Pumpernickels Delicatessen and Market
734 Rte 25A, Setauket- East Setauket
(631) 941-4200
Customers' Favorites
Eggs with Sausage with Your Choice of Drink & Bread
Rueben Sandwiches Original
Burger
Omelettes Breakfast
111. Western Omelette
Served with onions, peppers and ham.
112. Eastern Omelette
Served with onions and peppers.
113. Southern Omelette
Served with onions, peppers tomatoes and mushrooms.
114. Northern Omelette
Served with bacon, ham and potatoes.
Breakfast Heros
115. Hungry Man
3 eggs with bacon, ham, home fries with melted American cheese on a hero.
116. Healthy Hero
3 egg whites with grilled turkey and melted alpine Swiss and hot sauce on a hero.
118. Pumpernickles "Famous" Pancakes
Chocolate chip, pumpkin, fresh strawberries or blueberries plain. 3 large made to order delicious pancakes served with syrup and butter.
Homemade Texas French Toast
Pan-fried bread.
119. The Complete Box
2 large pancakes, 2 eggs any style with bacon or sausage and toast.
Breakfast Drinks
Coffee
Tea
Hot Chocolate
Iced Coffee
Iced Tea
Brewed Tea
Home Fries
Specialty Salad Sandwiches
217. Chicken Salad Sandwich
Chopped chicken that has been tossed in a creamy dressing.
218. Egg Salad Sandwich
A cold creamy sandwich made with chopped eggs, mayo, and seasoning.
219. Seafood Salad Sandwich
Sandwich with a seasoned mixed seafood base that is occasionally dressed with mayonnaise.
220. Tuna Salad Sandwich
Chilled creamy mild fish sandwich.
221. Shrimp Salad Sandwich
Shellfish salad.
237. BLT Sandwich
Bacon, lettuce, and tomato.
222. Chicken Cranberry Walnut Sandwich
223. Fit for Life Tuna Salad Sandwich
Cold salad with shredded tuna. Chilled creamy mild fish sandwich.
224. Egg White Veggie Salad Sandwich
Meatless sandwich.
225. Turkey Salad Sandwich
226. Cajun Chicken Salad Sandwich
Chopped chicken that has been tossed in a creamy dressing.
Fresh Chicken Cutlet
Fresh Chicken Cutlet Roll
Fresh Chicken Cutlet Hero
Salads
Cobb Salad
Served with bacon, sliced hard boiled eggs, crumbled blue cheese, red onion and avocado on top of romaine lettuce.
Tossed Salad
Mixed greens with cucumbers, tomatoes, carrots and red onion.
Caesar Salad
Crisp romaine lettuce tossed with our famous dressing topped with Parmesan and homemade croutons.
Greek Salad
Romaine lettuce with cucumbers, red onion, black olives feta and tomatoes.
Mexican Salad
Romaine, corn, black beans, tomatoes, cheddar cheese and tortilla chips.
Chef Salad
Ham, turkey, Swiss and American cheese over our tossed salad.
Cali Salad
Mixed greens, walnuts, cranberries, cucumber, feta, red onion and tomatoes.
On the Healthy Side
234. Tuna Lovers Special
Fit for life tuna with light mayo served on a bed of lettuce with tomatoes, carrots, cucumbers and your choice of dressing.
233. Choice is Yours
Chicken salad or white meat tuna salad, choice of potato, macaroni or coleslaw served over a bed of lettuce.
235. Grilled Chicken on a Roll
Chicken cutlet, lettuce, tomato and choice of dressing.
232. Grilled Chicken Platter
Chicken cutlet on a bed of lettuce with tomato and choice of dressing.
236. Grilled Chicken Delight
Chicken cutlet with melted cheddar cheese.
From Our Grill
192. Basic Burger Ala Cart
192. Basic Burger Platter
193. Burger Ala Cart
Served with lettuce, tomato, onions and pickles.
