The Islander
63 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island
(631) 749-1998
Customers' Favorites
Country Pot Roast
Mozzarella Sticks
Eggs Benedict
Menu
Photos
+46 photos
+45 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Just good diner food. Tacos and Fish and chips were tasty. French fries and salad with dressing, decent. The best part about the place is the cleanliness. The single server who was helping us on Monday, September 8 was a constant stream of activity, cleaning surfaces sweeping, just making sure everything was perfect. The islander is lucky to have her.
We came too early in the day for burger night. But we hope to come back on Monday for burger night.
We came too early in the day for burger night. But we hope to come back on Monday for burger night.
I've gone here my whole life, but two disappointing experiences recently.
1. On a weekend morning it was well understaffed with mediocre service, overheard multiple people get incorrect orders, the server was unable to communicate in English with the new employee who was supposed to help her I guess? She was getting upset at him.
2. (different day) A cash only restaurant should be able to break an 100$, I was sent to Chase myself when...
1. On a weekend morning it was well understaffed with mediocre service, overheard multiple people get incorrect orders, the server was unable to communicate in English with the new employee who was supposed to help her I guess? She was getting upset at him.
2. (different day) A cash only restaurant should be able to break an 100$, I was sent to Chase myself when...
You May Also Like
Maria's Kitchen - 55 N Ferry Rd
![]()
Mexican, Juice Bar & Smoothies, Salad
Kyle's - 27 N Ferry Rd
![]()
Bakery, Family, Vegetarian
Mike President Knights on Bikes