35 Best Pizza Restaurants near Guilford

“We used Pasta Avest to cater our daughter’s birthday party. They were professional and easy to work with. Food was DELICIOUS and prices are very reasonable. Thank you again!“

“AMAZING ONCE AGAIN!!! The best pizza truck ever! Fantastic pizza, service and all around great experience! This is our second go around for another grad party and they did not disappoint! It’s a 10 !“

“Authentic and unique: SO GOOD! My wife is Italian and she swears by this restaurant. Her Italian born grandmother brought her here and yes it is delicious!

Wheelchair accessibility: My wife was able to use all the facilities from her wheelchair.“

“Authentic. The Matt & Melissa are experts in real Italian cooking and wines. Authors of “The Italian Farmer's Table: Authentic Recipes and Local Lore from Northern Italy” & of lovers of that #MionettoStyle“

“Picked up a chicken Parmesan stuffed bread on Sunday and took it home ...reheated it ...it was soooo yummy. Wished I had 2-3 more. Their pizza crust is so good very old style.“

“Pizza is fantastic and the rest of the menu is equally as such. AMAZING food all around. Angelo is also awesome. Whole place is great. Everything about it.“

“Even though it was pouring down rain, our group stayed cozy & dry under the large tent and the sound of the rain was nice background music! BYOB & my garden salad with pizza was delicious! Thank you“

“Delicious every time! Definitely try the penne vodka or sausage and peppers. We order trays upon trays for our events like birthdays, holidays, etc. The food is always phenomenal, always on time, and the employees are nice enough to help bring them out to the car.“

“Great food and super friendly staff !!“

“I think the staff is just great, the pizza is the best in town and I'm always surprised there's not a line of people waiting to get in. I always get take-out, and around the holidays pick up their delicious stuffed breads. A really nice business and the food is just great.“

“Came all the way from Ohio for some New Haven style pizza and this one didn't disappoint! Friendly staff and reasonably priced! Highly recommend!!!“

“I'm really picky about my pizza and today I tried their for the first time. AMAZING.“

“Portofino’s has the best pizza in Madison hands down! We have tried their Fresco, margarita 2, their sausage and their pepperon all excellent. We even have gotten their lasagna for parties and their stuffed breads. I love their Gorgonzola salad. We get pizza every Friday delivered and it always come hot and delicious.“

“Bobby’s Pizza has been a local favorite for over 30 years, known for its consistently excellent thin-crust pizza. As a pizza lover, I can say Bobby’s nails the perfect balance between crispy and chewy with their thin slices. The crust is light yet sturdy enough to hold the toppings without becoming soggy, offering that satisfying crunch when you take a bite.

The sauce is tangy with a hint of sweetness, complementing the fresh, gooey cheese that stretches with every bite. Bobby’s doesn’t skimp on quality, ensuring every slice is flavorful without being overly heavy. Whether you go for a simple cheese slice or a fully loaded pie with pepperoni and veggies, each bite is a testament to the care they’ve put into their craft over the decades.

Operating for over 30 years, Bobby’s remains a go-to spot for pizza enthusiasts who appreciate the simplicity and perfection of a well-made slice. It’s the kind of place that keeps you coming back for more, and with good reason. That’s why they call me the pizza gavone.“

“Everything was delicious as always yesterday for our superbowl party. Thank you so much!“

“the food is delicious!! the stuffed breads are amazing and well stuffed!!“

“Stopped by on our way through CT from Long Island. Was pleasantly surprised with how great this pizza was! A little on the greasy side but nothing you couldn’t pick up with a napkin. The only “negative” was the inside is very plain. Not a ton a decor, but that’s not really important. Would deff come “

“Great restaurant and great staff!!“

“Best pizza in town, place is newly renovated serving New Haven style thin sliced pizza. Staff is very friendly and very fast service.“

“My new favorite pizza place. Pizza was amazing,(Baked potato pizza) the house made dressing is great, must try! Easily top 3 canoli, probably the best I've ever had, only thing better then the food was the service and accommodations. Really great experience, can wait to come back“

