14 Best Pizza Restaurants near Holmesville

“We are staying in the area for a quick little getaway. They were really close so we decided to give them a try. They were friendly from the phone call to order to when my husband went inside to pick up our order. They even welcomed him and held the door open for him when he went in. We ordered pizza subs. They were hot and cooked perfectly. They were pretty messy to eat. That’s just an us thing. We don’t really like messy sandwiches. The pizza sauce was a little sweet for us as well. They have a really great menu selection and priced reasonably too! I’m looking forward to trying the chicken wings and salad! That will probably be tonight’s dinner. Overall I say definitely give them a try!“

“Unique and fresh options! Wonderful staff! We had the Caprese Pizza and Cheesy Garlic bread, and they were both fantastic! When we travel... these are the amazing local gems we love to find! Thanks to all the great reviews that led us to it... we couldn't agree more! Yum!“

“We were in town and wanted something different than Amish style cooking. Excellent pizza, loads of toppings and the crust was crispy and delicious!!So many options to choose from, it makes it difficult to narrow down what you want.It doesn't matter, whatever you get it's going to be delicious!!“

“The place is new and clean and looks great. Service is friendly. The pizza is one of the best in Amish country. They also have chicken sandwich which is great. Plus try the hamburger, it's really actually one of the best things on the menu.“

“Pizzas from the Apple Creek drive through are downright delicious. They're always correctly made and their quoted times are pretty accurate.Only issue I ever have is they are pretty busy so often the wait is well over half an hour. Totally worth the wait; just remember to order with a longer wait in mind!“

“I’ve been going here for years and I have never had a bad experience. Everything I go here the pizza is always incredible and the soft serve ice cream has 24 flavors. The service is usually ok but sometimes are better then others. If your ever in Amish county make sure to stop in here.“

“Got lost in Amish country so stopped to ask directions and decided to stay for lunch. Glad we did. We ordered a mini pizza and it came topped with so many ingredients it filled us up. We also had onion rings. Just the way we like them. Friendly service including the owner.“

“At Pizza Parlour, a feast so grand,Ten large pizzas, a culinary plan.Right on time, they stood in line,Delicious delight, flavors so divine.Crispy crust, a symphony of taste,Not a hint of grease, no time to waste.A gathering's joy, a treat for the crew,Pizza Parlour, a gem we found, it's true.With gratitude we sing, a savory song,In the world of pizza, they truly belong.To friends, we'll recommend with glee,Pizza Parlour, where delight runs free.“

“Buffet was clean and well stocked. We asked, and they made pizza to order and placed it on the buffet and let us know it was there. Staff was attentive and friendly. Dining room was clean but very cold. We ate with our coats on. This in not the norm, just this time.“

“I live down the street from here and love it when we decide to go for pizza while these guys are open. Their pizza is phenomenal, and the owners are the sweetest. The handmade ice cream sandwiches are also amazing. This place is a true gem!“

“Just tried out the Brisket Sandwhich. The meat is done the way it should be. The jalapeños seem to be fresh and crisp. There is the right amount of ingredients on the sandwich and the sauce works well with the brisket. Great sandwich and I'm ready to try something else In the future.“

“Delicious! Recommend the pan crust. Fresh, crispy, soft, and delightful. Great Service too! Ohhhh yea can't forget the ole chicken bacon ranch sub either if ya haven't purchased any of these two.. you are truly missing out! One other great part is super freaky fast service! 🍕 🚗💨 💨💨“

“Although we ordered greasy foods, there was NOT a greasy mess. Our food was cooked perfectly! Our waitress was really nice and we were happy about how often she checked to see how we were doing or if we needed anything. Would 10/10 recommend!“

“My husband and I stopped in town for a few days and we hadn't had a pizza buffet in ages. This one didn't disappoint. It was only 10 dollars per person and the pizza was really tasty. The taco pizza was my favorite. 5 stars. I wish I lived here so I could have this all the time.“