Mitchell's Steakhouse

$$$ • Steak House

45 N 3rd St, Columbus
(614) 621-2333


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Mitchell's Steakhouse

Our server was mixing up all of our orders with other tables and forgetting our orders and they were coming out incorrectly. When they were she did not take the food back to the kitchen she just moved the food from one table to another. With covid, this is not safe at all. She did not seem well (mentally). If it was not for the manager to step in and resolve our issue and her other tables, this would have gotten so much worse

Common. Disappointed. Started with an insect in a water glass, really bad wine selection, I accepted the second bottle - my mistake. Parm crisps on the Caesar were burnt very badly. Waiter never recognized either issue with an recognition nor an apology. Thinking must have been new. This was 30year anniversary, not sure why inexperienced waiter was assigned for us. Staff knew that was the occasion. Lobster bisque and Steaks were excellent. Prepared well. Did leave an 18% for full review

We returned our Medium steaks because they were well done. Then we got new steaks - rare. One of the guests - who was the guest of honor - gave up and just sent it back. One took it home to cook the next day. Since I was the host I was very disappointed in my choice.

More Reviews(285)


Monday Closed
Tuesday 4:30 - 9PM
Wednesday 4:30 - 9PM
Thursday 11:30AM - 9PM
Friday 11:30AM - 9:30PM
Saturday 4:30 - 9:30PM
Sunday 4:30 - 9PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.