5 Best Caribbean Restaurants near Shirley

Stop n Nyamm Jamaican • $
921 Montauk Hwy, Shirley

Customers` Favorites

Oxtail and Curry Chicken
Horrible Rasta Pasta
Chicken Soup Large
Fried Plantains
Rice and Peas
Jerk Wings
Oxtail L
Snapper

“I had a great meal at this place food was on point and tasted very good . The service was great check it out for yourself“

3.2 Average48 Reviews
GOOD BICKLE Jamaican • $
617 Montauk Hwy, Center Moriches - 3.41 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fried Chicken
Curry Chicken
Jerk Chicken
Rasta Pasta
Coco Bread

“You can’t beat this place, I’ve been eating Jamaican food from Jamaica Ave Queens to Riverhead For many many years so I sent my Jamaican friend here he said it’s better than his family dishes . There a small mom pop place straight out of Jamaica and they. make Fresh food Everyday Every item is absolutely fresh . The spices the tenderness is Amazing. Especially the ox tail , Goat, Chicken it’s like butter . There saucers especially the spicy hot Kingston Sauce on the chicken wings is one of my favorite’s also the ox tail , curry sauce is delicious . You gotta try but make sure you call first to make sure there open and have food left“

4.4 Superb65 Reviews
Roti Shop Caribbean • $$
3632 NY-112, Coram - 8.04 miles

“Solid performance with each visit. Excellent menu of bistro favorites. Service very good. Tables side preparation of classics: steak tartare, bananas foster and crepes Suzette. Not many places where you can still get that kind of service and theater. Highly recommended.“

3.7 Good3 Reviews
Caribbean Spot 112 Caribbean • $
3632 NY-112, Coram - 8.04 miles

Customers` Favorites

Oxtail and Curry Goat over White Rice Cabbage and Sweet Plantains
Chicken Roti Canai
Cow Foot Soup
Jerk Chicken
Red Peas Soup
Oxtail Meal

“Had their stew peas and pigtail yesterday. Its was great. Loved the natural taste of coconut in the stew. Reminds me of when my mom used to cook. My daughter buys from them too. Always drove past and go next door to my appointment but never had the time to stop but I did yesterday and boy was I happy. So thanks guys for making my day yesterday. I would encourage anyone to stop and get a bite there.“

3.1 Average56 Reviews
Negril Restaurant Jamaican • $
3632 NY-112, Coram - 8.05 miles

Customers` Favorites

Rice and Peas with Fried Chicken and Steamed Vegetables
Rice \u0026 Peas with Oxtail and Veggies
Rice & Peas with Oxtail and Veggies
Negril Jerk Pork Chicken Salad
Rice and Peas with Stew Beef
Baked BBQ Chicken
Fried Plantains
Goat Head Soup
Jerk Chicken
Chicken Soup

“We first heard about this restaurant through a mutual friend. After checking it out for the first time we were absolutely sold! The food is so delicious and you receive very good portions. My wife loves the Oxtail and rice n peas and i enjoy their crunchy fried chicken. My son loves to get the curry goat grave with rice and pea and the staff gladly provides it for him. We love the staff there.Be sure to try out their breakfast menu too! It’s amazing! I don’t know who the chef is, but he’s a true chef and knows how to cook!And don’t pass up on the soups and natural juices, they taste great! It’s the only Jamaican restaurant outside of the city my family goes to for good food . Keep up the good work guys!“

3.5 Good54 Reviews