19 Best Pizza Restaurants in Milford

“The food was delicious and the service was attentive and courteous; Definitely going back!“

“By far the BEST pizza in town! I live across town (near West Haven) and get my pizza here every single time! All their specialty pies are OFF THE CHARTS amazing - love the sauce on the pies!!! Stacy who works typically on Fridays, is by far the nicest, friendliest, and best server at the window!!! They are all great people but she makes the visit even more special as she engages with each and every customer that comes by to pick up their orders! LOVE LOVE LOVE Papa's Pizza on Naugy Ave!!!!“

“Came in last night with a few girlfriends and everything was excellent! The portions are so huge that we were able to split 4 appetizers and, if we ended up getting entrées, we wouldn’t have been able to finish the delicious vintage carnival dessert! Our waitress was a doll and warned us that the dessert was a big portion. No, it was colossal and magnificent. You will definitely become a go to spot for girls night out in the future.“

“Tl;dr: great ny style pizza, good friendly people, highly recommended! The long story: Ive been wanting a sourdough pizza for quite some time. We heard about this place and it was close so we had to check it out. Sooo glad we did! Thats some of the best pizza ive had EVER! Its sold as a new york style sourdough pizza so dont go in there expecting pepe’s/sallys/modern, but also dont let that deter you! This is a damn good pizza in its own right. The sourdough crust and base was thicker than the new haven style joints, but not too thick, and it was soft and easy to bite and chew though unlike some places that you really have to work your muscles to chew through, and yet it still had enough strength to hold the cheese and toppings and not fall apart. The sauce is quite possibly my favorite anywhere. It is saltier/tangy-er than most, but lends its flavor well to the rest of the pie and i loved it! The cheese is good and was stringy and gooey like a good hot pizza should be. It was easy to bite through and not thick and rubbery and had very good flavor. I ordered pepperoni and green peppers for toppings. The peppers are fresh sliced bell peppers and had a nice flavor though they could have been cooked a tad longer or even been slightly pre cooked, but it really didnt detract much if at all from the pizza. The pepperoni was delicious and was the type that curls and gets slightly burnt and crunchy along the edges and it wasnt too greasy. And like i said, the crust was excellent. The un-initiated might think eww gross- sour dough?!?!, but thats not the case. In fact you barely notice the flavor except that its slightly tart/sour. Its not overpowering and you barely notice it, but yet it adds another dimension to the flavor of the pizza. So with the combination of all that, you get a really great pizza with wonderful flavor, and is meant to be picked up by the slice, folded and eaten just like they do in ny! Dont get me wrong, i love me some new haven pizza, but this is so deliciously different, but yet not all that different from the new haven pies we’re used to. This pie may even un-throne a few of those places as my new favorite! The staff was friendly and efficient, and the prices weren’t horrible. You can do take out or eat in, but if you eat in, you serve yourself and clean up when youre done. This place is a little out of my way to get to but has definitely been put on my list of favorites and id highly recommend it to anyone!“

“My family and I just moved to Milford… I gotta tell you this place is definitely worth a Stop. PAPA SCOTT Makes a mean pizza and the atmosphere is warm and inviting. Behind the counter, Kym’s got a big smile and a super helpful… But the best part is the pizza! Exceptionally tasty, awesome, and crunchy, undercarriage and playful toppings!!!!“

“The best pizza in Milford and the surrounding area—I recommend it one hundred percent. Delicious ☺️ and the service is excellent. Best of luck!“

“Best Mexican food around! 👌🏼“

“I don’t typically leave reviews and I will always recommend Colony Grill as it is my favorite pizza! However, the past few times I have ordered from Milford colony it’s like eating a tortilla- tonight I ordered there and the pizza was even thinner - the quality of the pizza has been going downhill for a while now yet the quantity of toppings available have been increasing. Please, stick to what you know and bring back the amazing pizza I know this is. Paper thin tonight, not a lot of sauce mostly cheese and my pizza wasn’t even sliced. Very disappointed - but I refuse to give up on Colony!“

“Best salad ever !!! Garlic knots were delicious,so was the meatball sub??“

“This restaurant is a hit or miss, I saw the ratings and I though it might be bad but I gave it a try and it was amazing, for my family and I loved the food. We got a large pizza and it was amazing, they get local prudence and everything was fresh!“

“Slices is great and you can’t beat the prices. The owner is one of the nicest people I have ever met. Support this small business!!!!“

“This pizza is by far the best I’ve ever had. Better than any New Haven style pizza. I’ve been goin for years. And on top of that the price is very reasonable and the people are so very nice. Highly recommended. I live in New Haven but work near the restaurant so I stillOrder it.“

“Just ordered a large NY Style Buffalo Chicken Pizza. It arrived within the required 30-45 minutes window. Hot & Delicious ! Delivery person was pleasant and on time“

“The staff is great and friendly and helpful. Every time. The orders come out quick. The restaurant is very clean. They have a great menu and everything is amazing. As somebody born and raised in Milford, I I’m a bit of a pizza connoisseur and since I have been on a restrictive diet, this has also been the best gluten-free pizza I have had around here. They really know what they’re doing and take pride in their work. Great location near exit 36 easy on and off the highway. Highly recommend.“

“I've been a customer for over 10 years, and both their Italian, and Mexican food is excellent. The delivery workers, Chefs, and employees who take the orders on the phone are very kind, hard working, and talented. Just want to thank them, and give them the recognition they deserve. Having worked in the F&B industry for over 20 years in NYC, I appreciate a place like this on nights when I'm too lazy to cook.“

“I ordered catered food for the first time today. Everyone enjoyed their delicious food!“

“Whole Foods has made-to-order large vegan pizzas for $11, which is amazing and a fraction of the cost anywhere else. I think they can be even cheaper than that if you order them on Fridays, but I don't remember the deal off the top of my head. For the store itself, their 365 brand is great and reasonably priced. Whole Foods has gotten a lot more affordable since the Amazon acquisition. They regularly have deals and sales on vegan brands so they're worth checking out.“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ We celebrated my daughter Stephanie’s Police Academy graduation here, and it was absolutely perfect. From the moment we arrived, the atmosphere was warm, welcoming, and celebratory exactly what we hoped for on such a meaningful day. The food was delicious, beautifully presented, and consistently excellent across the table. Every dish was flavorful and prepared with care. The service was attentive, kind, and made our family feel genuinely valued. What made the night truly special was how smoothly everything ran. Our guests were comfortable, happy, and full always a good sign! It created the perfect setting to honor Stephanie’s hard work and huge accomplishment. We are so grateful for such a wonderful experience and highly recommend this spot for special occasions, family celebrations, and milestone moments. Thank you for helping us create memories we’ll cherish forever. 💙“

“This is my second time going. Highly recommend. The food and the owner are both authentic Italian. You can't go wrong.“