50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Hinckley

“Good food, great staff and friendly patrons !!!!“

“Going to Mimi’s Pizza was a wonderful experience. We were greeted immediately and were assisted in making our order exactly what we wanted. Mimi and her team were patient, professional, and helpful. We were even offered a free portion of roast beef which was well prepared. Overall, our stromboli and NY slice were delicious when paired with the house sauce. Everything was homemade with fresh ingredients. We will be coming back again soon! Yummm 😋 Thank You for being nice and kind to us! ❤️“

“Best pizza I recommend the Jimmy Hoffa“

“Amazing, quality food. Creative, seasonal selections.“

“Best pizza around …Love the Honest Abe Forma & Peppy Pig ! Sabrina always does a great job!“

“These guys knock it out of the park when it comes to pizza! The Neapolitan crust is so good and how often do you order mushrooms and find the real deal, fresh and not water logged canned? Yep, they take it to the next level. It’s a great pie!“

“was in the area and was told by a friend the pizza here was very good. I can confirm that it is.“

“Been craving pizza (9 months pregnant). Ohio pie is always the answer. Went in today pizza is always 10/10 and customer service is always amazing. Got to meet Chris today at the Parma store and he was amazing. Ohio pie has forever ruined any other pizza for me. 100% worth it!“

“First time for drive thru pizza! Will be back!“

“I have been looking for quality NY style pizza in summit county for a long time and I have finally found it at Big Star. Big Star has some of the best pizza in summit county. If you want legit NY style pizza, this is it. The owner is incredibly nice and friendly. 10/10 pizza and service. Give them your business!!!“

“They checked all the boxes of the perfect nostalgic pizza shop! From the minute we walked in, they greeted us and were so friendly! We felt so welcome, and our server Heather and Mrs. Farinacci were so nice to talk to and were so friendly with our toddler! The pizza was delicious, especially the perfectly crispy crust; they accommodated my dairy allergy much better than most places, which I very much appreciate!
We have ordered from there in the past, but we will definitely be dining in more!“

“The Pint and Pie Works is a great casual place to eat. The pizza's and cocktails are amazing. The servers and owners are really nice people. Highly recommended!“

“Delicious pizza! We have been going to Deweys since their location opened in Cleveland Heights. Since we now live closer to the Fairlawn location, we eat here.

The family LOVES the Edgar Allen Poe, Southwest BBQ no salsa or peppers, Pepperoni, Caprice but will be adding pancetta next time and Porky Fig! The caesar salad too! Always great food. Highly recommend!“

“First time old fashioned place
..good pie somewhat like a Sicilian... Somewhat like a Brooklyn pie and a little characteristic of old Forge style.. I would definitely ask for lighter on the cheese next time but we will be back next time we are in town...“

“Very good pizza and good service“

“We ordered Chicken, pizza, coleslaw, pasta salad and garden salad for our family reunion on July 16th. There were 75 people. I talked to Julianne and she helped me with ordering the proper amount of food. We did have a few leftovers, however, there was no problem with people taking it home! It was delivered to the hall and was hot and delicious! Everyone loved the chicken! My favorite side was the bow tie pasta salad! The kids loved the pizza and the green salad and coleslaw rounded out the meal! We will order again from Mama Julianne’s!“

“It’s always the small family owned spots that make the best pizza. This is my favorite spot around strongsville and I’ve never had a bad experience. Highly recommend.“

“Tried here the first time. If you're in a hurry to order be prepared to be put on hold for a couple minutes. Pizza was good, but a little greasy. Garlic bread was definitely not worth the price for a toasted footlong sub bun with cheese and garlic.“

“great food. Janice is the greatest waitress. she friendly and efficient.“

“Love the pizza !!“

“This is one of two places in the county that we will buy from. I grew up in NY and am a self proclaimed pizza snob. You can’t beat a Capri pie. It’s the closest to NY style pizza in NEO.“

“Godmother's is always good, but tonight it's great!! I have to stop myself from eating the whole thing! 😋🍕😋“

“Always enjoy it there, good food and our service tonight was great“

“My kids took us to dinner here last night for my birthday. What a great restaurant! There were 11 of us! Our server, Gina, was so friendly, efficient, and helpful! The food was excellent too!“

“Every pizza place has their bad and good days, usually depending on who makes the pizza. Usually really good here. But, I recently ordered a cheese steak because I was the only one that didn't want pizza. What a let down. Dry beef, wondering where the rest was and a floury taste. Bread was really good thankfully. But very little meat. If I could add the picture i would.“

