Paul's Italian American Restaurant

21 Hill St, Southampton
(631) 283-1861

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

French Onion Soup
Garlic Bread
Waffle Fries
Chicken Parm
Cheese Pizza
Seafood
Clams

Menu

Pasta Sides
FETTUCINE ALFREDO PASTA SIDE
FETTUCINE ALFREDO W/ BROCCOLI PASTA SIDE
CLAM SAUCE PASTA SIDE
MEAT SAUCE PASTA SIDE
PESTO SAUCE PASTA SIDE
MARINARA SAUCE PASTA SIDE
PENNE ALLA VODKA PASTA SIDE

Side Dishes
GRILLED VEGGIES
Eggplant, Zucchini, Red Onion, Broccoli, Tomato, Roasted Peppers
FRIES
waffles or shoe string
ONION RINGS
MEATBALLS Or SAUSAGE
2 meaballs in pomodoro sauce. * contains pork
BAKED POTATO (after 5, If before, fries will be served)
VEGETABLE of the DAY
spinach or broccoli (sauteed vegetables extra)

Lite Delites
GRILLED CHICKEN BREAST PLATTER
With choice of steamed vegetable (grilled or saut
GRILLED SHRIMP & VEGETABLE PLATTER
Over risotto with eggplant, zucchini, roasted peppers & tomato
SPINACH CHICKEN DELITE
Served on baby-leaf spinach with bacon bits, hard-boiled egg, roasted peppers & diced cucumbers
VEGGIE MESCLUN SALAD
With avocado, tomatoes, grilled eggplant, roasted peppers over mesclun greens
GRILLED EGGPLANT
On Italian rustic bread with tomato, fresh mozzarella & balsamic marinated mesclun greens, served with house salad

Burgers
CHEESE BURGER PLATTER
Our 1/2 Lb burgers are served on a sesame bun with lettuce & tomato, choice of fries, house salad, steamed vegetables or baked potato
HAMBURGER PLATTER
Our 1/2 Lb burgers are served on a sesame bun with lettuce & tomato, choice of fries, house salad, steamed vegetables or baked potato
BACON CHEESE BURGER PLATTER
Our 1/2Lb burgers are served on a sesame bun with lettuce & tomato, choice of fries, house salad, steamed vegetables or baked potato
PIZZA BURGER PLATTER
Our 1/2 Lb burgers are served on a sesame bun with lettuce & tomato, choice of fries, house salad, steamed vegetables or baked potato
TURKEY BURGER PLATTER
Our 1/2 Lb burgers are served on a sesame bun with lettuce & tomato, choice of fries, house salad, steamed vegetables or baked potato

Heros
MEATBALL PARMIGIANA HERO
STEAK HERO
with sauteed onions and mozzarella cheese
EGGPLANT PARMIGIANA HERO
VEAL CUTLET PARMIGIANA HERO
SHRIMP PARMIGIANA HERO
SAUSAGE & PEPPERS PARMIGAN HERO
MEATBALL AND SAUSAGE PARMIGIANA HERO
SAUSAGE & Pepper PARMIGIANA HERO
CHICKEN CUTLET PARMIGIANA HERO

Featured items
CREATE YOUR OWN OMELETTE-THREE ITEMS
CREATE YOUR OWN OMELETTE - TWO ITEMS
SPINACH & FETA OMELETTE
French Toast
3 slices, dipped and cooked delicately
Short Stack French Toast
Egg Sandwiches On A Roll
CHEESE OMELETTE
Perfectly cooked with our fabulous home fries and your choice of cheese
WESTERN OMELETTE
sauteed ham, peppers and onions combined with eggs
TOMATO, ONION & PROVOLONE
ALL AMERICAN OMELETTE
Your choice of bacon, ham or sausage with your choice of cheese

Sandwiches & things
Egg Sandwiches On A Roll
Bacon or Sausage on Roll
Egg White Wrap
with Turkey, Swiss and Tomato
Western Egg Wrap
Ham, Pepper, Onions and Cheddar
American Egg Wrap
Ham, Bacon and American
Veggie Egg Wrap
Spinach, Mushroom and Tomato