193. Burger Platter
Served with lettuce, tomato, onions and pickles.
194. Cheese Burger Ala Cart
Served with your choice of cheese.
194. Cheese Burger Platter
Served with your choice of cheese.
195. Patty Melt Ala Cart
Served on grilled rye with Swiss cheese and onions.
195. Patty Melt Platter
Served on grilled rye with Swiss cheese and onions.
196. Bacon Cheeseburger Ala Cart
Served with crisp bacon and your choice of cheese.
196. Bacon Cheeseburger Platter
Served with crisp bacon and your choice of cheese.
197. Pizza Burger Ala Cart
Served with melted mozzarella cheese and tomato sauce.
197. Pizza Burger Platter
Served with melted mozzarella cheese and tomato sauce.
198. Dijon Burger Ala Cart
Served with Swiss, onions, bacon and Dijon mustard.
198. Dijon Burger Platter
Served with Swiss, onions, bacon and Dijon mustard.
199. World Wide Burger Ala Cart
Cheddar, bacon, onions, let, tom and pickle.
199. World Wide Burger Platter
Cheddar, bacon, onions, let, tom and pickle.
201. Cordon Bleu Burger Ala Cart
Served with Swiss cheese and sliced grilled ham.
201. Cordon Bleu Burger Platter
Served with Swiss cheese and sliced grilled ham.
200. BBQ Burger Ala Cart
Served with cheddar, bacon, onions and BBQ sauce.
200. BBQ Burger Platter
Served with cheddar, bacon, onions and BBQ sauce.
Rueben Sandwiches
200. Rueben Sandwiches Original
Grilled corned beef with Swiss, sauerkraut with Russian dressing or mustard.
200. Rueben Sandwiches Western
Grilled pastrami, American cheese, coleslaw and mustard.
200. Rueben Sandwiches Southern
Grilled Virginia ham, muenster cheese, onions and Russian dressing.
200. Rueben Sandwiches West Coast
Grilled turkey, Swiss, sauerkraut and Russian dressing.
200. Rueben Sandwiches East Coast
Grilled roast beef, cheddar cheese, onions and ranch dressing.
Grilled Sandwiches
203. Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Hot sandwich filled with cheese that has been pan cooked or grilled.
204. Grilled Cheese Sandwich with Ham
Hot sandwich filled with cheese that has been pan cooked or grilled.
205. Grilled Cheese Sandwich with Bacon
Hot sandwich filled with cheese that has been pan cooked or grilled.
206. Grilled Cheese Sandwich with Tomato
Hot sandwich filled with cheese that has been pan cooked or grilled.
207. Grilled Cheese Sandwich with Bacon and Tomato
Hot sandwich filled with cheese that has been pan cooked or grilled.
208. Arcade Deluxe Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Served with bacon, ham, lettuce and tomato.
Fried Food
210. Chicken Finger Platter
5 pieces. Served with fries.
211. French Fries
Daily Chefs Hot Steam Table
Daily Chefs Hot Steam Table Ala Cart
Daily Chefs Hot Steam Table Platter
Served with 2 sides.
Breakfast Bagel Melts
119. Toasted Bagel with Cheese
Served with your choice of melted cheese.
120. Toasted Bagel with Ham
Served with melted cheese.
121. Toasted Bagel with Bacon
Served with melted cheese.
122. Toasted Bagel with Turkey
Served with melted cheese.
123. Toasted Bagel with Sausage Patty
Served with melted cheese.
123. Toasted Bagel with Cream Cheese
Served with 3 pieces of bacon.
Bagels
Bagels with Butter
Bagels with Cream Cheese
Bagels with Jelly
Served with cream cheese.
Breakfast Wraps
125. Robert Moses
Egg stuffed with spinach, broccoli and tomatoes.
126. West Hampton
Egg stuffed with zucchini, tomatoes, onions and melted mozzarella.
127. Cedar Beach
Egg stuffed with mushrooms, tomatoes, grilled ham and alpine Swiss.
