50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Selden

“I wasn’t planning on stopping at Sal Anthony’s Pizza. I was actually on an important mission involving a suspicious-looking earthworm and a neighbor’s flower bed. But then… I caught the smell.

As a rooster with impeccable taste and a strict “no bad pizza” policy, I strutted inside. One peck at the crust and I knew my day had changed forever. Crispy on the outside, soft on the inside, with cheese so perfectly melted I briefly considered abandoning farm life to become a full-time pizza critic.

The staff behind the counter treated me with the respect any distinguished rooster deserves. Nobody questioned why I was reviewing the menu by standing on a chair and yelling.

By the time I left, I had forgotten all about the worm. That’s how good the pizza was.

If you’re debating where to eat, stop overthinking it. Sal Anthony’s Pizza has officially earned the coveted Richard Seal of Approval™. Five enthusiastic crows out of five.

—Richard 🐓🍕“

“Stopped in on my lunch break while working in the area, got 2 slices with Pepperoni & added fresh Garlic $12 total A bit pricey BUT Amazing crust, & Delicious ingredients, Best Pizza I ever had hands down! Would & have recommended to coworkers.“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Café Amici in Selden is a gem! From the warm greeting at the door to the attentive staff and fresh bread service, everything feels welcoming. The appetizers were delicious, but the highlight was the Trojan entrée — huge portions, amazing flavor, and beautifully presented. If you still have room, the desserts are worth it too. Prices are great for the quality, and meeting Joe, the owner, made the experience even more special. Highly recommend!“

“Great pizza spot next to the play pace Lil Steps . Super convenient, good pizza and excellent staff . The young girl working this evening (7/16) was very sweet , helpful and accommodating . My son is 3 years old and he loved it too. They cut his pizza perfectly for him. We will be back for sure .“

“Amazing place, under new ownership, who really cares about their customers.“

“Our son and daughter in law hired them for there wedding .The food was the best, so fresh and delicious. The whole time they were there at the wedding serving, the staff was friendly and very professional. Top notch service. This is amazing pizza company. I would definitely be recommend visiting them or if you need someone to cater a special occasion do not hesitate to reach out to them.Thank you again for a wonderful day.“

“All I'll say is.. Mama Mia !!“

“Tonight was a really good reminder that sometimes the little things mean the most. Lucas and I had one of our favorite mommy/son dinner dates at the new "The Pizzeria" in Yaphank. Since being diagnosed with celiac and deciding to go dairy free for my health, I've wondered if some of our favorite traditions would have to change. I knew they offered a gluten-free crust, but after I ordered Lucas's slices, I asked a few questions. Vinny, who was working behind the counter, was incredible. He told me he'd been with the company for three years and knew they had a dairy-free sauce. When I told him my favorite slice was the Aunt Danielle (vodka sauce, pepperoni, stracciatella, fresh basil, and hot honey), he smiled and said, "Let's make you a dairy-free version on a gluten-free pie." It was even better than I imagined. Every bite was amazing. But what meant the most wasn't just the pizza. It was realizing I don't have to give up one of my favorite traditions with my son to take care of my health. Thank you, Vinny, for taking the time to help and for making someone with celiac feel seen instead of like an inconvenience. Acts of kindness like that make a bigger difference than you probably realize.“

“They have been working with so many families in need. They are helping feed Long Island families while the SNAP program is still not being funded. In addition to a friendly eatery that truly cares about people their food is amazing. So many options to choose from! Stop by and say hello, grab some delicious food and help spread the love. Donate today or share their mission to feed Long Island families in need during this difficult time. No child should ever be hungry.“

“The nicest service and the best food hands down. Meatball parm on toasted garlic bread is to die for!“

“Amazing every time!! Your pizza is like a piece of GOLD!! Thank you for keeping it fresh!“

“Absolutely Amazing!! The owner himself delivered our food for my daughters birthday and was so generous! Everything was perfect and delicious! Thank you for being part of our occasion and looking forward to trying some more food in the dining area soon!“

