New Mexican Restaurants near Sag Harbor, NY

Estia's Little Kitchen Latin American • $$
1615 Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor Turnpike, Sag Harbor

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Fish Tacos with Tequila Sunrise Salsa
Gringo Hash
Chilaquiles
Quesadilla

“Solid. Mexican cuisine that my Mexican spouse approved. Chill little house turned restaurant with art for sale on the walls, friendly and welcoming staff, and quality drinks. Family friendly. Recommend this gem of a restaurant just outside of downtown sag harbor.“

3.6 Good56 Reviews
El Verano New Mexican Cuisine • $$$
10 Windmill Ln, Southampton - 9.48 miles

Customers` Favorites

Branzino a Las Brasas
Quesadilla de Trufa
Chicken Enchiladas
PF Tacos De Birria
Side of Guacamole
Tacos De Ribeye
Short Rib Tacos
Lobster Tacos
Crispy Sushi
Quesadillas

“Had another excellent dinner at El Verano. No matter how busy it is, the Staff is always attentive and smiling. Tacos de Birria remain a favorite. They’ve added new desserts to the menu. The Pastel Del Elote is a must. You’d never expect to hear corn as a sweet treat but make sure you try this.“

4.2 Good40 Reviews
CASA AMIGOS Restaurante Mexican • $$$
110 Front St, Greenport - 8.05 miles

Customers` Favorites

Churros Con Vanilla Ice Cream
Fajitas Texanas
Fried Calamari
Lamb Chops
Mexican

“Great cocktails, food and service at this Mexican restaurant on Front St. in Greenport. Many different 'Ritas to choose from. We went for the Cadillac and Top Shelf when we were advised that the jalapeños in the Jalapeño & Pineapple Margarita were hot today. Really hot? we asked. Yes, hotter than usual. Hot! Great drinks, worth a bit of a wait. My husband enjoyed his Fish Tacos. I had the salmon served over a tomato, corn, squash and zucchini ragú with a pleasant, not overpowering tomato sauce. Salmon was cooked medium rare as requested. Nice atmosphere, tables close enough to others but not too close. Given seasonal destination, the pricing was very reasonable. We'll be returning :-).“

4.4 Superb17 Reviews

Taste More In Sag Harbor