12 Best Cocktail Bars near Shelter Island Heights

“Kayla and I had an amazing dinner Steak night. Kayla's steak was out of this world delicious. I had the Swordfish which was tasty and delicious. Thank you Brad for treating us like family. We will be back again soon.“

“So fun. Such a great vibe.“

“We decided to head over to grab a cocktail ? after dinner. The Black Llama is in Stirling Square. This lounge is situated in the same square of the 1948 pizzeria, American Beach Hotel and Restaurant and the Tree bar. The evening was absolutely perfect. We went on a Friday night and it was a good mix of people at each place I mentioned. The Black Llama had a DJ playing music ?. I enjoyed it. I believe the type of music the DJ was playing is Electronic Dance Music - EDM. The drink menu is unique which is what I expected at this lounge bar. The waiter was super helpful and offered up suggestions. A relaxed atmosphere. We sat outside but I took a look at the inside and it looked great. Our cocktails were delicious. Also, for those who might not want alcohol, they do mocktails. I will go back ! It is a special spot.“

“Food and service was wonderful!“

“We made a reservation at this place thinking we wanted to try the pasta based on a past review. Turns out, they didn’t have that pasta and we decided to try Wiener schnitzel for the first time. What a treat! It was so delicious and enough for two. We also enjoyed the bread basket with coriander-sunflower butter and olive oil/balsamic vinegar. Yummy! We also had a side of pancetta savory spätzli - which pairs really well with our entree. The restaurant is cozy with Swiss flair. Our server was very friendly and attentive. Thank you for an amazing time!“

“Lo mejor q he conocido como Restaurante en el área de Greenport 👍👍👍“

“The food was fantastic and the atmosphere was very romantic!“

“Stephanie! She runs the greatest happy hour in NoFo!! She is so friendly and informative. Made great cocktails and the oysters are only $2! It’s a no brainer.“

“Great atmosphere, even better lobster rolls!“

“Excellent from beginning to finishing my meal. Joseph our waiter was spot on recommending the wine and specials. We enjoyed our meals ,water view and best service. This is our go to restaurant when we visit Greenport. See you next trip in from Queens.“

“Great burgers 🍔 and shakes“

“Had a spectacular meal. Came in last minute on a Saturday night. Lara, the hostess, was able to find us a spot at the bar. Gino served us a delicious meal (and drinks!) The must try items are the eggplant stack and spaghetti w/ meatballs. Save room for dessert!“