“AWESOME FOOD AND SERVICE !!“

“After having a falling out with our original catering company just weeks before our wedding, finding La Cucina Paisanos was truly a blessing in disguise. From the very first moment we walked into the restaurant to see if they might be an option for our wedding, we were warmly greeted by Nick, the owner, and immediately felt at ease. Nick took the time to walk us through the entire catering process and even allowed us to sample several menu items since we hadn’t yet had the chance to try the food. That level of care and hospitality set the tone for the entire experience. The customer service from Nick and the entire La Cucina Paisanos team genuinely went above and beyond every step of the way. My now husband and I are both Johnson & Wales Culinary graduates, so food quality was incredibly important to us — not just for ourselves, but because we knew our guests would expect nothing less. La Cucina Paisanos absolutely delivered. The food was outstanding, prepared with care, flavor, and consistency, and our guests raved about it all night long. It truly elevated our wedding day. That says so much that after returning from our honeymoon, we went straight back to La Cucina Paisanos for dinner — and once again, everything from the service to the ambiance to the quality of the food was exceptional. Whether you’re looking for incredible Italian cuisine for a family dinner or need catering for a special event, we cannot recommend La Cucina Paisanos enough. You can truly taste the love and passion that goes into every dish. This restaurant has earned our highest recommendation — 10-fold.“

“Everything! Food and service Holbrook definitely has a large assortment of goodies and staff is friendly and smart ❤️“

“Just Made the pizza from the Pizza Kit for The Harding Avenue Elementary School fundraiser, and it was delicious.“

“THE BEAT SALAD (added shrimp & avocado) ! Holy HEAVENS! OH MY DAYS! I had to sit in the parking lot to chow down. Absolutely worth the wait. Super delicious. Honestly I forgot to use the salad dressing. That’s how yummy this is. Will be back! Thank you all!! #DELISH“

“Had a wonderful lunch with three friends today. Great food and service. Such a wonderful surprise will certainly make it a go to place. Thanks for a great lunch.“

“I had the most delicious penne, broccoli rabe and chicken dinner. They are the nicest staff and very accommodating. I would definitely go back for both the friendly staff and this dish! Plenty of food and even some leftover. Reasonably priced too!!“

“Thank you for the spinach pinwheels, garlic knots, pepperoni knots, and vegetables with sausages. Your hospitality were great.“

“Amazing Pizza! Nice and crispy and delicious. This will be our new go to spot! 🍕“

“Love it here! Everything is so good. The food is fresh like homemade 🍝. I particularly like the penne à la vodka. I also love having them right here at the intersection of Middle Rd and Bayport Ave. It fits in perfectly!“

“Such a wonderful pizza spot! The pizza was absolutely delicious, the crust was perfect, and every bite was full of flavor. The food, atmosphere, and service were all amazing. Definitely one of those places you want to come back to again and again.“

“Nino's Pizza never disappoints! Everything is fresh, flavorful, and made with quality ingredients. My personal fav is the White Broccoli Ricotta Pizza, absolutely amazing—creamy ricotta, fresh broccoli, and a perfectly crispy crust make it a must-try. The staffs are very friendly, the service is excellent, and the guys are always very welcoming. Very reasonable prices, and consistent quality keep me coming back. If you're looking for Authentic pizza, highly recommend Nino's Pizza!“

“The food from the pizza place and the market is outstanding and never boring over at the market. You can find different meals and different specials!“

“Local pizza joint with 1980 prices! Food is good, people are nice, happy to support our small businesses in the neighborhood!“

“My family and I went to them since they first opened.. and when I say there was NOTHING that they made that was anything below amazing, believe me! From their pizza to pasta, to rolls and salads.. even their garlic bread. The hospitality they all provided, especially Benny, was enough to make you remember them forever.. then you add on their food? Forget it. Nothing holds a candle to this place and the family. They are SORELY missed! I have yet to find a salad/vinaigrette, or a marina sauce, from any other place that comes close to this place. I dream of that antipasto!! Thank you for all your years of service to the community. You are so, so missed. I hope your family is enjoying retirement! Love always, Victoria “Bella” (Benny called me that ever since I was a baby!!), Alice, and Raymond ❤️“

