12 Best Steakhouses near Rye

“Best steak I have had in a long time, service was impeccable. Will be back“

“What a wonderful, classy place! My husband and I celebrated our wedding anniversary here and had a great experience. We requested to sit outside because we had our 2 month old with us. A table with extra space outside was reserved for us, which was so sweet. Throughout the night our baby was loud and fussy, and the staff was incredibly kind and accommodating (offering to turn down the music, checking in on us, and even offering to rock the baby to sleep for us haha). Every staff member was professional and helpful and made us feel comfortable and special. At the end of the meal, they sang happy anniversary to us with a sparkler in our dessert. All the food was delicious and perfectly cooked, as well. The crab cake and octopus appetizers were especially tasty, and we appreciated the extensive wine list. So happy to have such a wonderful place in the neighborhood; we will certainly be back!“

“Wonderful experience at Lenny's, the stuff was phenomenal, they had a table for us at a very private quiet area that was perfect for our business dinner. The food, amazing! Overall excellent experience. Would definitely recommend Lenny's.“

“We went here with 3 generations and lots of different food preferences and we all loved our food. The service was wonderful. Anytime the water glass got low they were there to fill it up. It is a family owned restaurant and we wish them much success.“

“Terrific, but pricey. About $250 pp with tip.“

“We love coming here when in town. Peter and his team put out great food and the service is incredible. It's casual but the service emulates that of a high end steak house. On this visit, we started with the calamari which was delicately fried to be delicious and tender. The accompanying sauce was so complimented and delicious that hubby and and I ate every drop. I had the chiliean sea bass which was sweet, tender and so flavorful it literally melts in your mouth. Hubby tried the stuffed shrimp which was different for him and he raved about the flavor and ate all of it. We spilt a crème brûlée, well prepared with a crusty hard shell and delicious rich creamy custard. Highly recommend it based on our experience.“

“Phenomenal experience. Top notch food, atmosphere, and wait staff. Have been here multiple times, and every time is an amazing experience all around. The food is always superb and the bar is amazing. Definitely a lifetime customer!“

“The food and service were fantastic.“

“Dinner was fantastic! Music by DJ Bobby Flowers & Jerry Brown was awesome! Chef Rocco of Chef Rocco Dessert Creations Demonstration and delicious desserts was simply incredible! Can’t wait to go back again for Chef Rocco, DJ Bobby and Jerry’s next show♥️“

“If you want to experience the finest steakhouse dining in NY look no further!! From food Quality, ambience, to exceptional service Benjamins steakhouse has it all. It’s an absolute must! Cannot recommended highly enough.“

“Went for Sunday brunch with my dad & boyfriend. The food was absolutely amazing, but the thing I wanted to mention was the service we experienced. From the welcoming hosts at the front desk, to our AMAZING server Amani, and the manager Arod coming to greet us and ensure our experience was good, we felt so welcomed and taken care of. Amani was an absolute pleasure to be serviced from and extremely attentive. Arod was also a sweetheart for ensuring we had a great time. Great staff and would love to come back for them!!!“

“Had my daughter Sweet 16 dinner yesterday 10/26/25. Everything was amazing, the staff were attentive and catering, they made sure everything ran smoothly. Food was great, bartender did her thing for the adults. And shout out to Doogie!!! His favorite quote was “I’ll take care of you” and he did just that. My daughter and her friends had an amazing time. We will be back.“