18 Best Mexican Restaurants near Sag Harbor

Cilantro's Mexican take-out Mexican • $
138 Division St, Sag Harbor

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Quesadilla
Chicken Burrito
Any Burrito
Nacho Grande
Enchilada
Guacamole
Steak
Taco

“Driving around after setting up a display at a golf course we came across this little gem in Sag Harbour. I had three tacos; chicken, chorizo and beef. All were delicious. The portions were spot on. My colleague had a burrito and quesadilla. Both look amazing. Fresh tasting great quality ingredients. My pictures aren’t the best as we could wait to eat! Must try take away if you’re near.“

4.1 Good52 Reviews
LT Burger Sag Harbor Burgers • $$
62 Main St, Sag Harbor

“Great burgers 🍔 and shakes“

3.1 Average108 Reviews
Maria's Kitchen Mexican • $
55 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island - 5.64 miles

Customers` Favorites

Avocado & Goat Cheese
Chicken Cutlets Torta
Chicken Burrito Bowl
Grilled Chicken
Carne Asada
Fish

“Food is great, quick & friendly service“

4.7 Superb58 Reviews
Uno Mas Southampton Mexican • $$
44 Hampton Rd suite 2, Southampton - 9.12 miles

Customers` Favorites

Minerva’S Chips \u0026 Guac
Minerva’S Chips & Queso
Minerva’S Chips & Guac
Chicken Enchilada
Carne Asada Taco
Cinnamon Churros
Rice and Beans
Side of Salsa
Adobada Taco
SM Side Chips

“Service here was wonderful - keep it up. Food is delicious and the margaritas very well made and taste fresh. Sitting in here realizing it used to be half of La Parm was an added treat. So nice to see a well run business move into this space. We will be back 100%.“

4.7 Superb57 Reviews
The Island cafe Mexican • $
50D Montauk Hwy, Southampton - 10.69 miles

Customers` Favorites

Gallo Pinto

“Delicious amazing latin food 😍 Have so many good food on the menu! From tacos,burritos to delicious soups to carne asada and delicious breakfasts. If you want fresh food with lots of homemade flavor you know where to go 🤩Definitely recommend!!! 🌮🌯🥘 🍲“

5 Superb7 Reviews
La Hacienda Mexican Grill Mexican • $
48 Jagger Ln, Southampton - 9.23 miles

Customers` Favorites

3 Meat and Cheese Enchiladas
Al Pastor and Barbacoa Tacos
Quesadilla and Taco
Chips and Guacamole
2 Hard Shell Tacos
Veggie Burrito
Shrimp Burrito
Menudo
Nachos

“The food was delicious and the atmosphere was very inviting.“

4.4 Superb56 Reviews
CASA AMIGOS Restaurante Mexican • $$$
110 Front St, Greenport - 8.05 miles

Customers` Favorites

Churros Con Vanilla Ice Cream
Fajitas Texanas
Fried Calamari
Lamb Chops
Mexican

“Great atmosphere and food. Top shelf Mexican cuisine!!!“

4.4 Superb32 Reviews
La REGIA Deli And Restaurant Mexican • $
131 3rd St, Greenport - 8.1 miles
4.5 Superb2 Reviews
Lucharitos Mexican • $$
119 Main St, Greenport - 7.99 miles

Customers` Favorites

Coconut Shrimp Taco
Mexican Street Corn
Margaritas Classico
Seasonal Fish Tacos
Cheese Quesadilla
Chip Dip Trio
Veggie Tacos
Pulled Pork
Al Pastor
Greenport

“My grandson and I come in for the wings which we both love once once a week And we absolutely adore your little server Aly She’s the best! Keep up the good work“

4.2 Good189 Reviews
DeJesus Deli & Grocery Mexican • $
376 County Rd 39, Southampton - 9.29 miles

“I stopped in at lunch to see if they could put together a dinner for 15 people that afternoon, they told me no problem! .The food was authentic and amazing! Everything was packaged perfectly, labeled and delicious. If its true Hispanic food you are craving, this is your place!“

4 Good14 Reviews
Señor Taco Mexican Grill & Bar Mexican • $
44780 Middle Rd, Southold - 8.87 miles

Customers` Favorites

Jalapeño Poppers 6pc
Trío Fajitas Mixtas
Chicken Fingers 5
Margarita Flight
Small Quesadilla
Large Quesadilla
Sweet Plantains
Arroz Con Pollo
Chicken Fajitas
Sangria Flight

“As usual the food and drinks were delicious. Unfortunately the waiter was rude. He screwed up my order. Then came over and twice asked me to admit I ordered something I didn’t. The waitresses were nice as always. Nothing was done by him. He did not apologize. Did not even offer to comp a drink or something. Not that I was looking for something free. He didn’t care. Really sad. At least the waitresses apologized.“

