50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Independence

“I had Cavatalli with homemade meat sauce. Fresh baked roll, to dip in my sauce, salad. My husband had a meatball sub that was amazing. If you’re in the area this is the only place you need to go. Servers were friendly and personable.

Vegetarian options: Deep fried veggies option.

Parking: We parked at Ace Hardware they have a large parking lot.“

“Love the pizza by the slice for a quick bite for lunch if you're at work, but for me, the real star is the pasta. Their Rigatoni and Alfredo pasta are both amazing and have made me a regular at this restraunt. This is the perfect example of a mom and pop shop, "Hole in the Wall," that more people need to know about.“

“Great service and a delicious breakfast!“

“Had a delicious meal with my family of six. The pizza was excellent, meat lovers did not disappoint! The wings we tried were garlic and Parmesan, baked nit fried tender and juicy. The manager “Amanda” did a fantastic job. I highly recommend giving this place a try. We were informed they have a new owner!“

“Explored the creative cocktail menu and everything was excellent. Service was attentive.“

“Tried Valley Pizza for the first time tonight.Supreme Pizza. Wow.reminds me of the neat little mom and pop Pizza parlors from back it the day 1970s.Lots of flavor, even the dough tastes good.cant wait to try the other sauces.Very well done.Ill be back soon.“

“The Best Pizza This side of NYC!!!“

“I enjoyed a salad, pizza and half a carafe of white Zinfandel. Excellent food with a delightful waitress named Lexie.“

“You’ve seen the Facebook reviews! You’ve heard the buzz the rumors! You’ve talked to people who have tried and raved!! Get off your butt and get in line!
Absolutely amazing pizza done with passion, intent and true skill that only comes from a master of their craft. Upon entering the small, clean and purposeful shop the aroma of fresh ingredients and flour dusted surfaces will have you under its spell. It’s obvious the place means business. Options for pizza toppings are not as limited as the hours but after the first bite you will be a believer. Conversations with the owner/Pizzolo while we waited and preformed his dough magic transported us right to the city of Naples. His knowledge and stories made our 15 minute wait seem like an only a few seconds. Not being able to decide we ended up getting two pies and we’re glad we did! Crisp thin crusts with those dark “leopard spots”, perfectly balanced sauce and low moisture cheese ratio with just the right amount of toppings including basil picked fresh from the plant. This type of pizza might not be for everyone but it’s definitely a contender for Cleveland’s best. Very demure, very mindful.

Vegetarian options: Load up the veg and skip the cheese

Dietary restrictions: Ask and he will accommodate.

Parking: Few spots right up front

Kid-friendliness: Keep the kiddos at home. Small shop

Wheelchair accessibility: Yep“

“I am a seriously picky person when it comes to pizza. I absolutely love Napoleons. I have Never in 7 yrs had a bad pie from this place. when I order extra cheese you get Extra for sure. I Love it.“

“was in the area and was told by a friend the pizza here was very good. I can confirm that it is.“

“really good pizza( not super greasy) good salad! very cute inside will definitely be back“

“This is the best pizza in Cleveland. I've tried many pizza places in Cleveland and this is the best so far. Quality ingredients, excellent dough, perfect cooking time. Service was excellent. I went with my six-year old daughter and they prepared a kid-friendly cocktail for her. She enjoyed the food and experience. I did too. Highly recommended if you like quality food and cocktails.“

“Best pizza in Cleveland, and one of the few that sells by the slice.“

“I love everything about this place been eating their pizza for almost 40 years now and think they are the best overall pizza place probably in Ohio“

“Best pizza in town!“

“AMAZING pizza and sandwiches, walking distance from my house. What could be better!!! I've had an Italian mixed meat deli sandwich, the bread was amazing and the sandwich was huge. Definitely two meals worth. The pizza is pillowy, Sicilian style, and they use the cup-and-char pepperoni. So happy that this new market is open!!!“

“My mom used to order from here when I was growing up. I have always been in love with this place! Especially the chicken gyros! Haven’t been in Ohio for about 5 years, my family and I decided to satisfy our cravings and I’m so glad we did! I love seeing Pizza Joes and Deli still holding on strong! Staff is great! Food is great! Super clean and cute inside as well!“

“First time for drive thru pizza! Will be back!“

“Upon entry you can tell that the interior decorator has no boundaries. There isn't an inch of wall space not covered by some form of Italian photos newspaper clippings magazines flags and other cool memorabilia. You could spend a whole day looking at all the unique and Italian fanfare. The pizza was magnificent The staff was friendly and the bathroom was clean. Definitely tried this pizza if you're in the area.“

