Amazing service and food!! Every time I go there the experience gets better. My amazing waiter and all the supporting staff always make sure we are super welcome. I would pick Matteo's over Peter Lugar ANYDAY!!
Ralph
Food was really good, quiet too. They had a 40 dollar per person menu which had great value
Michael
I had my favorite dish there, the pork chop ultimo, but on this single occasion veal was somewhat tough and dry. I have had many occasions in the past and it was perfect.
Kathy Fradelakis
We recently had our son's graduation party at Matteo's, and the entire experience exceeded our expectations. The food was absolutely amazing—every dish was fresh, flavorful, and beautifully prepared. What truly made the event special, though, was the outstanding service. The staff went above and beyond to make sure everything ran smoothly and that all of our guests felt welcomed and well taken care of.
From start to finish, their attention to detail, professionalism, and genuine hospitality made our celebration stress-free and memorable. We couldn't have asked for a better place to celebrate such an important milestone. Thank you to everyone at Matteo's for helping make our son's graduation party such a wonderful success. We highly recommend Matteo's for any special occasion!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
H F
Love this place , best service, manager is on top of things , staff is great! Food excellent!
Alexandra
Great as always. Greeted at the front pleasantly. Seated right away. Waitress came over right away to offer drinks and give us menus. Ordered and food was delivered timely. The food was large portioned and delicious. Definitely recommend any night of the week.
Diane
The price fixe dinner is such a wonderful meal with so many outstanding choices. This is one of my favorite restaurants. It's consistently good!
Robert
Matteo's is a great place for dinner. Invariably the service is friendly and attentive. The menu is varied and all the selections are delicious. We've tried the fired calamari, chicken sorrentino, eggplant parm, pork chop ultimo and several deserts and these are all really good.
Dan Bara
Absolutely top notch of food & service... This restaurant is the O.G. of Italian in long Island!!! I highly recommend everything they have to offer, best of the best!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Doreen
We had a party of six and all our dinners were delicious and reasonably priced. Very good service and nice atmosphere.
Matteo's is my favorite special occasion place to eat! The food, ambiance and service are all top-notch. And to top it off, during the week they have a well-priced 3 course dinner menu.
Didier
The place was great to watch the knick game and have a great meal during long island restaurant week
Saul
Really good food and attentive service and the restaurant week menu was robust and reasonably priced.
Bobbi
Last night we enjoyed yet another wonderful dinner at Matteo's. The choices were expansive and everything from appetizers to entrees to desserts was absolutely delicious! The portions were more than plentiful and... all from their midweek special menu, including a glass of wine. The big surprise was the Spring Special! All three courses PLUS a glass of delicious wine for $39.99! Even the price is wonderful. Go ahead and enjoy ; we will be back again very soon!
Marsha
Food, was great, service was great. A little noisy, but i have hearing loss with hearing aids. They are very accommodating and service was great too.
Amazing service and food!! Every time I go there the experience gets better. My amazing waiter and all the supporting staff always make sure we are super welcome. I would pick Matteo's over Peter Lugar ANYDAY!!
Food was really good, quiet too. They had a 40 dollar per person menu which had great value
I had my favorite dish there, the pork chop ultimo, but on this single occasion veal was somewhat tough and dry. I have had many occasions in the past and it was perfect.
We recently had our son's graduation party at Matteo's, and the entire experience exceeded our expectations. The food was absolutely amazing—every dish was fresh, flavorful, and beautifully prepared. What truly made the event special, though, was the outstanding service. The staff went above and beyond to make sure everything ran smoothly and that all of our guests felt welcomed and well taken care of.
From start to finish, their attention to detail, professionalism, and genuine hospitality made our celebration stress-free and memorable. We couldn't have asked for a better place to celebrate such an important milestone. Thank you to everyone at Matteo's for helping make our son's graduation party such a wonderful success. We highly recommend Matteo's for any special occasion!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love this place , best service, manager is on top of things , staff is great! Food excellent!
Great as always. Greeted at the front pleasantly. Seated right away. Waitress came over right away to offer drinks and give us menus. Ordered and food was delivered timely. The food was large portioned and delicious. Definitely recommend any night of the week.
The price fixe dinner is such a wonderful meal with so many outstanding choices. This is one of my favorite restaurants. It's consistently good!
Matteo's is a great place for dinner. Invariably the service is friendly and attentive. The menu is varied and all the selections are delicious. We've tried the fired calamari, chicken sorrentino, eggplant parm, pork chop ultimo and several deserts and these are all really good.
Absolutely top notch of food & service... This restaurant is the O.G. of Italian in long Island!!! I highly recommend everything they have to offer, best of the best!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had a party of six and all our dinners were delicious and reasonably priced. Very good service and nice atmosphere.
Restaurantji Recommends
Matteo's is my favorite special occasion place to eat! The food, ambiance and service are all top-notch. And to top it off, during the week they have a well-priced 3 course dinner menu.
The place was great to watch the knick game and have a great meal during long island restaurant week
Really good food and attentive service and the restaurant week menu was robust and reasonably priced.
Last night we enjoyed yet another wonderful dinner at Matteo's. The choices were expansive and everything from appetizers to entrees to desserts was absolutely delicious! The portions were more than plentiful and... all from their midweek special menu, including a glass of wine. The big surprise was the Spring Special! All three courses PLUS a glass of delicious wine for $39.99! Even the price is wonderful. Go ahead and enjoy ; we will be back again very soon!
Food, was great, service was great. A little noisy, but i have hearing loss with hearing aids. They are very accommodating and service was great too.
Loading...