128. Smith Point
Egg stuffed with grilled turkey, alpine Swiss and tomato.
129. Jones Beach
Egg with sauteed spinach and feta.
130. Fire Island
Egg stuffed with broccoli, onions and cheddar cheese.
131. Cupsogue
Eggs stuffed with potatoes, peppers, onion and salsa.
132. Cupsogue II
Eggs stuffed with potatoes, peppers, onions and meat.
133. Sills Gully
Eggs stuffed with bacon , your choice of cheese lettuce and tomato.
Homemade Bakery
Blueberry Muffins
Chocolate Chip Muffins
Corn Muffins
Chocolate Muffins
Bran Muffins
Oat Bran Muffins
Banana Nut Muffins
Cranberry Crumb Muffins
Cappuccino Muffins
Apple Cheese Turnovers
Cherry Cheese Turnovers
Homemade Crumb Cake
Brownies
Danish
Yogurt Parfaits
Homemade Large Cookies
Special Sandwiches
134. The Manhattan Sandwich
Roast beef with melted mozzarella and bacon served on a toasted garlic hero.
135. BLT Chicken Sandwich
Chicken salad with bacon, lettuce and tomato served on a hero.
136. Italian Sandwich
Ham cappy, Genoa salami, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomato sweet peppers, oil and vinegar on a hero.
137. Turkey Club Sandwich
Turkey breast with bacon, lettuce and tomato served on a hero.
138. Virginia Fusion Sandwich
Baked Virginia ham with melted muenster cheese, lettuce, tomato and Russian dressing on a hero.
139. Canadian Turkey Club Sandwich
B.H. turkey, Canadian bacon, melted Swiss, lettuce, tomato topped with coleslaw on a toasted hero.
140. Tuna Melt Sandwich
Tuna salad with melted American cheese served in a toasted roll.
141. American Sandwich
Roast beef, turkey, ham, American cheese, lettuce, tomato on on a hero with choice of dressing.
142. Monte Cristo Sandwich
Turkey, ham, melted Swiss cheese, lettuce and tomato with Russian dressing on a hero.
143. Chicken Cutlet Overload Sandwich
Chicken cutlet with bacon, melted American cheese, lettuce, tomato and Russian dressing on a hero.
144. Honey Maple Melt Sandwich
Honey maple turkey with Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato and honey mustard on a roll.
145. Cracked Pepper Melt Sandwich
Pepper mill turkey with bacon, melted provolone cheese, lettuce and onion on a toasted hero.
146. The Smokin Melt Sandwich
Smoked turkey with alpine laced swiss cheese , lettuce, tomato and honey mustard on rye toast.
147. The Veggie Melt Sandwich
Grilled vegetables with fresh mozzarella cheese on a roll with balsamic vinaigrette.
148. Chicken Cutlet Parmesan Sandwich
Breaded or grilled chicken topped with marinara sauce and melted fresh mozzarella on a toasted hero.
149. Chicken Cordon Bleu Sandwich
Breaded or grilled chicken topped with grilled ham and melted Swiss cheese on a toasted hero.
150. Original Monte Cristo Sandwich
Ham and turkey with melted Swiss on grilled
Challah bread with a side of syrup and choice of dressing.
151. Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich
Sauteed roast beef with peppers and onions with you choice of cheese. American, mozzarella or cheddar on a garlic her.
152. BBQ Chicken Melt Sandwich
Chicken cutlet with bacon, melted cheddar, lettuce, tomato and barbeque sauce on a hero.
153. The Mutz Melt Sandwich
Fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, tomatoes and fresh pesto aioli on a toasted garlic hero.
154. The Tuscan Melt Sandwich
Chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella and roasted peppers on a toasted garlic hero with fresh pesto aiolii.
Cold Cut Sandwiches
157. Bologna Sandwich
Finlely sliced sausage sandwich.
