Pizza Restaurants near Columbus Grove

Aguirre's Fillin' Station Pizza •
404 N Main St, Columbus Grove
4.5 Superb4 Reviews
The Pizzeria Pizza • $
112 N High St, Columbus Grove

Customers` Favorites

Cheesy Garlic Bread
Pizza

“Nice place. Scenery is full of the town's team, Bulldogs. There's a pool table. There's a few other things that give a nice vibe.I've never seen a pizza where the pepperoni is under the cheese. That's how they do it here though lolI'm from NY and every pizzeria has spices that you can add. At the very least garlic and pepper. They only had some spicy pepper flakes, what?My wife didn't like it much but my daughter and I thought it was good enough.Had a ton of cheese.I'd life to try their other menu items another day.Parking: There's a good amount of spots for their free parking.Kid-friendliness: My daughter lived it. Lots of things on the wall to keep busy. There was a small pinball machine too.“

3.1 Average11 Reviews
Highland Lanes, Ottawa, Ohio Pizza •
1895 E 4th St, Ottawa - 7.28 miles
5 Superb20 Reviews
Uncle Al's Pizza Pizza • $
4305 Lincoln Hwy, Gomer - 8.51 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pizza

“Love coming back to Gomer just for Uncle Al’s. My kids raised on this fine pizza and everything else this quaint local store has to offer. They are like extended family! Hope everyone will continue to support this worthy community business!“

4.9 Superb17 Reviews
Casey's Pizza Takeaway •
730 N Taft Ave, Ottawa - 7.32 miles

“Yo super big shout out to lorrie and her crew the night of 11-10 for accommodating me bring a over sized truck drive letting me stop here and block the parking lot while I got food and drink tonight Ty so much again and the food was amazing and everyone was so nice. Also the store was stocked and very clean. A+++“

5 Superb7 Reviews
Thirsty's Food & Spirits - Best Local Pizza Pizza • $
317 E Main St #9725, Beaverdam - 7.5 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Pepperoni Mushroom Pizza
Build Your Own Calzone
Place Chicken Chunks
Chicken Wings
Deluxe Pizza
Loaded Nachos

“This evening we had a delicious pizza topped with ham, bacon, and extra cheese. Even the sauce was outstanding; it tasted fresh and homemade.Kid-friendliness: It was nice to see a dart game at the restaurant for kids to play instead of playing games on their phones while waiting on their food.“

4.4 Superb51 Reviews
Bluelick General Store Pizza • $
3497 Slabtown Rd, Lima - 9.03 miles

“Good food and Ice Cream. Shredded Chicken sandwich, Tenderloin and Onion Rings and Double Cheese with Bacon and Chocolate Shake and Natural Disaster / M & M Flurry Were Very Yummy. Come Out & Support Them. If You need Extra $$$ They are Hiring Hard Worker's.“

4.5 Superb8 Reviews
The Bombshelter Carry Out & Bar Pizza • $
100 Ottawa-Glandorf Rd, Ottawa - 7.07 miles

Customers` Favorites

Oven Baked Nachos
Cheeseburger
Pizza

“Hard to say too much because the food options were limited due to a broken grill. Ordered a deluxe sub which tasted good but was also burned. Family ordered a pepperoni pizza. Sauce and cheese were good but the crust was tough and hard to bite through. Service was okay but the waitress forgot our drinks until we reminded her. Pretzel sticks were good and the prices were reasonable.“

4.4 Superb19 Reviews
Pizzeria Pizza • $
1085 N Perry St, Ottawa - 7.51 miles

Customers` Favorites

Three Topping Pizza
Two Topping Pizza

“We got a large pizza with pepperoni and sausage. It was very good. The crust is one of the best crusts I have had. The sauce is not too sweet. I would say just right amount and plenty of pepperoni and sausage. Just a tad too much cheese for me and I like my cheese a little browned. A large was enough to feed 4 of us. All and all it was a very nice meal and worth the price.Vegetarian options: They have pasta.Parking: Any number of spots you can park in.Kid-friendliness: All kids love pizza. So they willl love this place.Wheelchair accessibility: Yes they have wheelchair entrance.“

