22 Best American Restaurants in Elyria

“This was my first time visiting and my experience was quite pleasant. It is a weekday so there was no wait. The place is clean and you don't feel like your sharing your table with strangers. The food was good, nice sized portions with a fair price, and the service was on point. I will definitely go again“

“The pizza of the month was the best thing I’ve ever had here. It was amazing!“

“Just visited here with my boyfriend tonight and we were the only people in the front dining room! The food was great and very great value. Feel like they are getting screwed because of the construction right there. Would have went past it myself if my boyfriend hasn’t been there before and pointed it out. Very much recommend. Will be back very soon. :)“

“Elyria Rotary Club just brought in a group of 15 and we had the best time. Delicious food and really AWESOME service from Remy! 🤩5 Stars!! Thanks for taking such great care of us!“

“Love everything about this place.“

“The waiter Anthon was great at the Ruby Tuesday in Elyria,OHIO and the food was amazing.“

“Our first visit to Wolfe's and we were quite impressed. Seated at a window table in the bar, very comfortable. Greeted by Eileen who was super nice. Went over the menu with us, took our drink order. Ordered a pepperoni & sausage calzone to start. DELICIOUS!!! Dave had a steak salad and I had grilled cheese sandwich with chips. We finished the afternoon off by ordering 2 specialty pizzas to go. I can't stress enough the excellent service Eileen gave us. We will definitely be back and ask for a table with Eileen. Thank you, Eileen! Carol and Dave“

“Yummy! Me and my hubby stopped in after our appointments today. Had a delicious breakfast. I got corned beef hash, sunny side up egg and he got chopped steak and eggs and we split some pancakes 🥞. Everything was cooked to perfection, flavorful and great price. Waitress was a sweetheart too! This is the type of place we both grew up eating at with our grandparents. Hope to bring our kids with us in the future one day. Happy customers!“

“Ate here on a whim on our way back from Columbus. We decided let’s choose a local restaurant instead of a big chain. Glad we did because the oh boy burger was awesome! That sauce is amazing!“

“Whitney was our server. she was very polite and the service was outstanding!!“

“Good service and appreciate the variety“

“If you miss nostalgia,and going back to simpler time, this is the place for you!! My wife was so excited because she remembered this place from her childhood in Chesterland. You couldn't wipe the smile off her face. And yes it didn't disappoint. Will definitely be bringing her back. Thank you!!!“

“My family and I traveled back to our hometown in Ohio for a funeral. We wanted to have some fun to cheer us up and we got in late, so this was the only place open later on a Sunday. We were so happy that we could let go and have a nice time together for some affordable bowling and some good food. The bartender was very helpful and she gave great service. Thank you to the staff for lightening our night last week.“

“Good drinks,food & SERVICE“

“Great food, friendly staff and super service. Please help support our areas small businesses.“

“Great wings great bartender and nice atmosphere!“

“Me and my 2 daughters usually stop in on the weekends and we love their breakfast always fast service we love Jackie she is always friendly and does a great job serving us :)“

“Our server Lisa was amazing. It was very busy but she was on top of everything. Our drinks and food came out very fast and she was so attentive with refills and sides. She was also very nice and informative. Best experience I’ve had at a restaurant. She deserves a raise“

“My husband and I arrived just before closing on a Sunday night. The staff was incredibly kind---even welcomed us with a smile.
Our server was Melissa. She was attentive and and treated us as if it was the beginning of her shift. I am now re-evaluating how I approach my employment. I finished my meal inspired to do a better job where I work---and most of all, to be more kind.
Thank you to all of those working on a Sunday night February 23, 2025.“

“I love this place the server are wonderful and management is concern about how your treated the place is clean clean clean and safety is #1 priority“

“Superior restaurant employees are the best I’ve seen in a very long time if you enjoy great food awesome service this is the place“

“I gotta say, I travel alot for work and chains aren't usually my favorite but this was a great experience at this location. Jessica my waitress was AWESOME and so attentive. Not only to me but I watched how she treated other customers as well and she's just that way. Food was also great, I'll definitely come back.“