13 Best American Restaurants near Kelleys Island

“OMG if you can get Hillary as your server you have struck the lottery!!! She’s quick and SO witty and she sings at times and is amazing!!! She’s the ONLY one you want!!!“

“The Island House staff is always awesome! Great food, drinks and atmosphere. Shout out to Erica - one of my favorite bartenders on the island. She and Joe (at the Caddy Shack) are the best!“

“Great. Ambience. Good Pizza. Excellent food truck.“

“I had lunch at the Goat today and not only was the food and service excellent, but the owner went out of his way to make sure our day trip ended on a high note. My bike got a flat tire and he insisted on hauling my bike and myself to the ferry. This 70 year old greatly appreciated his kindness and you can be sure we will support the Goat every time we visit the island.“

“Love the vibe at Crush. Good food and great drink selection.“

“Please put a hot turkey sandwich on the menu ! Love the roast beef version but turkey is the go too“

“This is a fantastic indoor restaurant with two bars and outside dining. The patio area is beautifully designed, offering a refreshing open-air experience. The real showstopper is the incredible outdoor area featuring a gorgeous pool with an entrancing waterfall. It creates an unbelievably relaxing ambiance. Whether you're looking for a lively night out, a peaceful escape, or simply a great meal in a beautiful setting, JF Walleyes delivers on all fronts.“

“I actually love the place. Unfortunately on our last visit we ordered prime rib which was without a doubt the worst I have ever had. I would think they'd be embarrassed to serve it and to charge $25 was robbery at its finest. Very disappointing from a place I typically enjoy.“

“Wonderful food, friendly people, quick service. Came to Middle Bass for a quick island stop to refuel and refresh after a day of boating, and couldn't have asked for a better experience. The people who work here are very friendly. The restaurant itself is simplistic and pleasant. The food was PHENOMENAL. The cheese bread (or whatever it was called, I can't quite remember) was delicious, simply superb. The pickle pizza was also delicious, these people have the brilliance of putting ruffles chips on top as well. Simply amazing, awesome, and will return again!“

“came up from perry county for a little summer fun and told my wife I was not leaving back to the hills till I had some type of seafood and this joint was on point! I had 2 lobster tails with potatoes as a side absolutely delicious also had a half pound of crab legs, my son had the steam pot and he loved it, my other son had pizza and shrimp and he loved the pizza and I ate the shrimp he was full from the pizza, my wife had the steam pot but brought it home and she tore it up when we walked in the door! highly recommend and loved being able to sit 5 feet from the lake! employees was the best and very helpful! check this place out you won't regret it!“

“Just spent an awesome day at Baypoint Resort & Marina and I’m already counting down until we’re back! Caught The Visitors playing at the tiki bar and they absolutely crushed it! Such a fun, high energy set. The whole vibe was immaculate, from the music to the water views, and the bartenders were on point. Seriously, we love everything about this place. Hoping The Visitors are back again soon because we’ll definitely be there! 🎶🍹“

“We finally tried their grinders and we were not disappointed. It was great and everything was fresh. We got the west coast turkey and the heavy Italian. Very nice staff, the chip selection was great. We will definitely return to try the other grinders and other menu items.“