Pizza Restaurants near Gibsonburg

“Nice to see an old Gibsonburg Family run icon Still going strong They have stripped the old wooden floor, wow does it look fantastic And much brighter inside .They have added an outdoor dining area And new central air. The pizza was as expected Sauced and topped to the edges With a perfect crispy crust, Price was real reasonable, Service was exceptional“

“You might not know this if you're local, but ohio pizza is no good. However if you're from one of those pretentious pizza cities/nj, you'll be happy you stopped here. This place is way better than it has any right to be, based on geography, and proves that it's not "the water" that makes the pizza good, but the people. God bless the pizza people in Elmore Ohio.The pizza place is open earlier than the bistro. When my girlfriend and I were there, there were literally 10 or so people just milling about outside like extras waiting for the pizza scene to start. It was the strangest thing I've ever seen. But in this town, there is nothing more important than the pizza apparently. Until they get to sit down and order food, they just mill about like npcs.“

“Our cheese bites, were cold. The pizza was gross ?, it always was not even hot all the way through. The dough was gooey and uncooked. ?The sauce was all watering and dripping of the crust...?and the server never once came back ? to our table to ask us if everything was OK!! NOT, great service, coming from a server. She was nice, tho! We definitely, won't be going back!“

“Marcos pizza messed up our order. Did not replace what they messed up. Our pizza was cold. We had no ranch with our cheesy bread and when we received our cinnamon bread, it had no icing on it. We had to wait for an hour to get our order after the time that they had told us. Very disappointing.“

“This is a small town pizzeria at its best. I though I would try it. Due to the pandemic, there is no seating available, just carryout. I ordered a small pizza with sausage and an Italian sub. The pizza was cooked to perfection and it was delicious. The sub was OK and for me it could have been cooked longer. The prices are reasonable and the staff friendly. It is small inside and probable only seating for 16 (I'm guessing). I will be back on my next time through!!! It's definitely in my top 5 pizza places!!!“

“Been a frequent flyer for years. Wholesome and fun staff! Food is always great and is exactly what we love to eat after a long week. Pizza is their staple but their subs are my favorite! Not having current seating inside but when it was available the staff were a hoot to be with and the seating was very home-like. Small town dining with a heart of gold.“

“Local favorite! Great for when we need a late night meal! Staff is always friendly and is accommodating to any allergen issues. Quick service and are always willing to make to order. Quite an experience! You're able watch the employees make the food, giving the restaurant a great vibe.“