13 Best Steakhouses near Rye

“As I stepped into Frankie and Johnnie's Steakhouse in Rye, NY, I knew I was in for a memorable evening. From the moment we were greeted at the door to the final bite of dessert, every aspect of our birthday celebration was impeccable.

The ambiance was sophisticated yet inviting, with dim lighting and cozy seating creating the perfect atmosphere for a special occasion. The staff went above and beyond to ensure our experience was nothing short of exceptional, catering to our every need with professionalism and warmth.

Now, onto the star of the show: the food. Frankie and Johnnie's Steakhouse exceeded all expectations with their mouthwatering selection of prime cuts. Each steak was cooked to perfection, with a charred exterior giving way to a tender, juicy center bursting with flavor. The sides were equally impressive, from the creamy mashed potatoes to the crisp asparagus spears.

Of course, no birthday celebration would be complete without dessert, and Frankie and Johnnie's did not disappoint. We indulged in their decadent chocolate lava cake and rich New York cheesecake, both of which were the perfect sweet endings to an unforgettable meal.

Overall, our experience at Frankie and Johnnie's Steakhouse was nothing short of phenomenal. From the impeccable service to the exquisite cuisine, every detail was carefully curated to ensure a truly memorable birthday celebration. I can't wait for the opportunity to return and create more cherished memories at this exceptional restaurant.“

“Best steak I have had in a long time, service was impeccable. Will be back“

“I had the pleasure of dining at Lenny's Steakhouse last night, and it was truly a wonderful experience from start to finish. The ambiance was warm and welcoming, with just the right mix of elegance and comfort. The service was impeccable — friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable without ever feeling intrusive. Our server made great recommendations and ensured everything ran smoothly throughout the evening. Now, the food — absolutely fantastic. I started with the lobster soup which was beautifully presented and packed with flavor. For the main course, I had the sniper cooked to perfection and served with seasonal sides that complemented it perfectly. We ended with a shared dessert of Key Lime Pie, which was the perfect sweet note to finish the meal. Overall, it was a memorable dining experience. Whether you're celebrating something special or just want a quality meal in a great setting, I'd highly recommend Lenny's Steakhouse. I'm already looking forward to going back!“

“Went for Fathers Day. The Fix Price menu prompted us to order Salads, you got vegetables, and 3 Filet Mignons and a Rib Eye bone in. The House Salad is chopped included vegetables and avacado. It was 6 inches high covering a full dinner plate! The service was consistent of leaving us alone, yet being immediately attentive. Water glasses filled, ample bread filled basket, and changeover between courses properly timed. They had a single desert in the package, however allowed a substitution for ice cream instead. Nice touch.“

“Phenomenal experience. Top notch food, atmosphere, and wait staff. Have been here multiple times, and every time is an amazing experience all around. The food is always superb and the bar is amazing. Definitely a lifetime customer!“

“Went here with my family after my daughters Graduation it was Wednesday at 1:00pm it was not busy the waiter treated us so good the Chef sent out a pasta appetizer dish for us to try.
The food was unbelievable the service was outstanding we couldn’t ask for better service from them for sure would recommend to everyone
Thank You Ridges“

“Terrific, but pricey. About $250 pp with tip.“

“If you want to experience the finest steakhouse dining in NY look no further!! From food Quality, ambience, to exceptional service Benjamins steakhouse has it all. It’s an absolute must! Cannot recommended highly enough.“

“The food and service were fantastic.“

“Dinner was fantastic! Music by DJ Bobby Flowers & Jerry Brown was awesome! Chef Rocco of Chef Rocco Dessert Creations Demonstration and delicious desserts was simply incredible! Can’t wait to go back again for Chef Rocco, DJ Bobby and Jerry’s next show♥️“

“Celebrated my birthday party 🥳 thanks Blackstone“

“It was my first time visiting and I was pleased! My server-Austin was exceptional! He was attentive, courteous and efficient. He took care of my table as well as another servers table as he passed by.

The dinner rolls with cinnamon butter were to die for. I ordered the steak and shrimp with mashed potatoes and vegetables and it was absolutely divine. My boyfriend ordered the catfish with with seasoned rice and chili, and it was amazing. Looking forward to returning and ordering more you will not be disappointed.“

“I had a great experience at this steakhouse! The atmosphere was lively, and the music really set the tone for a fun and enjoyable evening. Our waiter was incredibly attentive—always checking in at just the right time without being overbearing. The food came out hot and was absolutely delicious. From start to finish, everything was on point. I'll definitely be coming back!“