Custom Cakes near Rye, NY

1 Carvel Express

5.0 Superb 2 Reviews

Playland Pkwy, Rye

2 Just Desserts by Jess

5.0 Superb 39 Reviews

810 Commerce St, Thornwood · 10.96 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The best specialty cookies ever. Jess pays such close attention to detail in her work. The cake pops are beautiful and delicious- best I have ever had and my guests agreed! She is extremely responsive and attentive. Go to Just Desserts by Jess for all of your needs!”

3 Steph's Sweet Creations Dessert Boutique

4.9 Superb 47 Reviews

137 Willett Ave, Port Chester · 1.91 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Steph and her sister Evette were absolutely amazing. I was recommended by a friend to try Steph’s sweet creation because I was looking for a place to make the desserts for my sisters bridal shower. From the moment we walked in I knew we were in the right place.Evette was so welcoming answered all our questions and helped us with every detail from what kind of desserts,flavors and colors to match the theme. Everyone at the shower loved the desserts and kept asking where did you get these there’s so good. I def will be a forever customer and will be using Steph’s for all my events! Thank you girls for making my sisters shower amazing!”

4 La Flor De Jalisco Bakery

4.7 Superb 64 Reviews

217 Westchester Ave, Port Chester · 1.75 miles

• Take-Out

“I ordered a cake for my daughter’s Sweet Sixteen for August 14, 2021. I provided a picture of the design of what she wanted to the bakery, and spoke to the owner about making a few minor details. The cake came out absolutely beautiful! She was on point with every detail. It was delivered on time, and it was absolutely delicious! I highly recommend La Flor De Jalisco for all your special bakery needs or just to stop by and sample all their delicious treats. They are responsible, friendly and professional! They are now my go to bakery!!! Thank you again to the owner, Lilia for helping to make my daughter’s Sweet Sixteen a success!”

5 Sisters Confections

5.0 Superb 14 Reviews

143 Manorhaven Blvd, Port Washington · 9.79 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“It’s incredibly difficult to find a bakery that can make a delicious gluten-free free cake, but Sisters has not only nailed the recipe they have also set a very high standard! Those of us who have to be GF constantly lower our expectations. That’s just how it is! My birthday cake was the most delicious cake I’ve ever had and it was gorgeous! Thank you so much for the attention to detail and for being such amazing bakers! ???”

6 Boiano Bakery

4.5 Superb 68 Reviews

258 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck · 3.36 miles

• Take-Out

“OMG! This place! I cant BELIEVE ive lived in Harrison for 25 years and never knew this amazing little nugget stayed open at night with a bubbly staff, the most amazing Sfiogatelle and coffee fresh and brewed to perfection…not too strong, not even slightly burnt! My hubby had the italian cheesecake…also delicious. Im on my way there now…in a storm! (YES THAT GOOD) :)”

7 Carvel

4.5 Superb 42 Reviews

325 Webster Ave, New Rochelle · 7.35 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“The service is exceptional - when choosing ice cream cakes, always willing to provide advice and take the time to personalize and make each one special. The ice cream cakes are freshly made here and by far the best. Ice cream and shakes are also great at this location. Finally, the equipment is well maintained and sanitary. Carvel does one thing - ice cream - and at Webster Ave it is done right!”

8 Baked With Love by Abigail

5.0 Superb 3 Reviews

1050 Seven Oaks Ln, Mamaroneck · 3.3 miles

• Delivery

“I can’t say enough about Baked with Love by Abigail. The cupcakes and cookies were amazing if I could give you 10 stars I would. Thank you so much for making this day even more special.”

9 Petite Sweets by Donna

5.0 Superb 3 Reviews

41 Dimsdale Dr, Scarsdale · 7.25 miles

“Donna made my engagement cookies and brownies for our engagement party. The brownies were sooo delicious and the cookies came out so cute!”

10 By the Way Bakery

4.3 Superb 64 Reviews

19 E Putnam Ave, Greenwich · 4.63 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Outstanding whoopee pies!!”

11 Flowerbake by Angela

3.9 Good 9 Reviews

494 New Rochelle Rd, Bronxville · 7.46 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Angela is immeasurably talented and the cake she made for my daughter's birthday was truly exceptional - both in design and taste. As a bonus, Angela was delightful to work with and helped bring my daughter's dream cake to fruition. If you're looking for a custom cake, I couldn't recommend Flowerbake more highly!”

12 Carvel

4.1 Good 24 Reviews

233 E Main St, New Rochelle · 6.48 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The service is satisfactory. Plenty of flavors and toppings to choose from.”

13 Gelato&Cioccolato

3.9 Good 53 Reviews

232 E Putnam Ave, Cos Cob · 6 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Ottimo 👏 lavoro . Gelato come in Italia”

14 Cold Stone Creamery

3.6 Good 100 Reviews

993 Central Park Ave, Scarsdale · 7.3 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Eliza is one of the kindest, most professional employees I’ve encountered at Cold Stone in Scarsdale. She always greets with a smile, stays patient, and truly cares about customers. It’s upsetting to see adults leave condescending reviews just because she clarified they don’t serve rolled ice cream. Being a teenager doesn’t make her any less capable & she consistently goes above and beyond. Eliza, you’re doing amazing! Your kindness, maturity, and work ethic don’t go unnoticed. Cold Stone is lucky to have you! 💛”