Prestano Bakery
$ • Bakery, Donuts, BagelsAbout Prestano Bakery
Customers' Favorites
Chocolate Strawberry Shortcake
Boston Cream Donut Jelly Donut
7 Cheesecake with Fruit
Black and White Cookie
Italian Pastry 1 lb
2 Eggs and 1 Item
Assorted Cookies
Red Velvet Cake
Semolina Bread
Sausage Bread
Prestano Bakery Reviews
147 ratings
Share your opinion about Prestano Bakery
Got bagels, jelly donut, and sprinkle cookies. Jelly donut was heavy with jelly. Out of this world!
I came for one bagel. Now I judge every other bagel shop against this one, and they all lose. Best egg sandwiches in Suffolk County, amazing bagels, fair prices, and worth every bite. My only complaint? They ruined all other bagels for me. 🍳🥯
Love this bakery everyone is so nice and never have any issues getting what I need 😃♥
Hours
| Monday | 5AM - 7PM |
| Tuesday | 5AM - 7PM |
| Wednesday | 5AM - 7PM |
| Thursday | 5AM - 7PM |
| Friday | 5AM - 7PM |
| Saturday | 5AM - 7PM |
| Sunday | 5AM - 6PM |
Prestano Bakery is a standout among bakeries, offering an impressive selection of baked goods, including exceptional donuts and a variety of bagels with cream cheeses, such as the spicy jalapeno cheddar. Customers appreciate the family-owned atmosphere and the warm environment that makes for a delightful experience. The bakery is known for its beautiful and delicious cakes, which have received praise from many. While some customers have noted that the bagels seem different compared to what they remember, they still enjoy the treats offered. Friendly staff contribute to the positive experience, and whether stopping in for a breakfast sandwich, pastry, or bread, customers can expect fresh and delicious options that generally satisfy. Many visitors have praised the bakery for maintaining the tradition of New York-style baked goods, with some returning multiple times for breakfast sandwiches on amazing rolls or jelly donuts that are described as heavenly. The bakery also offers Italian bread that is always fresh, even late in the day. Overall, Prestano Bakery provides a warm, friendly environment with a wide variety of freshly baked treats that appeal to both locals and visitors seeking a true taste of New York cuisine.