22 Best Steakhouses in Columbus

“Food was excellent, have tried to resolve a charge on my CC. After 4 calls I have not gotten any resolution or return calls. I guess my expectation of service was too high. I thought I was dealing with a service-oriented restaurant not a chain steakhouse.“

“First time dining here. Wanted to take my wife somewhere special for a night away that we don't get often. We were not disappointed. Nicholas was our server and he did a wonderful job. Very informative on menu and very kind. Food was delicious! Will be back for sure.“

“Always a great time at The Avenue, but Brady really set the bar tonight. Constantly checking on us, very attentive to us and everyone around us, and never skipped a beat when it came to explaining specials and answering our questions. Can’t wait to come back!“

“Ordered the medallion meal. The meat was all fat and gristle.“

“My favorite place, steak is seasoned well. Also cooked right. Spinach dip and French onion soup are a must try in my opinion. The stuffed mushrooms are so good but roo expensive in my opinion. Also a must try is the brussel sprouts. Even if you think you don't like them try these ones they have a honey glaze that's (chef's kiss lol)“

“My workplace held a private event here and everything was outstanding. From the food to the service, everything was perfectly coordinated. The staff go above and beyond to ensure that your event goes as you wish and are respectful, timely, and lovely to work with. The food was really incredible and the Preston room was ideal for our event. Thank you, Butcher & Rose, and to Jaime, our waitperson.“

“Always a good time and good food with a laid back atmosphere“

“Our server Manny was amazing , even though we aren’t from the area we will be back!“

“We really enjoyed our meals here. The filet mignon was cooked perfectly, tender and great flavor. The wood fired chicken was equally good. We would've preferred the roasted vegetables be a bit more cooked. They were hot but basically still raw. The desserts that came with the 3 course meal were all tasty and generous in size. Would definitely recommend the creme brulee cheesecake... outstanding. The only thing that kept this from 5 stars is the ridiculously cold air conditioning. Our server said she'd talk to the manager about it, but nothing ever changed. The food cooled off very quickly, and we were frozen by the end of the meal.“

“We were very impressed with both the food and the service. Will definitely return when we are in Columbus!“

“My goodness Ross was BEYOND amazing, I haven’t had customer service like that in years ! I see why my parents love coming here. He knew them by name which was very impressive! His customer service will definitely have us back as a family.“

“I had a great dinner on Tuesday, 9th with St. Paul Lutheran Church group. I may have lost a gold wedding band (seated at the rear group tables, back left corner). I appreciate the extra searching done by your staff. In case it should be found, please contact me at 614 8782562. Thank for checking and plan to enjoy more dinners with you!! Marie Rehbeck“

“Prime rib and top mac and cheese

Food was very good, like prime rib and rich mac and cheese should be.

I made a reservation for 1 yet they sat me for two and didnt serve me for a while because they thought i was waiting on someone, which was somewhat annoying.

It was a friday night so it was packed and noisy. Would like to revisit on a slower day/time for a peaceful experience.“

“I loved every second being here! The ambience is great, the food is great, and service is great too. Meagan, my server, was just the best came around at just the right times and made me feel very comfortable and welcome here. Would come again :)“

“my girlfriend came all the way to pick up our order you forgot the blooming onions I love those looked forward to them“

“big roaches don't go unless you want to be sick I sat in my car and threw up for 10 minutes these were definitely deformed roaches carrying pesticides“

“First time to this location. Restaurant was clean. Service was great. Server was Melby. He was attentive. Never asked for anything because it was always there. The workers functioned as a team. They were supportive of each other which is needed to keep a restaurant flow going. Are food was tasty but on the salty side. Will go back.“

“May 26 2025 Anderson’s Thanks to Angela our waitress our dinner service was excellent!! Hope you enjoy your pen! It’s refillable!! Sincerely, Teresa Flannery Anderson“

“Went to Final Cut with family for Father’s Day dinner!! Filet was cooked perfectly! I had the salmon which was amazing and spot on as well! Service was impeccable! Lindsay was incredible! I ordered a Riesling but they did not have it in stock so she brought me Moscato to try. Loved the Moscato! Never had to ask to refill water! Table was always cleaned! Dishes were cleared as soon as they were empty! Shared a chocolate cake for the finale!! We will definitely be back!!!“

“The food is all delicious and perfectly prepared. The filet melts in your mouth. The service is great as well - not hovering but always available. This is a posh place. You'll want to wear at least chinos and a collared shirt and can be much more formal than that if you want.“

“Great food, with friendly service“

“Food is very good. It was great.“