22 Best Pizza Restaurants near Rittman

“We've been in this area for 1 and a half years and this is, hands down, the best pizza we've found! We didn't care for the white pizza sauce but the red is perfect. Good prices, accurate orders, friendly workers, and the perfect pie. What more could you want? We'll be trying other meni items in the future.“

“The pizza is very delicious, and the staff is very nice!!“

“Employees are very nice, and make you feel you matter as a customer. Any time I experienced an "issue" they were quick to correct it and make it right. One of my pizza's came out burnt once and they put a new one in, they noticed it before giving it to me.“

“i like their loaded crust over stuffed crust at pizza hut. but my last order is making me leery about ordering again. i ordered extra pepperoni and extra cheese. it was pouring rain when i picked it up and didn't check it, i should of, when i got home, was very disappointed. we were hungry, so instead of going back thru the rain we just ate it.“

“We had an excellent celebration for my son and future daughter-in-law's lunch rehearsal the day before their wedding. Everyone enjoyed the atmosphere along with the delicious pizza and salads; the service was exceptional. Thank you especially to Sarah and Grant. No doubt it is one of our favorite places.What a blessing! We truly especially the pickle pizza!! 5 star!“

“First time ordering from Big Star thanks to a pizza group I’m in on FB. Expansive menu including pastas, salads, burgers yes burgers, some Greek options and other Italian options. I can’t wait to order from here again. The person taking my order was super friendly. Pizza came out amazing. Ordered the New York style with all veggies and a side of garlic dipping sauce. Also Not greasy either. Crispy and balanced. So so yummy. Ordered the breaded mixed veggies as well. Delish breading. Recommend.“

“We were gifted a meal from a family member who lives out of town and she read the reviews and order us a wonderful delicious meal of chicken Alfredo sausage peppers onion's and pasta, spaghetti and meatballs, pasta, breadsticks, salad! We live in Wadsworth and hadn’t heard of this place well I will tell you their food is amazing! I loved it very tasteful! I have found a new place to get a good meal from! Highly recommend this place!“

“Great food from great people. A staple of the community!“

“Definitely need more parking. Especially when you are part of a poker run“

“Amazing Pizza... carnivore w/ mushroom... we're pizza snobs, definitely on the top of our take out list now ..“

“Best chicken around . Fresh toss salad. Great staff. Makes my day. I have been ordering Fat Boy pizza since 2003. First time my son order. The owner sent our family chicken an jojo the day after my sons accident. Been with you for your kindness. Be a customer for life.“

“Best Pizza EVER“

“good place to eat“

“I have been there a few times and it never disappoints. The homemade lasagna is to die for . The spaghetti was the proper proportion and just wonderful in taste and texture. I have been there for a couple breakfast and everything was really good. I do also want to add about the atmosphere, and the people that work there they are funny attentive to our needs and pleasant to everybody. This is a must go to restaurant.“

“currently eating Tavanello's for the first time and I'm going to have to put it on my top 5 at least!!! great pizza!“

“Was in town for sons baseball game I was hungry got the pepperoni power house pizza ? and it honestly has to be in the top five pizzas I have ever had. It was very good I was very happy with it we'll definitely go back two thumbs up for sure ??????“

“If you’re craving a hearty pizza experience, East of Chicago in Seville, Ohio, is a must-try. They serve some of the best pies I’ve ever had from any pizza chain. Their deep-dish pizzas are particularly impressive, and they truly deliver a satisfying meal.

The classic offerings—pepperoni, sausage, and cheese—are outstanding. Each pie is generously topped with an even layer of cheese that melts beautifully, creating a perfect balance with the savory toppings. The dough is just right—not too doughy, not too dry—making for a delicious crust that holds everything together.

I did have one disappointing experience with their taco pizza. It was packed with an overwhelming amount of lettuce and sour cream, making it look unappetizing and far from what we expected. Unfortunately, it was so off-putting that we couldn’t bring ourselves to eat it. I felt bad for wasting a whole pizza, but I just couldn’t get past the sight and smell of it.

Despite that hiccup, East of Chicago has consistently impressed me with their deep-dish offerings. My wife often picks up our orders, and I’ve noticed that the pizza boxes are well-designed to keep the heat in and the food warm, with tightly sealed lids that ensure freshness.

One thing to keep in mind is that I’ve had some issues trying to place orders when they’re open, as there have been times when nobody answered the phone. While I understand that they might be busy restocking, it can be a bit frustrating.

Overall, I highly recommend trying the deep-dish pizza from East of Chicago. It stands out as one of the best in the area, and despite the minor setbacks, it’s definitely a pizza experience worth indulging in!“

“A wonderful establishment. The customer service was next level. I had a very long day at work and came in to order pizza late at night and this store treated me like I was family. The guy behind the counter was new, but he did his job very well, and served me with a smile. Would recommend. 10/10“

“Romeo's, you are my new favorite pizza place!! I've lived in this area over 20 years and had your pizza for the first time a couple of months ago at my son's house. Wow, I was stunned by how good the pizza was! You are now my go-to without question! I love the sweet sauce you use on your pizza. Yesterday, we ordered bone-in wings. When my hubby got home with them, we realized they were boneless. We were floored that they were not your normal dry, hard boneless wings! Will be ordering boneless again! Your sauce, I got barbecue, was delicious. Great little Gem we have in our small town! Thank you!!“

“Everyone is always super friendly in here, but my food is correct about 60% of the time. The issues are also typically huge deviations from the original order. The day shift drivers do not follow any directions that you leave for them. Night shift does great.“

“After ordering from there for 3 years, then working their for approximately four months, they take cleaning, cooking, preparing, pretty seriously, but while still being lenient on the workers to try to enjoy themselves. I've only ever had one bad order from them before working there but other than that, the food has always been great.“

“I had my wedding in orrville this past weekend. My hired caterer stood me up an hour before my guests were supposed to eat. They were able to make enough Pizza, chicken and JoJo's and salad to feed my guests last minute when we called in a panic. I cannot tell you how grateful I am for them to take on such a huge surprise order at the last minute. My guests said the food was delicious and we barely had any left! I can’t thank you enough Gionino's in Orrville for saving my day.“