4 Good103 Reviews
Latin Fuzion Restaurant Spanish • $
53345 Main Rd, Southold - 8.49 miles

Customers` Favorites

Coconut Shrimp Platter with Rice and Veggies
Grilled Shrimp Tacos 3 13 95
Chorizo Carne Asada or Mixed
Steak or Shrimp Enchiladas
Chorizo Tacos 3 11 95
Chicken Enchiladas
Veggie Quesadilla
Breakfast Burrito
Arroz Con Pollo
Fried Plantain

“My wife and I visited Latin Fusion, and upon arrival, we were warmly greeted by a pleasant person who took our order and delivered it to us in short order. The food was plentiful and delicious, with its own distinct flavor and taste. No boilerplate here—warm and inviting, absolutely a hidden gem. 👍👍👍👍👍“

4.6 Superb62 Reviews
El Verano New Mexican Cuisine • $$$
10 Windmill Ln, Southampton - 9.48 miles

Customers` Favorites

Quesadilla Verano Con Pollo
Branzino a Las Brasas
Steak Tartar Tostada
Side Pee Wee Potatoes
Quesadilla de Trufa
Chips and Guacamole
Southampton Burrito
Chicken Enchiladas
PF Tacos De Birria
Langosta de Verano

“Ate there with my entire family. Started with fresh avocado dip and chips, then had 6 dinners on the menu all different. Everyone DELICIOUS !!. Atmosphere was busy but not real noisy We could eat and chat without shouting. The wait staff was attentive but not hovering. They would look from a distance and see if we needed anything. A great taste I had the steak and it was fabulous. Easy to get to and we all had a great time !!“

4.1 Good80 Reviews
Blue Parrot Mexican • $$
33A Main St, East Hampton - 6.05 miles

Customers` Favorites

Our House-Made Tortilla Chips
Lime Chipotle Chicken Burrito
Shrimp Quesadilla
Baja Shrimp Tacos
Shredded Chicken
Corn on the Cob
Guacamole Bowl
Mexican Corn

“Thank you! EXCELLENT time and food! Highly recommend.“

3.6 Good39 Reviews
Sabrosa Mexican Grill Mexican • $
1152 Montauk Hwy, Water Mill - 6.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

Spicy Buffalo Chicken Quesadilla
Spicy Chicken Corn Chowder
Fresh Baked Cookies
Side of Guacamole
Chips & Guacamole
Vegetarian Chili
Vegetarian Bowl
Meat Quesadilla
Tacos Al Pastor
Chips & Salsa

“If you want a spot like Chipotle but on the east end of long island, Sabrosa is your spot.
And I can tell you, the food is way better here than it is there. As a local realtor I stop in there once or twice a week to get a great hot nutritious and delicious meal.
It’s basically make to order what you want to eat eat a bowl a salad taco burrito you name it anything with the Mexican flare they’ll make for you.
The service is fantastic. The portions are copious. The hot sauces are delicious. It’s just a great place to come.“

3.6 Good52 Reviews
Stars Cafe Cafe • $
17 Grand Ave, Shelter Island Heights - 6.75 miles

Customers` Favorites

Mediterranean Chicken
Chilaquiles Con Huevo
Blueberry Pancakes
Grilled Chicken
Pancake Platter
Huevos Rancheros
Yoghurt Parfait
Healthy Wrap
French Toast
Soup of The

“This beautiful spot is THE culinary highlight of Shelter Island. From breakfast burritos to burgers, to coffee and smoothies, this place can do it all and do it well. They are beyond welcoming and open to everyone that’s walks in. Since moving away I’ve missed their hospitality and food more than ever. So go in and have a try they are definitely worth it!!“

4.2 Good60 Reviews
Hampton Coffee Company Coffee Shops • $
869 Montauk Hwy, Water Mill - 6.56 miles

Customers` Favorites

Traditional Lobster Roll
Coffee Beans
Hamburger
Croissant
Avocado
Pancake
Muffin

“Hampton Coffee has the most delicious iced matcha lattes! They also have amazing iced coffee, refreshers, and a wide variety of fresh treats!“

4.2 Good96 Reviews
The Beach Hut on Main Acai Bowls • $$
104 Ocean Ave, East Hampton - 6.36 miles

Customers` Favorites

French Toast Sticks Breakfast with Maple Syrup and Butter
Funky Chunky Monkey Smoothie Breakfast
Chocolate Chip Cookies
Lobster Roll

“All of the 1 Star ⭐️ reviews are laughable. Cmon folks, this is a food spot on the beach… relax a little! Food is decent and service is good. Prices are very fair considering you’re steps away from the beautiful beach. If you want a cloth napkin, go somewhere else… or better yet - go back to the city.“

3.9 Good38 Reviews

Taste More In Sag Harbor

You May Also Like