Custom Cakes near Grove City, OH

Capital City Cakes Bakery • $$
4009 Broadway Grove City, Grove City

“We love CCC! Sue is the best. Their cakes are wonderful! We had Capital City make our wedding cake, and have enjoyed using them for special occasions ever since then. This was a cake Sue made for my husband’s 40th yesterday. Everyone raved about it!“

3.9 Good28 Reviews
Cold Stone Creamery Ice Cream Shop • $$
1776 Stringtown Rd, Grove City

Customers` Favorites

Ice Cream Cookie Build Your Own 4-Pack

“Fans with the recessed lights could cause issues for those susceptible to seizures. But the ladies behind the counter are on the ball, respectful, and efficient at their craft. As always the ice cream is great, can’t really screw that up I guess.Kid-friendliness: Is ice cream that has candy mixed into it, what kid wouldn’t want that?“

2.5 Average19 Reviews
Three Bites Bakery Bakery • $
999 Mt Vernon Ave, Columbus - 8.82 miles

Customers` Favorites

Brown Butter Sage Sweet Potato Galette
Slice of Italian Lemon & Almond Cake
Mushroom Artichoke & Leek Croissant
Mushroom Artichoke Hot Oil Pizzette
Mexican Hot Chocolate Cookies
Ube Pandesal with Cheese
Polenta Mushroom Sandwich
Italian Anise Cookies
Chinese Pineapple Bun
Slice of Coffee Cake

“We’ve been going to Isa for a while, so when we started planning our wedding, she was honestly our first and only choice. Yes, her pastries are out of this world and I could wax poetic on them - specifically the sweet potato one, look if you know you know - but this review is for the absolute masterpiece of a wedding cake that she put together for us. Because we’re long standing customers, we actually ended up doing both the spring/summer and the fall/winter tasting boxes. There is no wrong answer here, every single cake she makes is delicious, but we ended up going with the pretty traditional almond raspberry with the raspberry jam. It’s sweet, it’s decadent, and it was a huge hit with our guests. And god, just look at it! So beautiful! 100% worth it, choose Isa and Three Bites for all your pastry and cake needs!“

5 Superb53 Reviews
The Cakehound Bakery • $$
1147 Jaeger St, Columbus - 6.73 miles

“I can't say enough great things about The Cakehound! My dog was the ring bearer in my wedding so we had a special cake made for him for the big day. Not only was it GORGEOUS and matched our theme but Teresa also catered the ingredients to suit my sensitive dog's dietary requirements. I don't know how she managed to make a raw-incorporated cake look so beautiful but she did it! He went absolutely bonkers for the cake and it added a fun, special touch that all of our guests loved. I highly recommend stopping in to check the shop out! From the overall aesthetic, ADORABLE baked goods and other items, to the fun events, there's something there for every dog/dog lover. It is my go-to place for goodies for all of the pups in my life!“

5 Superb29 Reviews
Kuro Neko Cake Studio Custom Cakes • $$$
1660 Northwest Blvd, Columbus - 8.15 miles

“Deborah Li is not only an artist but an actual wizard, and Kuro Neko Cake Studio is her tower of magic. My wife and I were lucky enough to commission a cake from Kuro Neko for our wedding, and it turned out that one of the best parts of the whole reception was telling people that, yes, it really is cake! (I'm still not sure that my wife's grandma believes us.) When we asked for a book cake, we knew it would be beautiful, but upon seeing it the morning of, we were absolutely blown away. The colors, the sculpting, and how it all fit together as a piece of art left us without words. And, somehow, it tasted as good as it looked. As for the process, Deborah was wonderful to work with: attentive, keen to get the personal details just right, and fantastically friendly and supportive. Thanks in no small part to her artistry and amazing work, our wedding day was completely magical!“

5 Superb10 Reviews
Kennedy's Kakes Custom Cakes • $
310 S High St, Columbus - 7.17 miles

Customers` Favorites

Wedding Cake

“Ordered cake and cupcakes for our wedding reception. They were DELICIOUS. We got earl grey with lemon curd along with white almond raspberry and both were so good! Earl grey is a must try! And the icing on the cake (pun intended) is that Adrian is a sweetheart.“

4.3 Superb35 Reviews
J's Sweet Treats and Wedding Cakes Bakery
400 N High St, Columbus - 7.91 miles

“I called with less than a week notice needing a birthday cake last minute for ours sons Mario themed birthday. They were able to not only accommodate the order, but the cake was beautiful and just like the photos I had sent. On top of that it tasted amazing - the cake was super moist and icing was delicious. This was our first order, but will be our go to for party cakes going forward. Thank you!“

4 Good40 Reviews