“Sole Mio donated an incredible meal to the Ronald McDonald Room at Stony Brook University Hospital while our daughter was there. The meal included a wonderful chicken Parmesan and a pasta with vodka sauce that was especially good. We were very thankful for their kind donation and hope to visit in person in the future.“

“Just had some amazing slices! 2 Grandma slices, 1 Chicken Marsala slice and 1 regular. Great taste and crust was cooked perfectly. Definitely recommend“

“Everything was great from the time I placed my order till the day it arrive the owner was a pleasure and the food was excellent.so happy I chose them for the baby shower would definitely recommend them to others and if I ever have another party I’ll call him“

“BEST FOODS EVERY!!! YUMMY YUM YUM!!“

“Both round and square.“

“Great place with great staff. I recommend!“

“Fabulous lunch today!!! Excellent food and service!!!“

“Anthonys Grill did the food for a father daughter dance. Amazing is an understatement. Ricky went above and beyond for us. We will be using them again very soon. Food was awesome!!!“

“Great pizza!!! Great people!!!“

“Had a great experience at Papa John’s in Mount Sinai! The pizza was hot, fresh, and made perfectly, and the staff was super friendly and helpful. My order was ready quickly, everything tasted amazing, and the restaurant was clean and welcoming. You can tell the team works hard to provide great service. Definitely one of the better Papa John’s locations around — I order from here often!“

“I’ve been going here for years hands-down the best place I’ve ever been The owner is amazing. The food is delicious. I tell everybody about this place and I will always come here for the rest of my life. This is what pizza is supposed to taste like.Amazing food and Quality and quantity very satisfied customer.“

“Meatballs-tasted almost identical to when my Italian, childhood best friend’s grandma would slow simmer them ALL day long every Sunday!! The grilled chicken in the Greek salad was very moist and soft. Loved their 6 slice pizza too-great cheese and perfect amount of sauce that’s way less acidic than other local pizza, maybe partially because they use less sauce. Staff were very kind too. Highly recommend.“

“We had a catered party yesterday, with several recommendations to use Tony's Pizza. The food was delivered and set up for us. It was piping hot, had very generous portions, and most importantly delicious! Luigi was super friendly at the pizzeria, and great to work with for the follow-up. Thank you guys, for helping my son's 21st birthday be a huge success! The Sitler Family.“

“Amazing pizza 🔥 Best late night spot in town. Quick question — do you guys have a website for direct orders?“

“ive been looking for a good wood fired pizza place for a while and now ive found it , i went there on friday and got a margarita pizza and a calzone , both were super yum and made with fresh ingredients but the calzone was out of this world and i will be coming back with my wife for lunch“

“Second time I had Sicilian pizza and salad delivered. One of the best pizzas I’ve ever had on Long Island. I am definitely going to visit them to see what else they have to offer. Their salad was delicious too, and their dressing was outstanding.“

“The BEST pizza in the world!“

“I walked in there My pizza was ready. Sausages And peppers pie was really good and the Pie was really loaded I was very pleased with the sausages they used and the peper where very colorful and plentifull, I will highly recommend it. And can't wait to be around the area to get another one. Thank you.“

“great food , the staff are wonderful. would recommend it“

“Tonight we had Gino’s Pizza Truck at our school carnival event and they were absolutely a HUGE hit ! Pizza was delicious and families were so happy! The staff were so kind and everyone raved ! Thank you for adding to our carnival event. We will definitely be booking them for future events !“

“Great food. Great experience overall. 👍🏼“

“My father and I quickly fell in love with this place! The owner is really nice and the woman behind the counter is a shining light :) Their pizza is delicious, but in particular... The Alfredo spice omgggg it's heavenly!!!! Nice environment, friendly people, amazing food, great prices! You can't go wrong.“

“Rocco’s is the epitome of a long established neighborhood Italian pizzeria and restaurant that also brings regional world class food every day to locals and smart newcomers.

So clean, fresh food, pizza to rival Gloria’s in Flushing. The rest of the menu - never disappointed- always glad we moved close to them from Queens and Brooklyn.

The men and women who work there- treat all like familia. What a treasure. Keep it up. We need to eat your food at least twice a week. Grazie“