“Nowadays, as we all know, everything is stupid expensive. So since that is a given, I can only feel that I was not robbed if I receive a product that is worth these exorbitant prices. Benny J's Pizza is such an excellent restaurant that when I get food from there I feel like I Won! The food is absolutely delicious & I've had sandwiches, pizza, calzones, salad & def more! Every single thing I've ordered from Benny J's has been excellent! Never once was my order the least bit shy of perfect. On top of the great quality of the food, Benny J's also gives you portions that end up being TWO big meals! And, somehow, the food is just as good the 2nd time! I highly recommend Benny J's, if you couldn't already tell ?! Worth every penny, every time!“

“I finally made it into the market today after hearing so many good things about it for so long. I’m so glad I did! I’m usually not a fan of prepared foods, but got a selection of their offerings for the week. Everything I’ve tried has been absolutely outstanding, each dish better than the last. The panecotte Is better than some I’ve had in five star restaurants and that’s after taking it home and reheating it. I’ve been very happy with all the other dishes as well and I’m so glad I found this local spot and will be going there much more frequently.“

“We are so lucky to live near Dino's! The food is great, and Dino even makes carbonara for my husband even though it is not on the menu.“

“Great local place. Friendly atmosphere and very good food!“

“We have been enjoying Chow for years and everything we have ever had from them has been delicious but yesterday… Father’s Day, they went above and beyond! They were packed and after waiting for a while for my take out order (understandable for a busy night) they confessed and profusely apologized because in the rush of the busy evening one of my pizzas had been dropped. Without missing a beat they promised my pizzas would be remade and delivered to my house…. Half hour away!!! That is stellar customer service!!! So, amazing food AND wonderful customer service, what more could anyone want?!“

“What I had , lasagna, was tasty. My wife didn't enjoy the lobster ravioli though. But, only one visit there and was at an off hour so can't fully review. Very reasonably priced. Pizza was very good, new haven style. Will go back.“

“Awesome spaghetti and meatball pizza and Hawiian too! Dave is Great guy m/“

“Have to admit, one of the best pizza I have had in a long time. And the Caesar salad is to die for. The ambiance is superb especially sitting outside just across the street from the beach. But there’s no reason we should wait for over an hour for pizza. I mean - it’s just pizza. It shouldn’t take more than 20 mins to make. even on a Friday night. Get a bigger pizza oven or a second one. Seriously.“

“The pizza is outstanding. But never get soda there! $4 for a liter of soda is outrageous. So they’re price gouging bad right now. I’ll look for somewhere else to go next time.⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Always the best food no matter what you order. Kindest people I've ever met!!! Definitely recommend!!!!“

“Our favorite pizza place! Everything on the menu is delicious! We order Red Tomato every Friday!“

“I was in town on an estimate and had 30 minutes to kill. Stopped in for a couple slices. The pizza was so delicious. The gentleman was so kind. He had his step daughter "Angela" with him a 4 year old who sat down with me and kept me company. She was adorable. I think I would actually come back down here for the pizza and I live in waterbury it was that good.“

“They catered my daughters 40th birthday and everything was absolutely delicious! From the salad, the pizza with so many selections and the gelato our family and friends are still talking about how delicious everything was! We will definitely have them back to cater another party for us !“

“I am a big fan of B & W’s overall food quality especially the variety of salads, especially the tunafish & fruit. Met a woman from Branford who comes especially for their Broccoli & Tunasalad a ***** always fresh. The homemade dressings delish especially the Honey Lime my favorite. Yes standing in line is never easy but servers work very hard to keep up with food requests & always willing to make the selections exactly as requested. We on the Shoreline fortunate to have such a great place to order such a variety of home cooked food.“

“Always our “go-to” pizza place in Branford, CT. Deliciously consistent, New Haven style pizza with quality ingredients. 5 ⭐️’s!“