“I have worked in the Garfield Hts area for almost 8 years now and anytime I think of having pizza for lunch or dinner, I think of East Coast Pizza. Their pies are always hot with fresh ingredients. Delivery service is great however, if I order pickup the parking has never been an issue. My staff and ladies at the group home love them.“

“Awesome pizza!! And their salad is also very good with their homemade italian dressing. We go quite often to the Brecksville or Northfield location. When I brought my grandkids they said it was the best pizza they ever had. Highly recommended!!!“

“Great service great pizza and amazing salad. Only thing I would change is for the salad they just gave us bagged newmans own dressing. A homemade itialian dressing would have made this a 10 out of 10 5 star review. Hopefully they consider a from scratch dressing in the future.“

“Myself and family tried the pizza and wings for the first time very delicious! highly recommend and the staff are friendly and helpful!“

“10 out of 10 pizza, recommend NYC style“

“great food. nice environment. drive thru window for carryout is very nice. service and everyone who works here are always amazing“

“We ordered delivery for the first time here. We ordered a chicken bacon ranch and cheeseburger pizza, along with some broasted chicken.

The chicken bacon ranch wasn't what I was expecting, but that wasn't a bad thing. The cheeseburger pizza was phenomenal and I will be ordering that from now on.

The family loved the broasted chicken and will definitely order it in the future for family gatherings.

I'd recommend giving them a try. The employee who answered the phone was very nice (even when my phone started losing connection) and the delivery time was reasonable for the day and time we ordered. The food was hot and fresh, tasted great, and had been added to my rotation of pizza joints in the Parma area.“

“We order carry out probably once every two weeks. The portions have diminished. The food is still very good, service is excellent and love the decor. We couldn’t believe the smaller portions for what we pay. We used to get 3 stuffed Hungarian peppers, now 2 small ones for the same price. The children’s portions are also smaller. Please go back to servings portions about a month ago??“

“Dewey’s Pizza is a fantastic spot that captures the essence of creative, flavorful pizza in a fun and casual atmosphere. Known for its diverse menu and fresh ingredients, Dewey’s is the go-to place for pizza lovers looking for something a bit different.

One of the standout features of Dewey’s is their seasonal pizzas, and our absolute favorite has to be the Tito Santana—a taco-inspired pizza that never fails to impress. This unique offering perfectly combines the comforting elements of pizza with the bold flavors of tacos, creating a delightful fusion that keeps us coming back for more.

The Tito Santana pizza is a masterpiece, featuring a perfectly baked crust that is both crispy and chewy. Topped with seasoned ground beef, fresh lettuce, diced tomatoes, and a sprinkle of cheddar cheese, it delivers all the flavors you’d expect from a classic taco. The addition of zesty salsa and a drizzle of creamy ranch dressing elevates the pizza even further, tying all the flavors together in a way that is truly satisfying.

What we love most about Dewey’s is their commitment to quality ingredients. The freshness of the toppings shines through in every bite, making each pizza not just a meal but a flavorful experience. The seasonal nature of the Tito Santana means it's available for a limited time, which adds to its allure and makes it all the more special whenever we get the chance to enjoy it.

The ambiance at Dewey’s is welcoming and lively, making it a great place to gather with friends or family. The staff is always friendly and attentive, ensuring that our dining experience is enjoyable from start to finish. Whether dining in or taking out, we appreciate the consistent quality of service.

In addition to the Tito Santana, Dewey’s offers a wide variety of other pizzas and salads, catering to all tastes and preferences. Their ability to customize pizzas means that anyone can find something to love, whether it’s a classic margherita or a more adventurous creation.