4.4 Superb10 Reviews
Bluelick Ice cream And Pizza Pizza Delivery • $
3497 Slabtown Rd, Lima - 9.03 miles

“We order consistently from them and the pizza is always great. Their chicken chunks and wings are great and their Buffalo Ranch sauce is the best wing sauce ever. Their cheeseburgers are the best around! Highly recommend you stop in for a reasonably priced delicious meal. Top it off with some of the best soft serve ice cream around.“

4.4 Superb10 Reviews
The Pizzeria Pizza • $
206 E Main St, Pandora - 5.39 miles

“This was our first time to Pandora Ohio. This restaurant was right around the corner. We ordered pizza, baked subs, mozzarella sticks, and the small calzones. Oh, and a personal pasta. First, it was cheap. I had the chicken bacon ranch sub, but I sampled all. I was very surprised. All the food was great. Google had 3 reviews but it sounded like someone had a grudge. I'll eat there anytime.“

4.2 Good16 Reviews
Poppy's Elida Depot Pizza • $
430 E Kiracofe Ave, Elida - 11.87 miles

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Parmesan Bread
Pepperoni Pizza
Boneless Wings

“The pizza was good, but the cheesy bread is dynamite! 0rdered a build your own pizza, toppings were great, crust is thin and over worked. Because it's over worked it makes it a little chewy. This isn't the only kind of pizza they have though. Perhaps next time I order from here I will try the Detroit style or wings.“

4.2 Good21 Reviews
Smoke-E's Bar & Grill Bar & Grill • $
403 Ottawa St, Kalida - 8.44 miles

Customers` Favorites

Smokin'b's Special
Flatbread Pizza
Smothered Chips
Pulled Pork
Onion Rings
BBQ Plate
Sandwich
Slaw

“Busy but comfortable atmosphere. Service pleasant although nervous with our large group. She did great! Fish was alright, looking forward to going back and trying other options. Chicken wings (for kids meal) looked and smelled amazing . Clean restrooms tooKid-friendliness: Great for whole family“

4.1 Good34 Reviews
14

Casey's

Casey's Pizza Delivery • $
4411 Elida Rd, Elida - 11.77 miles

“I usually stop at Casey's further west. And, in the morning. (They have great donuts!) I'd heard online that Casey's has great roadfood pizza. They'right! Not only is it great roadfood, but also great pizza in general! I had a slice each of the pepperoni and plain. I'd rate both on a par with what I've had in upstate New York. However, if you're from out-of-state, I cannot recommend a special trip here. Unless your compliance with traffic law is super-human, you risk being stopped by law enforcement. On the preceding day, I was stopped for doing barely seven mph over the limit while trying to pass a dump truck, the driver of which sped-up upon seeing the cop in the center median. I slowed-down, got behind the truck and was then stopped by an OHP officer. I got a "Friendly Reminder" warning ticket for speeding. Next time, you or I might not be as lucky. I mention this because the next day, while en-route to Lima, I was followed by an Ohio Highway Patrol officer for nearly ten miles after getting off U.S. 30. I saw the officer in my rearview mirror make a U-turn to follow me. (I have out-of-state 'vanity' plates. Chances are his/her "plate reader" caught that I had recently been stopped.) OHP, I have learned my lesson. I am now a much more careful driver. But, I am now also a very fearful driver. And, I now regard Ohio as a "drive thru" state. I'll refuel before entry and again after exiting the state. While I won't let this experience deter me from going to places in Ohio which I enjoy, I won't be as enthusiastic -or as likely to return soon. Ohio has fallen to 51st of U.S. jurisdictions to spend my money in. Sometimes actions have unintended consequences. Watch your driving here very, very carefully. Even getting a "warning ticket" on a traffic stop ruins a vacation“

3.9 Good24 Reviews