What are you looking for?

Italian Restaurants in Wallingford

4.5 - 224 votes

Hours: 12 - 10PM

1145 N Colony Rd, Wallingford
(203) 265-2214

Papa Johns Pizza

When your waitress comes over to ask if your done and you turned your burnt eggplant over so the waitress can see that it's black on the bottom and ... More reviews

4.4 - 91 votes

Hours: 11AM - 9PM

69 N Turnpike Rd, Wallingford
(203) 265-9282

Papa Johns Pizza

Found my new favorite pizza joint in Wallingford Great pizza. Crust not too thick - not too thin. Sauce was superb. Toppings and cheese fresh. Baked to p... More reviews

4.5 - 45 votes

Hours: 4 - 9PM

23a S Colony Rd, Wallingford
(203) 303-1894

Papa Johns Pizza

I ordered takeout last Thursday and as always had a great pizza half elm street and the other half mozzarella bacon and onion. . We really love their piz... More reviews

4.3 - 199 votes

Hours: 12 - 9PM

344 Center St, Wallingford
(203) 269-5303

Papa Johns Pizza

I read the reviews and I thought I found a winner. We decided to try it for my wife's birthday on a Sunday night. We walked in and the hostess passe... More reviews

4.3 - 171 votes

Hours: Closed today

950 Yale Ave, Wallingford
(203) 697-9365

Papa Johns Pizza

Went here for the first time last night and the bartender and the service was great! Drinks were great and the food was very good! We will definitely be ... More reviews

4.3 - 135 votes

Hours: 4 - 7PM

118 Dudley Ave, Wallingford
(203) 697-1081

Papa Johns Pizza

Quick service, friendly, good pizza. Quaint little hometown vibes. Very good spot! Definitely a must if you're in the area and hungry. More reviews

4.3 - 110 votes

Hours: Closed today

970 North Colony Road Rt. 5, Wallingford
(203) 265-4200

Papa Johns Pizza

I love Nardelli's and have frequented almost all of their locations between now and the past 10 years or so, but as of the last couple of years they... More reviews

4.2 - 101 votes

Hours: 11AM - 10PM

624 S Colony Rd, Wallingford
(203) 294-9494

Papa Johns Pizza

Great lunch or dinner spot. HUGE variety of items on the menu. Small but quaint dining area. Friendly staff and quick service. Easy access off of Rte 5... More reviews

4.1 - 227 votes

Hours: 11:30AM - 11PM

40 N Main St, Wallingford
(203) 294-1114

Papa Johns Pizza

If I could leave negative stars I would. The owner? Manager? Not really sure, Deb, is outright nasty. I had booked their back room for a rehearsal brunch... More reviews

4.1 - 232 votes

Hours: 12 - 10PM

552 N Colony Rd, Wallingford
(203) 294-4626

Papa Johns Pizza

my boyfriend and i were excited for some chicken parm. we got the $40 deal with salad and bread. we started eating the chicken and soon realized every si... More reviews

View on map