13 Best Steakhouses near Rye

“As I stepped into Frankie and Johnnie's Steakhouse in Rye, NY, I knew I was in for a memorable evening. From the moment we were greeted at the door to the final bite of dessert, every aspect of our birthday celebration was impeccable.

The ambiance was sophisticated yet inviting, with dim lighting and cozy seating creating the perfect atmosphere for a special occasion. The staff went above and beyond to ensure our experience was nothing short of exceptional, catering to our every need with professionalism and warmth.

Now, onto the star of the show: the food. Frankie and Johnnie's Steakhouse exceeded all expectations with their mouthwatering selection of prime cuts. Each steak was cooked to perfection, with a charred exterior giving way to a tender, juicy center bursting with flavor. The sides were equally impressive, from the creamy mashed potatoes to the crisp asparagus spears.

Of course, no birthday celebration would be complete without dessert, and Frankie and Johnnie's did not disappoint. We indulged in their decadent chocolate lava cake and rich New York cheesecake, both of which were the perfect sweet endings to an unforgettable meal.

Overall, our experience at Frankie and Johnnie's Steakhouse was nothing short of phenomenal. From the impeccable service to the exquisite cuisine, every detail was carefully curated to ensure a truly memorable birthday celebration. I can't wait for the opportunity to return and create more cherished memories at this exceptional restaurant.“

“Best steak I have had in a long time, service was impeccable. Will be back“

“Great place to meet Frands . Delicious food - the best New York strip ever , services, phenomenal, & friendly , love the new items added to the menu. Worth the price for quality they serve. . Can't wait for you guys to come to Stanford !“

“My wife and I enjoyed our evening. Johnny our server recommended the porterhouse and it was one of the best we've had but the sides were the star of the show. Wild mushrooms in truffle cream were unbelievable and the fries were crisp and delicious.“

“I went on the weekday night. Smart decision! Weekend will need to wait I think. I ordered ribeye and my friend had New York strip steak. We all love the food. One of the best steak I ever had. And he was very generous and gave a dessert on the house. This restaurant is not in my neighborhoods, but will come again when I pass by.“

“Phenomenal experience. Top notch food, atmosphere, and wait staff. Have been here multiple times, and every time is an amazing experience all around. The food is always superb and the bar is amazing. Definitely a lifetime customer!“

“The food and service were fantastic.“

“Terrific, but pricey. About $250 pp with tip.“

“Dinner was fantastic! Music by DJ Bobby Flowers & Jerry Brown was awesome! Chef Rocco of Chef Rocco Dessert Creations Demonstration and delicious desserts was simply incredible! Can’t wait to go back again for Chef Rocco, DJ Bobby and Jerry’s next show♥️“

“If you want to experience the finest steakhouse dining in NY look no further!! From food Quality, ambience, to exceptional service Benjamins steakhouse has it all. It’s an absolute must! Cannot recommended highly enough.“

“Celebrated my birthday party 🥳 thanks Blackstone“

“It was my first time visiting and I was pleased! My server-Austin was exceptional! He was attentive, courteous and efficient. He took care of my table as well as another servers table as he passed by.

The dinner rolls with cinnamon butter were to die for. I ordered the steak and shrimp with mashed potatoes and vegetables and it was absolutely divine. My boyfriend ordered the catfish with with seasoned rice and chili, and it was amazing. Looking forward to returning and ordering more you will not be disappointed.“

“Oh my goodness where do I start. I almost never write reviews but my experience was nothing short of amazing. From the moment my boyfriend and I walked in, until the we left the service we received was incredible. The food ! Wow. The oysters were so fresh , the crab cake is a must try I woke up this morning with it on my mind. Truffle Mac and cheese is a hit . Tomahawk steak for two 10/10. I also ordered 3 drinks one at the bar and 2 more sitting down and baby it was LIQUOR in those drinks 😂♥️. I’m so upset I didn’t get my waiters name he was wonderful as well he treated us with care. Truly had a great time, and It’s so hard finding a steakhouse that has good food along with appealing ambiance. 10/10 would recommend. Oh and I almost forgot there was a photographer that took the most beautiful photos of us and put them in a glass frame.“