158. Ham Sandwich
Thinly sliced meat from a pig.'s leg.
159. Roast Beef Sandwich
Sandwich with thinly sliced beef that has been cooked over a dry heat.
160. Corned Beef Sandwich
Salt cured beef sandwich.
161. Fresh Turkey Breast Sandwich
162. Genoa Salami Sandwich
Cured sausage sandwich.
163. Ham Cappy Sandwich
Cured pork sandwich.
164. Honey Glazed Turkey Sandwich
Poultry sandwich.
165. Liverwurst Sandwich
Liver sausage sandwich.
166. Pepperoni Sandwich
Seasoned beef and pork salami sandwich.
167. Peppermill Turkey Sandwich
168. Pastrami Sandwich
Smoked and cured beef sandwich. .
169. Roast Pork Sandwich
170. Sausalito Turkey Sandwich
171. Smoked Turkey Sandwich
172. Turkey Breast Sandwich
173. Virginia Ham Sandwich
Thinly sliced meat from a pig.'s leg.
Cheese Sandwiches
174. American Cheese Sandwich
Add toppings for an additional charge.
175. Swiss Cheese Sandwich
Add toppings for an additional charge
176. Provolone Cheese Sandwich
Add toppings for an additional charge
177. Alpine Swiss Cheese Sandwich
Add toppings for an additional charge
178. Mozzarella Cheese Sandwich
Mellow mikly cheese.
179. Cheddar Cheese Sandwich
Add toppings for an additional charge
180. Muenster Cheese Sandwich
Add toppings for an additional charge
Wraps
182. Chicken Caesar Wrap
Grilled chicken, romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese, croutons and mixed with a homemade dressing.
183. BLT Club Wrap
Grilled chicken, crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato and ranch dressing.
184. Balsamic Chicken and Vegetable Wrap
Strips of marinated grilled chicken with vegetables and rice.
185. Deli Wrap
Turkey, Swiss, lettuce and tomato.
186. Sicilian Wrap
Genoa salami, ham cappy, provolone, lettuce, tomato and sweet red peppers with Italian dressing on the side.
187. Vegetable Tuna Wrap
Tuna with low fat mayo diced vegetables with lettuce and tomato.
188. Pesto Wrap
Grilled chicken, tomatoes, mozzarella cheese with a lite pesto dressing.
189. Teriyaki Wrap
Chicken teriyaki, broccoli, vegetables and rice.
190. Beefeater Wrap
Rare roast beef, sharp cheddar, lettuce, tomato red onion and a creamy horseradish sauce.
191. Greek Wrap
Grilled chicken with lettuce, tomato, black olives and feta.
Photos
+15 photos
+14 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Delicious food. Very clean. Chicken cutlets are absolutely phenomenal. I don’t eat mac and cheese anywhere else but when I come to this deli I always get some and it is amazing as well. Can’t say good enough things about this place.
January 2025
Pumpernickels Deli is an absolute gem—a small, cute spot that’s impressively clean with a warm and welcoming atmosphere. The staff, mostly younger folks, are delightful, efficient, and incredibly organized. They’re also so sweet when answering questions, making the experience feel personal and inviting.
On this visit, I ordered a simple bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich, and it was perfect. Sometimes it’s the basics that say the most, and Pumpernickels...
On this visit, I ordered a simple bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich, and it was perfect. Sometimes it’s the basics that say the most, and Pumpernickels...
December 2024
I travel 8 miles for BLT's passing over a half dozen places that are closer... pumpernickels perfected what bacon should taste like and how it is cooked....rare amongst the masses....I have had many other sandwiches as well.... the place is just very very
January 2024
You May Also Like
Sichuan Garden - 736 Rte 25A
![]()
Chinese
Eastern Pavilion - 750 NY-25A
![]()
Chinese, Japanese, Salad, Vegan
Bliss - 766 Rte 25A
![]()
Seafood, American, Salad