Jerry and The Mermaid

Name: Jerry and The Mermaid
Address: 469 E Main St, Riverhead, New York, 11901, US
Telephone: (855) 445-3072
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.6

$$ • Seafood, American, Bars

Hours:
469 E Main St, Riverhead
(855) 445-3072

Menu Order Online Reserve

About Jerry and The Mermaid

Jerry and The Mermaid is a popular seafood restaurant known for its friendly staff, delicious dishes, and lively atmosphere. Customers frequently praise the fresh oysters and flavorful espresso martinis, as well as the chef's attentive approach to ensuring a pleasant dining experience. The restaurant has received glowing reviews about the broiled combo, which includes white fish, shrimp, and bay scallops, noted for being fresh and generously portioned. The fried soft shell crab sandwich is also a must-have, being perfectly crispy without being greasy. Despite high demand, the restaurant strives to accommodate guests and provide a memorable visit. The owner, Jerry, is often mentioned for his welcoming presence, and the wait staff is described as helpful and friendly, enhancing the overall experience. With a beautiful view of the pier and a rich history, Jerry and The Mermaid is highly recommended for anyone seeking excellent seafood cuisine. Recent visitors highlight the outstanding service, with staff members like Kim and Sam praised for their attentiveness, politeness, and knowledge. One guest hosted a rehearsal dinner and commended Jerry for his exceptional hospitality, noting the professional and friendly team that made the event seamless. Another guest, new to leaving reviews, shared that the service and food were unmatched, especially enjoying the lobster roll and peanut butter pie, which brought joy after a difficult trip. Overall, the restaurant offers a combination of fresh seafood, excellent service, and a warm, lively atmosphere.