Custom Cakes near Saint James, NY

“I love this bakery... always a delight. Cinnamon cake donuts crispy even when you buy them at 2:00, my favorite are the raspberry filled butter cookies dipped in chocolate. I recently got the chocolate chocolate cup cake...the cake moist (not dry like most places), and the frosting was melt in your mouth. So much better than other bakeries...this is a neighborhood secret !“

“Outstanding bakery! Lemon Meringue pie is to die for. Whenever we visit our relatives on Long Island (a 200+mile trip for us), we make a stop here. Pies and cakes are second to none! This is a destination bakery!Parking: On Pulaski Street. About 20 spots.“

“Cake Fairyland did such an awesome job designing a Studio Ghibli birthday cake for me! When I saw the cake for the first time my mouth dropped and I couldn't believe how perfect it looked, it was even better than I could have imagined. The staff were very helpful and courteous and made my experience so memorable. Truly above and beyond! Will definitely order again!!“

“Familia Bakery is the home of my favorite tres leches cake. I've had the traditional and Oreo cakes. This time, I had the coconut tres leches. It was great! Not too wet but moist. The coconut flakes definitely complimented the cake. My daughter had the traditional tres leches and loved it. Hopefully, one weekend, I'll bring the kids for some Columbian style breakfast pastries.“

“I like to come here and check out the goods anytime I'm in the area.I've gotten a rainbow cake from here before for a birthday.They always have macaroons but the same flavors. They are a good size and pricing is always expensive anywhere but I prefer these over uncle guiseppes. I'd never get a bunch but one is good once in awhile. I recommend the cake pops though those are good for the pricing and makes the kids happy.Well worth it.Also tried the fruit cheese cake yesterday. They had a candied blackberry. Raspberry. And some blueberries. It's small but good.They've gotten more expensive over the years but what hasn't...When you get in there you can look around but be sure to get online when your ready. They are usually pretty busy there so unless your online don't expect to be able to ask a bunch of questions !But when it's your turn to order they are super nice. And do they're best to help you. When they're busy though it's to be expected they don't want to stand around answering what each baked good is haha. Ask your questions all at once!“

“i normally don't leave reviews but they were so so sweet, fantastic customer service and the man who decorated the cake was very efficient and did a beautiful job. unfortunately i wasn't carrying cash on me to leave a tip, they don't take tips on card just a heads up!! so i went back to my car and grabbed whatever i had & went back in. like seriously lovely people thanks guys didn't catch ur names“

“Five stars definitely she made a beautiful amazing delicious cake for my daughter’s baby shower with macaroons and chocolate covered pretzels everything came out delicious. Everything was done perfectly in a timely manner. The lady that made the cake was just amazing and so polite and just as sweet as her cake. If you’re looking for a delicious beautiful cake or sweets , she’s the person to go to.“

“Rolling Pin Bakery was fantastic! The wedding cake tasted amazing and looked beautiful. I showed them a picture of what I envisioned our wedding cake to be and they knocked it out of the park. They also helped with last minute questions and I was able to send them the type of edible pearl decoration I wanted to use. Highly recommend!“

“Always Exceeds Expectations ! Today we enjoyed the very best Linzer Tarts since Huntington's Rise Above/ The Well Bread Loaf of yesteryear. Chocolate Layer Cakes just Fabulous.....and Don't forget the Crumb Cake of the Month. Try it- you'll ❤️ it!“

“The last time I went to an Ice Cream store that provides their own custom flavors was in Carey, North Carolina. This store is located in a small strip mall with ample parking. From what I read; Ice Cream Social has several flavors of ice cream along with vegan flavors. They do have traditional flavors such as vanilla, chocolate, and cookie dough, but they are constantly designing new flavors. I tried many flavors before choosing the pumpkin pie flavor ice cream. But I did also like the apple cider donut and Coco Almond Joy. Next time I will explore other interesting creations. The staff was kind enough to afford me the opportunity to taste many creative flavors. It was not easy to settle on just one flavor. I recall a family member explaining to me what it takes to create these interesting flavors, and he stated it is all in the Cream mix. If you want to enjoy high quality ice cream with many creative flavors, one must indulge in Ice Cream Social.“

“Honestly the best frozen yogurt and the best toppings anywhere! Employees are nice and courteous!!!Kid-friendliness: Always come here after my son and daughter's school concerts. Filled with parents and a lot of kids. The owner and the employees are super professional even with 30+ kids running around .“