4 Best Ice Cream Shops near Sackets Harbor

“Absolutely loved this little ice cream stand! From the moment we walked up, the staff was friendly, and the atmosphere was fun! The ice cream itself? Incredible. Super creamy, full of flavor, and clearly made with care—every scoop felt like a treat. We tried the blueberry cheesecake and maple soft serve and both were absolutely top-notch. Prices were fair, portions were generous, and everything was clean and well-maintained. This is our new favorite summer stop—can’t wait to come back!“

“Pennocks has been a staple for our annual family trip to the cottage. They have many flavors and are friendly. As a PSA, bring cash. This is a small seasonal business and they do not take cards. The Dollar General across the street is a good place to get cash if needed. Support this wonderful local business! Great people, great ice cream.“

“love the new maple nut twist flavor....at least new to me. it was delicious!“

“Family tradition to stop at the Trolley on Mother's Day after walking the beach at Southwicks. Today's top pick was the caramel praline turtle. Yum!! Of course a well enjoyed doggy ice cream for Daisy May. Great service with a friendly smile, Looking forward to having our summer ice cream stops at the Trolley... 🌟🌟🌟🌞🌟🌟🌟“