Tomaso's Italian Villa
CLOSED$ •
About Tomaso's Italian Villa
Tomaso's Italian Villa Reviews
I agree with a few other people. Prices have doubled since new ownership and the pizza is very different. It's a shame definitely won't be back.
I have been going to Tomaso’s since I was born (30+ years ago), it was always my favorite pizza, even when I moved away for a while I had to have it as soon as I came back.
I was so sad when I heard they were closing but hopeful when I heard things would be staying the same. I gave them the benefit of the doubt last Friday and went for dinner with my son.
It was 7pm on a Friday and the place was entirely empty, only us and one other person sitting at the bar, one...read full review
My family and I have been going here for years! We were so happy to hear that it wasn’t going to close and instead get new owners. I was under the impression everything would be the same. So far Definitely some bumps for the new owners. Way too much cheese, so much rosemary it made our stomachs upset, the sauce is completely different, the crust was not thin, pizza was very wonky looking, and they have made the pizzas smaller but kept the prices the same but for a lower quality....read full review
Tomaso's Italian Villa offers a variety of dishes, with the Bianco pizza and sausage options receiving mixed reviews. The restaurant has recently undergone renovations, making the atmosphere feel more modern but also somewhat colder and less welcoming. The interior updates include a new bar area and repairs that improve the overall look. The service is generally quick and friendly, although some customers have experienced slow service with only one waitress.
The food quality has seen some changes. While the pizza still looks and smells familiar, some customers feel the sauce is different and less flavorful, and the dough and cheese remain the same. However, others notice that the pizza size has gotten smaller and the toppings, especially the cheese and rosemary, are now excessive, sometimes upsetting stomachs. The menu can be confusing due to different names and limited options, and prices have increased significantly. A party-sized cheese pizza, two salads, two drinks, and breadsticks used to cost around $25, but now a similar meal costs more, with some dishes like the meatball sub priced steeply at $15.
Overall, Tomaso's Italian Villa maintains a friendly atmosphere, but food quality and pricing inconsistencies have been noted. Despite some disappointments, many customers still consider it a place worth trying again, hoping the new ownership will restore its former charm and quality.