8 Best Mexican Restaurants near Shelter Island

“Food is great, quick & friendly service“

“The best coffee ☕️ 🍮☕️☕️Good“

“Great atmosphere and food. Top shelf Mexican cuisine!!!“

“My grandson and I come in for the wings which we both love once once a week And we absolutely adore your little server Aly She’s the best! Keep up the good work“

“Amongst all the mediocrity out here, Cilantro’s really rises to the top. The food was great, it was well packaged for takeout, the place looked nice and clean inside, staff was a delight, and if you like hot sauce, I highly recommend trying the red stuff. It’s delish, and it’ll also give your pucker a facelift - if you catch my drift!“

“As usual the food and drinks were delicious. Unfortunately the waiter was rude. He screwed up my order. Then came over and twice asked me to admit I ordered something I didn’t. The waitresses were nice as always. Nothing was done by him. He did not apologize. Did not even offer to comp a drink or something. Not that I was looking for something free. He didn’t care. Really sad. At least the waitresses apologized.“

“The food was fantastic. We had the fajita platter and shared it, it was definitely enough for two people plus extra. It seems to be very popular as a takeout restaurant. We ate in and sat down, and the food took quite a while to come out. The time for our food to arrive was the reason I knocked a star down. Really good food, I recommend this place!“