15 Best Coffee Shops near Shelter Island

“The best coffee ☕️ 🍮☕️☕️Good“

“The place is very convenient. I like the coffee and the ambiance is nice and relaxing and also the service was good. The staffs are very nice“

“Hot, cold, iced latte and the food are all amazing!“

“This is an amazing place. A little nondescript building with a gravel lot on Maple Lane in Bridgehampton, NY. It’s always busy. You’ll see workers, contractors, local folk, film directors and billionaires all in the same line to get some of the best coffee on earth. It’s a sight to behold.

They make the smoothest and tastiest Americano. My favorites to take home to grind are espresso and Bonacker. They bring in top notch pastries too on the morning. Get there early. They go quick.

When you’re there take a walk around and admire the artwork.

My favorite place.“

“Delicious and unique home made donuts and excellent service.“

“ya.good...................“

“Iced latte and coffee were delicious and I got to choose from two kinds of espresso for my latte which was unique. Usually I'm never asked. The barista was super friendly too! The market has lots of great stuff and their backyard is beautiful. It is a little pricy (paid $13ish without tip for the coffee and iced latte) but I think that may be par for the course with this area. Would definitely return!“

“Amazing addition to Sag Harbor! Sage and Madison is the ultimate curated boutique filled with incredible artisanal goods. Exceptional attention to detail and impeccable customer service! Perfect spot to find a special gift, pickup fresh baked goods for self-indulge! The owner and staff are warm and welcoming.“

“While visiting Greenport, I stumbled upon this charming café and instantly fell in love. Their bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich paired with a cinnamon bun became my go-to breakfast combo, and the coffee? Absolutely amazing.. smooth, strong, and perfectly balanced.

But let’s talk about their croissants! I tried the ham and cheese croissant, and it was next-level. Topped with everything bagel seasoning, it was perfectly flaky on the outside and soft on the inside... a total game-changer. Do not miss this one; it’s seriously special.

The staff was warm and friendly, and the cozy decor made it feel so inviting. I noticed they had donuts, but they were sold out when I visited. (Apparently, they make a limited batch each day, so getting there early is key!) It’s one of those places that feels like a hidden treasure—hard to leave and even harder to forget. If you’re in Greenport, this café is a must-visit!“

“What nice people! Such a pleasure to go in and talk with them and get recommendations. Everything they have is incredible. I love everything in this beautiful shop. I embarrass myself because I buy so much. People are happy when in this shop and smile and talk. If you eat one of their grilled cheese sandwiches you will lie in bed dreaming of them. Did I mention how nice everyone is. Linda“

“The service is great - Nicole is a fantastic ice cream Barista and the owner is very friendly. Their is comfortable and spacious indoor and outdoor seating, convenient parking in the rear of the building, interesting wall art and photos, and a variety of ice creams, greek yogurts, and smoothies. This place has been a staple in the Greenport community for many years, and hopefully many more to come.“

“The East Hampton Starbucks is hands-down one of the best Starbucks locations I’ve ever visited. From the moment you walk in, the staff greets you with genuine smiles and fast, friendly service. Even during busy summer mornings, they keep the line moving quickly without compromising quality. The drinks are always made perfectly—my iced coffee with cold foam came out smooth and balanced every time. The interior is clean and comfortable, with a modern vibe that fits right in with the Hamptons aesthetic. It’s a great place to grab your favorite drink and relax for a bit or take it to go while exploring the town. The location is super convenient, and the team behind the counter really seems to care about creating a good experience. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this Starbucks is a reliable go-to for top-tier coffee and excellent customer service.“

“The most important takeaway for me was the hospitality and kindness of the staff. I arrived on a quiet night not realizing that they were preparing to close. It would have been reasonable to say they closing, but without hesitation a hot chocolate was whipped up and they were so sweet about it.The hot chocolate was a perfect balance of nostalgic sweet chocolate with a gourmet touch that made it delicious. I grabbed a brownie at the last minute and was so glad i did. The brownie was fresh, soft on the inside, and moist. Would absolutely order this again and I am excited to try their other baked items.It was just a hot chocolate and brownie, but it warmed me up on a chilly night and their kindness made my night. Awesome little place with great people.“

“Great staff a lot of great tea and golden crocks 😜 can’t wait to go back“

“Delicious baguettes-traditional or multigrain. Also love the rye loaf to die for. Delicious coffee, pastries and hometown charm.“