“Pizza was hot and fresh when we picked it up. Everything was made exactly the way we customized it. Pickup person was very fast and friendly. Pizza tasted like it did in the old days. Buttery crust, back to the sweet sauce. Love it! All pizzas were devoured.“
“Ordered pizza and cheesy garlic bread last night and it was so GOOD! We probably order from the Orrville location once every other month and have literally never had a bad experience. Our order is always correct, ready for pick-up at the time we are given and it is consistently hot. The employees are friendly and professional. Thanks Orrville East of Chicago!!“
“I really like the hand made pan crust for a pizza. The rewards program isn't all that bad either. Employees there are polite. I have not had any incorrect orders made online, phone, or had any problems with pick up, curb, or delivery service.“
“- Despite the young service crowd, they seem very proficient, EXTREMELY kind, and produce great pizza.- The crust is awesome. I order a custom pizza each time and never have had an issue of anything missing. I also do pick up each time.- Turn-around times for pizza are quick, usually 20 minutes and they are very on-the-ball for any style of delay.- Prices are very fair- Read a few negative reviews, I personally have not had those experiences. I love this pizza place.“
“We're from Texas, I drive OTR and we took our break this weekend in Wooster. As outdoor enthusiasts, who can't make a place called Ugly Duck a first stop? It is outstanding on all levels. We will probably be back this afternoon. The people, both staff and customers, as well as the atmosphere almost make me want to move here.“
“Great 1st experience..Was recommended by friend,didnt disappoint.. Get the chips with their homemade dip,awesome. The pizza was sooo good. They bring you a 'shaker' of their special spicy seasoning to put on pizza...defibetly try it. We bought some to bring home,it's that good. Hubby enjoyed the beers,great selection. This place is a hidden gem... but folks find it,they do a great business“
“Pizzas from the Apple Creek drive through are downright delicious. They're always correctly made and their quoted times are pretty accurate.Only issue I ever have is they are pretty busy so often the wait is well over half an hour. Totally worth the wait; just remember to order with a longer wait in mind!“
“We've been in this area for 1 and a half years and this is, hands down, the best pizza we've found! We didn't care for the white pizza sauce but the red is perfect. Good prices, accurate orders, friendly workers, and the perfect pie. What more could you want? We'll be trying other meni items in the future.“
“My favorite buffet in Wooster. The buffet will be $13.38/person and includes fountain drinks. It's a little cheaper if you pay with cash. Great Pizza and they do a different extra every day. You can call to find out what is on the buffet. Fish ? are on Fridays. Boneless Chicken Wings ? on Thursdays.“
“I love to stop by when I come through town. This establishment is a town classic rhat serves fantastic pizza: sauce that has the perfect hint of sweetness paired with an amazingly flavorful crust. The texture is perfect and the cheese has a wonderful flavor, it doesn't taste processed like chain pizza. Their jojo potatoes are crispy on the outside and melt-in-your-mouth soft on the inside. Their prices are also fantastic! I recommend pairing their food with a specialty soda from Lehmans (I chose an Almond soda!), and then finishing it up with one of their ice cream cones.“
“Picked up a pizza to take to Silver Creek and enjoy by the lake for dinner. Crust was crispy and not too thick with good flavor. Sauce was a little sweet and a little savory, with a great selection of toppings. Would definitely go again when in the area!Parking: Decent availability of street parking to quickly pick up orders“
“Employees are very nice, and make you feel you matter as a customer. Any time I experienced an "issue" they were quick to correct it and make it right. One of my pizza's came out burnt once and they put a new one in, they noticed it before giving it to me.“
“I have ordered pizza, chicken and JoJo's loved pizza and the chicken is delish! JoJo's are good but wish they would cut a bit thicker and batter them a bit more but they are great! Chicken comes golden brown, it seems they change their oil more often then some of these other places here in town.. Thw parking isn't great.. but you can always park on the side of the building and the lady and gentlemen that work the pick up are so kind! Keep up the great service..“