Presti's Bakery

12101 Mayfield Rd, Cleveland
(216) 421-3060

Recent Reviews

Ted Vartorella

Nice lunch and pastries! Haven't been here for a couple of years. Had very nice lunch and pastries to go!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Meat Stromboli, Bakery, Cannoli Small

Audrey

I stop here when I am home, and I love their pastries soooo much. Their lunch foods can be hit or miss. The pastries, though, delectable. Their easter pastries are so yummy. I love the chocolate mousse, raspberry mousse, fruit tart, peanut butter brownie, and kolaczkis. I had their quiche for the first time the other day, and I was pleased! A coffee is always good here, too. Gellato in the summer is also a nice treat. Just make sure to take a number and wait to be called when you walk in. My family has ordered large cassata cake here over the phone for an event, too, and it did not disappoint!Parking: I always park on random street a block away and usually find something. Parking is always difficult in little italy, especially on the weekend

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cookies, Cassata Cake, Croissants, Raspberry Mousse, Brownies, Chocolate Mousse, Gellato, Pepperoni Bread, Cannoli Small, Choc Cannoli Cake Lobstertail

Buffalo Bills

I have to be honest this is why this place gets a 1star. We stoped in Friday night and got a cannoli & espresso both on point. We noticed they have food, so we decided to come back Saturday after the game to eat & have desert. So I ordered the chicken cutlet and asked the girl how they serve it. She said they warm and put it on a plate. I asked can I get it as a sub or sandwich? She tells me we are out of bread. Is the word bakery in your name and on the outside sign. 5pm on a Saturday night and you have no bread. Come on really I guess when you do so much business it don’t matter if you run out of bread. Well we walked out and went to Corbo’s Bakery. They had bread for my chicken cutlet sub. I know my $65 I spent down the street you won’t miss it. But I won’t spend a dime in your place ever again. Lets try to do better if you want to use Bakery in you name.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 2

Sima Kooshi

The rudest people work there! I never go there

Steviejr

One of the best pastries I’ve ever had was the amaretto lobster tail, the filling was perfect and the pastry had a fantastic crunch to it. The cappuccino and coffee was also pretty good, but getting served took quite a while. The pizza with red sauce and sausage was quite good but the artichoke pizza tasted more like a flatbread and was mostly bread with no sauce. Overall really good pastries!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Cookies, Cannoli Small

Barbara Warp

Great food and staff

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cookies, Bakery

S

Parking: You must drive around searching for a pkng space. No available pkng. Take someone with you who can go in and p/u your order.Plan on waiting in line s/t up to 2 hrs regardless of the time you were told to pick up your food.You take a number & wait for it to be called. If you miss the # being called or if they make a mistake and go out of order, to bad. No one will help or address the issue with the exception of maybe 1 of the owners who have always been very nice & helpful.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Veggie Stromboli, Salad Bar, Meat Stromboli, Bakery, Cannoli Small

Pil G

Food looks good but even dough it's all preparer, they are suuuuuper slow. I came in and took a 53 number and they were serving order12. I decided to wait but after 20min othey were in 25 order and a lot for those had not been customers as it looks many people left as I did...

Atmosphere: 3

Service: 1

Janice McKernan

First time there! love this place ❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cookies, Brownies, Bakery

Robert Frazier

Lots of options to choose from. Lemon Bar was awesome. Can't wait to return and try more.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sebastian Kalen

We went to this place for lunch on a Saturday at 2:30 PM. It took 45 minutes waiting in line just to place the order and the food was just OK. The place is incredibly disorganized and run by unprofessional staff. Several times the staff had to come back to us standing at the counter to ask what we ordered. Nothing was written down on paper. I didn't see a POS ordering system either. This restaurant is badly in need of a manager to streamline their operation and get people their foods in 15 min rather than 60 min. I am sure their pastries are great but we did not stick around to sample that after the train wreck of the lunch line.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 1

David Alki

Very delicious bakery eats.Also have food..

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cookies, Salad Bar, Bakery, Cinnamon Roll

David Bailey

Wonderful tira misu and wonderful carrot cake. Stopped in for a quick treat and an espresso. Definitely some you should not miss.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Melissa Lovelace

I love Prestis because of the variety on the menu. The employees and customers are both pleasant. I go at least three times a week.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nikki D.

Stopped in on a whim and had the pleasure of being assisted by Isaac, great personality! Ordered tiramisu, a chocolate canoli, a slice of Italian cheesecake and cassata. Thumbs up to all except I wouldn't purchase the cassata again. The strawberries were good and the whipped cream was good and heavy, but the cake itself was tasteless. I will stick to Barona's for the best cassata in CLE. I visited in the evening and the place was nice clean and calm. Stop in and see for yourself. Good atmosphere and great slection.

Load More