8 Best Bakeries in Chillicothe

1 Crumbl

4.8 Superb 410 Reviews

1075 North Bridge Street Suite 202, Chillicothe

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Cleanest store I’ve EVER visited - and I’ve been to stores all across the country! Super friendly employees that give a genuine warm welcome with ridiculously fast quality service! I order online and pickup in store and always have a seamlessly flawless experience! I couldn’t recommend this store more! Whoever is running this place knows what they’re doing, hiring quality employees and providing an excellent customer experience every single time!! This is just one photo of many many many visits that I’ve made to Crumbl - And I’ve never once been the slightest bit disappointed! 5 STARS ALL AROUND to the Chillicothe location!!!”

2 Crispie Creme Donut Shop

4.8 Superb 298 Reviews

47 North Bridge Street, Chillicothe

• Take-Out

“Absolute incredible baking center. Have had many large corporate meetings and they have always been able to accommodate regardless of the day or time.”

3 Shanks Bakery and Boba

4.6 Superb 185 Reviews

107 East 2nd Street, Chillicothe

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I had lemon cheesecake, and it was the most amazing cheesecake ever!! The taste was beyond words.”

4 Rustic Whisk Baking Co.

5.0 Superb 11 Reviews

820 Spud Run Rd, Chillicothe

“Georgia did an amazing job on an updated replica of the top of my wedding cake. Not only was it gorgeous, but it was also delicious! So moist and flavorful. I was so surprised and happy at how wonderful it turned out.”

5 Cinnabon

4.0 Good 9 Reviews

1111 East Main Street, Chillicothe

• Delivery

6 New System Bakery

4.3 Superb 78 Reviews

125 Western Avenue, Chillicothe

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I give them five stars for food, the staff, and the coffee. They make my mornings fabulous. It’s my favorite Coffee shop/bakery. It’s 45 minutes from my house, but if I have a reason to go to Chillicothe…I’m stopping there🤭”

7 Livy Cakes & Two Roasting Joes

4.3 Superb 87 Reviews

659 North High Street, Chillicothe

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Awesome cakes! My friends surprised me with a birthday cake from here and I would absolutely order from here in the future. The cake tasted great and even had a fruit filling. Highly recommend!”

8 Tim Hortons

3.5 Good 158 Reviews

1100 East Main Street, Chillicothe

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Perfect pit stop while traveling through Chillicothe! Tim Hortons served up reliably good coffee in a clean, friendly setting just steps from our hotel—super convenient. The Iced Caramel Latte was exactly what I needed to recharge, smooth and satisfying. Great service, quick turnaround, and a cozy vibe that made it more than just a coffee run. A solid choice for travelers and locals alike.”