Benny's Pizzeria
3835 US-209, Stone Ridge
(845) 687-4243
Customers' Favorites
Chicken Bacon & Ranch Pizza
Battered Mozzarella Sticks
Sicilian Slice or Grandmas
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Fresh Mushroom Pizza
Philly Cheese Steak
Jumbo Garlic Knots
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Chicken Sandwich
Grilled Chicken
Menu
Photos
+33 photos
+32 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
My wife and I moved from New Paltz to High Falls recently, and this is the best pizza in the area. Where other pizzas lack toppings and are either over or undercooked consistently, Benny’s is always cooked perfectly with delicious dough, crust and plenty of toppings. Their dough is actually the best I’ve ever had anywhere! There’s no reason to go anywhere but here to get delicious pizza and wings (that’s all we’ve tried so far) - and I’m sure their other food is just...
Was a fantastic local pizzeria, stopped here with family on my way up to Massachusetts was an awesome place, the pizza was the best, fresh grown tomatoes out front they use in the sauce it was delicious
They've been a staple for years. The pizza is great and the atmosphere as well. Unfortunately, the staff has become distant with the public, and the pizza prices are INSANE. 25 dollars for a large pizza is literal NYC prices.
You May Also Like
Ming Moon - 3855 Main St
![]()
Chinese, Asian, Cantonese
Dunkin' - 3853 Main St
![]()
Coffee Shops, Donuts, Coffee & Tea, Coffee
Butterfield - 3805 Main St
![]()
Fine Dining, American, Bar, Vegetarian, New American