“My family loves Toni’s Pizza! 🍕🫶🏻“

“Hats off to Justin at East of Chicago!! We work here at an apartment complex & were in a pinch for some last minute pizzas. We called & Justin was able to make it happen for us, while also being the only worker in the shop at the time!“

“Thank you driver Dave for the cookies 🐶 and the delicious pizza!! Quick delivery, great service and a really nice delivery guy! 🍕“

“Great food and large portions.“

“Love the Peppadew Punch!!! Your lunch specials are great too!“

“Words cannot accurately explain how great our experience was tonight! I decided to celebrate my mom’s 78th birthday here due to the fact my mom loves Antonio’s pepperoni nuggets and she’s never been here before. We had 14 people in our party and Megan K. was an absolute rockstar! Everyone was so welcoming and gracious to my mom on her special day! Food was FANTASTIC!! Thank you all for a wonderful evening!“

“Deep dish pizza deserves a good hearty crunch; complimenting its soft dough bed covered with sheets of sweet and tangy pizza sauce. Its the perfect balance of that big chain size and convience, while maintaining that grungy greasy mom and pop hole in the wall realness.“

“Best food! Great food, great pizza, chicken parmesan dinner, c’mon!“

“We loved it! they've had a couple NEW owners in the past couple years. THESE NEW OWNERS ARE GREAT, PERSONABLE, EFFICENT AND THE FOOD IS GREAT. THEY HAVE A NICE LIQUOR SELECTION AS WELL“

“They provided us lunch today at Valley College. Very good pasta, pizza and salad! I will definitely order from here soon. Thank you!“

“I ordered a house garden salad but received otherwise. Pizza was crisp and golden.“

“Best sheet pizza ever ! Its even better in the morning for breakfast !“

“Thanks to my husband discovering this gem of a pizza joint I can’t help but want their delicious food about once a week. I love their BBQ chicken pizza and garlic Parmesan wings, but everything else we’ve tried has been just as delicious! Double edged sword bc I found the best place around, but I’m wanting to eat it all the time. Must try!!“

“Jasmine was a sweet pea and so nice when I called also with a awesome attitude when I arrived!! She deserves a day off or lunch and not pizza 🍕😉“

“I have no idea why so many people say bad things about this place. I've been going there for the last year or so and have absolutely zero complaints. The food prices are more than reasonable, the food quality is very good and I've never had one single issue with any aspect. People need to stop looking for perfection as they define it.“

“Big shout out to the manager Chris for fixing my order tonight. Def will be ordering again soon. Thanks guys“

“First time eating Romeo’s pizza. Our family was here from Indiana so we ordered 2 one topping extra large and 1 one topping large pizzas with extra sauce. The sauce was delicious. Pizzas were great. Julie was so nice to talk with. Thank you! God bless you!“

“Don't miss dining at Vaccaro's Trattoria, it's a gem! The service is spot on, the meal is true Italian, and the total dining experience is well worth the drive from anywhere. We really enjoyed having a meal in a restaurant that gets it when it comes to the background music, smooth, soft jazz, very relaxing, perfect volume level. Look no further than Vaccaro's when you're craving real Italian cuisine.“

“I don't typically review pizza providers because... it's pizza.

Having said that...

First time ordering from the Great American Pizza Company...

I knew from the moment I opened the box that this was going to be *amazing*!

Great job!“

“I just picked up a Detroit style eight cut and and side salad. I guess it’s a large pepperoni sausage. Excellent Dan makes a good pizza. This was Broadview Heights, Ohio location Broadview Road and West Sprague.“

“Niko’s Gyros is my go-to spot when I’m craving something quick and delicious! It’s a takeout-only place, which makes it super convenient to call ahead and grab on my way home.

The gyros and fries are always fresh and hot - exactly what you want every time. I also appreciate that my order is always ready right when they say it will be.“

“Slowly becoming a once a week customer for the chicken and jojo's. Evrytime I've come here the chicken and jojo's are freshly cooked and always delicious. Staff is always very professional and helpful when need be.
Two thumbs up on the Gionino bread as well!!! Keep up the great food and great work!“

“I grew up in Detroit with some of the best deep dish pizza known to man. Better than Chicago or New York style pizza (in my opinion). Antonio's 216 pizza is the closest you'll get to Detroit Style Pizza here in Cleveland. The 216 is the real deal! I've had their other pizzas, and they're all great, but the 216 is my favorite. Antonio's is by far the best pizza in Cleveland.“

“Our favorite dinner spot ..the salmon sandwich, chicken sandwich and chicken salad melt are our first choices. All their soups.. and Irish Stout is excellent too.“