In conclusion, Dewey’s Pizza is a must-visit for anyone craving delicious, innovative pizza. The Tito Santana seasonal pizza is a true standout, combining the best of taco flavors with the beloved pizza experience. With its fresh ingredients, inviting atmosphere, and friendly service, Dewey’s has become one of our favorite spots, and we can’t wait to return for another slice of that taco pizza magic!“

“After searching for good pizza in Cleveland for a decade, I finally found The Tomato Company <3 Easily the best pizza in the area!“

“A true Mom and Pop pizza shop. You walk in and it instantly gives off that vibe, that you know the food is about to be hitting differently. Just pick up an order and see for yourself. I'm happy to have discovered this place while walking, I never would've known about it otherwise, as it's basically hidden on Pearl Rd. You won't be disappointed, try a pie from this local gem.“

“The owner at Papa Nick's went above and beyond for hospitality, going as far as hunting down a high chair for our baby to use. The food was fantastic and satisfying, we will be eating here any time we find ourselves in the Cleveland area.“

“I want to thank the crew at City Slice for helping me throw the best pizza party ever! From the booking process to hosting they were nothing short of amazing, the food was perfect (as always) and the kids had a ton of fun. Thank you guys once again!“

“Wow!!! We just left Danny Boys. We had the pleasure of Maria being our server! She blew my socks off!! Wow, just wow. Talk about customer service. Her personality was so welcoming and warm and genuine. The way she slyly grabbed straw wrappers off the table when she set the garlic bread down (which was an amazing recommendation) did not go unnoticed. I’d give Maria 100 stars if I could. Thank you so much! Our food was excellent and such a great experience and great place. We will definitely be back!!!“

“Simply the best pizza I've ever had. Superior toppings, great crust and consistent excellence for decades now. I find it unreasonable for me to go anywhere else.“

“Parking: Very nice parking lot also free i always find a parking spot.

Kid-friendliness: They are very friendly with kids very nice down to heart people. Best pizza in all of Cleveland I drove here all the way from Pittsburgh just to try it and i am very satisfied“

“chef Gav flings the doh, my tummy it doth grow“

“Came here from the East side to surprise my husband . He loves Italian Deli. Tripi did not disappoint. Friendly service as soon as we walked in, great food and a cute dinning area. We had the Papa Tony, Pasta dinner with meatballs and the Wedding soup. All delicious! Our favorite was the Papa Tony.“

“By far the best pizza I’ve ever had with great service.“

“This was our first dinner on our trip to Cleveland and it was perfect! We had two pizzas, a salad, wings, fries, and a giant cookie. Everyone there was so nice and helpful!! The food was fantastic and the pizza was even good the next morning (cold for breakfast).“

“When they actually get your order right it’s good food. The problem is that they screw up the orders too often. It doesn’t matter if you order online or over the phone, what you ask for and pay for is not what’s in the box. They either drown the wings because you ask for extra sauce (to the point where the box can’t hold the sauce & it’s spilling out) or the wings are bone dry. The last order I placed was for a white pizza with chicken and bacon, I got a white pizza with banana peppers, tomatoes, black olives and bacon… NOT the same!
It’s frustrating because the food IS good :(“

“amazing food! everyone in our party of 10 loved everything we ordered from pizza to soups to salads to chicken parm!“

“I picked up from the University Hts location. Super clean, fast, friendly and great pizza. So many options. Our new favorite!“

“Great Pizza!!! Really neat to watch it cook.“

“Good Pizza but I would reccommend calling in to place your order and asking about what's on each pizza you want. Never in all my years have I ordered a veggie pizza where the veggies were carrots, broccoli, and Zucchini. It's not your traditional veggie with Red and Green Peppers, Black Olives Banana Peppers and onions“

“Holy cow so good ? ?
Got a thin crust pepperoni pizza with extra cheese and a BBQ chicken pizza with veggies and I am not disappointed! Will definitely make this a regular cause baaabaaay it's the best pizza I have had so far since being in ohio. The delivery guy was really nice and delivered with care. Thanks you guys for a great dinner.“

“I had just gotten into Cleveland at 10 at night and was famished. We stopped and got us a pie. Omg I'm in love. Fabio is the best!! While we waited, he gave us 2 meatballs and let me tell you, they just melt in your mouth they are that good!! Recommended 200%“

“Thanks to my husband discovering this gem of a pizza joint I can’t help but want their delicious food about once a week. I love their BBQ chicken pizza and garlic Parmesan wings, but everything else we’ve tried has been just as delicious! Double edged sword bc I found the best place around, but I’m wanting to eat it all the time. Must try!!“

“best dinners since Augustinos in Brooklyn,oh where standard was veal parmesan and bottle of wine,no menu needed!! lol“

“The cheese pizza was good for the price of only $12.01 for a extra large pizza and it had plenty of cheese on it but if you like lots of sauce then I would order it with extra sauce on it but anyway this pizza place has got my approval and trust me I am a pizza person and if the pizza was bad I would tell you the truth but this place for the money you can't beat it and the staff working there are really nice people“