Comfort Food Restaurants near Windham, NY

“We had a family reunion up in Windham and had a gathering for 30 at Chicken Run. From the moment I sent an inquiry and Cathy got back to me things were handled professionally. Cathy answered all of my questions and kept in touch by email as well as phone calls and text. Upon arrival they could not have been more helpful, attentive and kind.
Our server Melanie was absolutely wonderful. We had her separate bar tabs for whomever was drinking, not easy to keep all of that straight but she did it with a smile. She could not have been more attentive and kind. We had the most incredible weather. They opened all the garage windows so we brought the outside in and some sat outside around the fire pit. It was perfect. When the Music started l, the singer oh my, he was fabulous.
Let’s talk about the food, we chose the most expensive buffet package because we wanted the prime rib. Well let me tell you, they did not disappoint. The amount of food was insane, and everything was absolutely delicious. Chicken, eggplant parm, ribs, prime rib, mac and cheese etc. The prime rib was an entire roast, I thought for sure it would be shaved in a shaving dish, but it was a carving station, that alone was worth the money.
I can’t say enough about the service, the owner being on hand to help and the food.
If you are thinking of having a gathering in Windham this is your place. Get the prime rib!!!!
I can’t wait to come back.“

“We had dinner here twice during our stay at the Hunter Lodge. Both times we had the pleasure of being served by Stephanie, who was warm, knowledgeable, and very patient :) The first night, we ordered the smash burger and chicken sandwich, and our kids had the chicken tenders and kids hamburger. All meals were great, but the smash burger was the winner! There was also live music, which made the meal even more special. The second evening we had the fish and chips, kids mac and cheese, and the gnocchi (served pot pie style). Fries were hot and delicious both nights. Again, we were really happy with the dishes, and shout out to the team for keeping the restaurant open on a Monday (when it’s normally closed) because of the snowstorm. It made our stay that much more memorable!! Looking forward to coming back in the fall :)“

“Such kind and accommodating people! Jaie was our waitress and was attentive, prompt, and so nice to our very large party of 20. The entire night was made possible due to the great staff here, absolutely would be back. Food was delicious, with large portions! Additionally, beautiful property for great photos!“