Farm Fresh Eggs
One Egg Any Style
Two Egg Any Style
Three Egg Any Style

Outrageous Omelettes
CHEESE OMELETTE
Perfectly cooked with our fabulous home fries and your choice of cheese
WESTERN OMELETTE
sauteed ham, peppers and onions combined with eggs
ALL AMERICAN OMELETTE
Your choice of bacon, ham or sausage with your choice of cheese
SPINACH & FETA OMELETTE
MUSHROOM, BROCCOLI & CHEDDAR
TOMATO, ONION & PROVOLONE
CREATE YOUR OWN OMELETTE - TWO ITEMS
CREATE YOUR OWN OMELETTE-THREE ITEMS

Great Griddles
French Toast
3 slices, dipped and cooked delicately
Short Stack French Toast
Pancakes
3 Buttermilk pancakes perfectly cooked
Short Stack Of Pancakes

Side Orders
BACON, HAM or SAUSAGE
TOAST
ENGLISH MUFFINS
BAGELS

For The Kids
KID'S PANCAKE
Kids FRENCH TOAST (Slice)
ONE EGG KIDS
any style with Toast (home fries included!)

Premium
TWO BUTTERMILK PANCAKES
with Two Eggs, any style and Home Fries
TWO FRENCH TOAST
with Two Eggs, any style and Home Fries

Steak and Eggs
Steak Cooked To liking
Served with Two Eggs, Our Fabulous home Fries and Choice of Toast

Featured items
GRANDMA PIZZA
Calzones
Buffalo Chicken Slice
Chicken Bacon Cheddar Ranch Slice
Chicken Parm Slice
Chicken Caesar Slice

Pizza (Neopolitan)
GRANDMA PIZZA
Calzones
10 " Cauliflower Pizza
w/ Fresh Mozzarella & Basil w/ Homemade Marinara Sauce
CHEESE PIZZA
SHRIMP PIZZA
FRESH BASIL & MOZZARELLA PIZZA
WHITE PIZZA
PESTO PLUM PIZZA
CHICKEN BACON CHEDDAR RANCH PIZZA
BUFFALO CHICKEN PIZZA
PAUL'S SPECIAL
sausage, meatball, pepper & onion
HAMPTON GARDEN
broccoli, mushrooms, olives, fresh garlic and artichoke hearts
SICILIAN PIZZA
10" GLUTEN FREE PIZZA
12" PERSONAL BAR PIZZA
CHICKEN CAESAR PIZZA

Pan Pizza
CHEESE PAN PIZZA
VEGGIE PAN PIZZA
mushrooms, eggplant, onion and olives
SEAFOOD PAN PIZZA
Shrimp & Clams

Pizza Slices
Buffalo Chicken Slice
Grandma Slice
Chicken Parm Slice
Chicken Caesar Slice
Chicken Bacon Cheddar Ranch Slice
Cheese Slice
Fresh Basil & Mozzarella Slice
White Pizza Slice

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: google
+71 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+70 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Paul,

First off I'm slightly confused, I ordered some pies from David. I seem to have ended up with a box of sloppy pizza from yourself.

One that's kinda good because I got the pizza.

On a second note I did need to eat the Margherita over the hedge and did spill some tomato juice on the decking and the exterior carpet and gas powered fire pit (that was my colleague). As you can understand I'm sure there will...
October 2024
Under new management. The online menu doesn't make sense, and you get completely different information when you call. Most annoying,, pasta is included with the dinner, but if you want sauce with the pasta, that will cost an additional $7. A prior review suggested the pan pizza. It's just a loaf of bread, with little sauce and cheese on top. Generally speaking, the food is still okay. But not as good as when Paul was running things.
March 2024
A great affordable traditional Italian restaurant and pizzeria. Whether you're looking for a slice, a sandwich or a full Italian entree, Paul's has you covered. A Southampton institution.
February 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Limoncello Ristorante - 21 Hill St
Italian
Windmill Lane Bakery - 17 Windmill Ln
Bakery, Vegetarian
El Verano - 10 Windmill Ln
New Mexican Cuisine, Mexican, Cocktail Bar

Paul's Italian American Restaurant

21 Hill St, Southampton, NY 11968
(631) 283-1861