn’t an idiot sandwich). (Also don’t worry I’m not a creepy person).“

“I have been going to Aldo’s for many years and think it’s time I left a review. Service - always 10/10, can never do enough for you. Value for money - 10/10. Everything is reasonably priced and the quality is unreal. I’ve probably tried everything on the menu but today I went for the Sunday dinner. Why would you get a roast at an Italian you may wonder, well let me tell you, I am the biggest roast critique as I am pretty good at them myself, but Aldo’s roast is the reason you should get a roast at an Italian. Beef, pink and tender, Yorkshire, fluffy and crispy, mash, buttery and smooth, roasts, caramelised and fluffy, veg, seasoned to perfection, all topped off with a thick shiny gravy. Cannot wait to be back next week for another round. P.S always get the little meatballs as a starter as they are THE tastiest things in the world.“

“Having an outside party? THIS is the best food truck to hire! Today, June 21,2025, I’m at my niece’s graduation party & this food truck was amazing! It’s like having a personal restaurant on your lawn. The pizza was fantastic -THE BEST- actually! Frank made me a gluten free pizza with potato, bacon & carmelized onions. Oh my goodness! It has to be the BEST GF pizza I have ever eaten in my life. Super thin, well cooked! I can’t say enough good things about this pizza. He made all types of pizza. Very organized, clean and so delicious! Wonderful people to talk to! Then they have other services like Gelato Giuliana-between the pizza and the gelato-it is the best of New Haven! Then if that wasn’t enough, he made Italian coffee! I have never been so impressed by a food truck in my life as I was today! Wonderful experience! Best Wishes to Frank & his team! Buon Appetito!“

“Vegetable pizza was just perfect. Cant wait to get there again. Crispy crust with fresh crunchy vegetables was the best vegetable pizza I have ever tasted. All four of us felt the same way. Very clean , simple and friendly place to relax with family and friends.“

“The carbonara is THE BEST!!! I WILL NEVER EAT ANY OTHER 😋“

“FABULOUS FAMILY ITALY ALWAYS“

“Every experience at Carbone's & More has been amazing! The food is absolutely delicious and tastes like authentic homemade Puerto Rican cooking. Even their sauces and desserts are homemade! Everything is fresh, flavorful, and cooked perfectly. You can tell they really care about the quality of their food and the experience they give their customers.
The staff is incredibly friendly and welcoming, and the service was fast and attentive. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, and it really felt like a place where the community comes together over great food.
If you’re looking for authentic Puerto Rican food with amazing flavor and great service, I highly recommend Carbone’s & More. I've been there multiple times! Tastes and feels like home. Wepa!!!“

“Nice place, food was delicious. Service was awesome. Highly recommend it.“

“My family and I were there yesterday celebrating a 21st birthday party. Delicious varieties of pizza and baked ziti was an added surprise. Staff was courteous and friendly. Jim was knocking everything out of the park. Everyone enjoyed their time. Thanks for everything“

“The food was good. The service unfortunately was on the down side. I don't know if it's because it was busy?? We sat for at least a half hour before being asked to order food. The food took another thirty-five minutes to get to the table. 😒“

“It was my first experience, and I am definitely going back there again. The pizza was phenomenal and my guests kept asking where it came from. Full disclosure, I grew up on Wooster Street, and near Modern Pizza, so that is definitely telling you something. 😋“