Papa's Pizza
$$ • PizzaAbout Papa's Pizza
Customers' Favorites
A Pizza Di Erica Deva's Delight
Sausage and Hot Cherry Peppers
A Pizza Di Sony Old School
Tomato and Parmesan Pizza
Mozzarella Cheese Pizza
Work's Red Vegi Pizza
Half Cheese Half Pep
Pizza with Broccoli
A Pizza Di Gardenia
A Pizza Di Big Dawg
Papa's Pizza Reviews
163 ratings
Share your opinion about Papa's Pizza
Highly underrated, been to all the New Haven style and personally this was a favorite. Generous size with awesome quality sausage.
So good! Add this spot to your CT pizza trail list. The only negative is that there’s no seating, but no big deal. I enjoyed it in my car.
Always busy but worth the wait. One of the best spots on the gold coast
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 7PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 7PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 6PM |
Papa's Pizza is a take-out pizza and pasta restaurant that offers a variety of options. They serve New Haven-style pizza with customizable toppings and specialty pies with thicker, Naples-style crusts. Customers praise the quality of the fresh, made-to-order pies and the attentive service. Many reviews highlight the great tasty pies cooked to perfection, with special mentions for the shrimp and bacon. It is also noted that all their specialty pies are amazing, especially the sauce. The restaurant is considered one of the best pizza places in the area, and it is appreciated for its friendly staff, particularly a server who engages warmly with customers. Papa's Pizza continues to be a popular choice for those looking for delicious pizza in Milford.